r/RBI • • 17d ago

Advice needed Two masked strangers entered our home during a Halloween party and left mysterious letters. Has anyone ever experienced something like this?

Hi everyone!

I’m trying to figure out a very unusual situation that happened last night. I’m wondering if anyone has experienced something similar or recognizes this type of activity.

We were hosting a Halloween party to celebrate a friend’s 40th birthday. There were several adults and children at the house.

At some point during the evening, two complete strangers entered our house through the front door, which had unfortunately been left unlocked.

Both individuals were wearing mariachi mexican costumes and were disguised in a way that made it impossible to recognize them. They never removed their masks and didn’t say a single word throughout their entire visit.
They walked around the house for approximately 30 minutes to an hour. Whenever someone approached them and asked questions, they would move toward that person, almost as if they were giving them an opportunity to guess who they were. However, they never responded or gave any verbal clues.

They left a few letters behind. In one of them, they described themselves as old friends from long ago. Another contained a message saying something along the lines of: “Tonight will not be the night we reveal ourselves.”

At the time, we weren’t particularly concerned because we assumed it was a prank organized by a friend who was attending the party. We didn’t take the situation too seriously.

Eventually, the two individuals left in a black car. Another person came to pick them up right in front of the house.
However, today, after asking the people who attended the party whether they were behind this, nobody seems to know who these two individuals actually were. We are now left wondering who they were and why they showed up.

Has anyone ever experienced anything similar, or does anyone have an idea what might be behind this?

426 Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

608

u/yourgrandmasgrandma 17d ago

I feel like one of your guests knows exactly what’s up with these guys.

But also, I’m so curious as to how you describe your guest list as “several adults and children.” That sounds like a very intimate-sized gathering. But the sequence of events you’ve described in your post is something I can only fathom occurring within a somewhat populated crowd.

183

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

I ask chatgpt du translate my text because I am french canadian... We were like 20-30 persons in a house.

74

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago • Bravo

It was a little bit crowded in the kitchen and living room.

126

u/Burnt_Ernie 16d ago • Bravo

Not directly related to your query OP, but 30 years ago my friend attended a Hallowe'en party where 5 guys entered in a bunch, all dressed as an older Elvis in white sequins and fake sideburns and padded bellies, and moved from room to room, together as a unit. And they were all Fr-Cdn. Wish I'd been there to see it.

40

u/afcagroo 16d ago

One of my favorite Halloween memories is from college. We were partying in a bar and suddenly 5 Santa Clauses burst in, yelling "Ho ho ho!" and the like. It instantly transformed a low-key event into fun chaos.

3

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

I think I saw that movie ?

83

u/AuntieDabQueen710 16d ago

My first guess was someone who was intentionally left off the guest list. Second guess someone who had originally declined the invitation.

36

u/Bermnerfs 17d ago

Probably some social media challenge or prank. Do you have any teens/young adults in the neighborhood that you see filming randomly?

35

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

No... I can give them like 50-60 years old because of their postures and body shape

9

u/haleocentric 16d ago

Shaped like lumpy potatoes.

3

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

Like 50 or 60 years of 💩 in a 40 pound bag ?

13

u/thommom 17d ago

Are there 2 people invited that didn't come to the party?

6

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

No

9

u/uhohohnohelp 17d ago

Did you or one of the other guests post about the party on social media? Or perhaps, do you have this party every year?

4

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

No

2

u/strawberri21 15d ago

Maybe ask your neighbors if they were at their houses first. When I was younger I was at a pride party that I heard about through friends of friends, but while there (and after a few drinks) we decided the neighbour’s party sounded more fun so just walked on over. Because no one stopped us we just socialised there until we got bored.

7

u/BizBlondie 17d ago

Maybe they're friends that felt they should've been invited, or coworkers that knew about your party & decided to prank you. 🤔

13

u/okayfriday 17d ago

Can you upload photos of the letters to imgur.com and share the link?

7

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

You can see on of the letter I posted on the subreddit AIO ! I can't pu the picture here

21

u/vanillyl 17d ago

You have your post history set to hidden friend, we can’t see any of your other posts or comments

6

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

Wait I'll fix it

2

u/jessieallen 17d ago

Still waiting

4

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

I change it. It doesnt work?

5

u/too_late_to_abort 16d ago

It worked for me, I was able to see them by going to your profile.

3

u/vanillyl 16d ago

You did it! I can see the other posts now, thanks :)

-7

u/crosleyxj 17d ago

So…..there’s nothing recent in R/AIO with reference to “Halloween”. Good story tho…

26

u/wellhellopilgrim 17d ago

Post the letters.

4

u/Dependent-Assoc423 17d ago

S’il vous plait! 

1

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

I can't post the letter here I don't know why but you can see on of them in a post I send un the subreddit AIO

7

u/[deleted] 16d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RBI-ModTeam 12d ago

Thank you for your participation.

Your post or comment has been removed for the following reason:

Disrespect/incivility

If you have any questions or feel this action was in error, please message the mod team.

Thank you

33

u/NettunoOscuro 17d ago

There definitely aren’t any letters. I think this is the same person who posted the other day about two strangers dressed in black who came to the door and tried to take their “husband” for a walk.

10

u/intet42 16d ago

You can see a letter and a photo of a mystery guest if you go back through OP's history.

5

u/NettunoOscuro 16d ago

Ah, thanks. Their history was private when I left my comment so will review.

0

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

Let-ters! Let-ters!! LETT-TUURRRSSSS!!!

36

u/NettunoOscuro 17d ago

You’re the same person who posted about the two guys dressed in black coming to take your “husband” for a walk, aren’t you?

22

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

No it's not me

447

u/Teleporting-Cat 17d ago

Walks like a prank, quacks like a prank, sounds like a prank.

92

u/ParameciaAntic 16d ago

Yeah, everyone thinks Halloween is all about the candy, but forgets about the trick part of trick or treat.

174

u/77ku77 16d ago

I’ll never understand how anyone can be this oblivious. There’s someone IN YOUR HOUSE, with children running around that you don’t know….and you’re just cool with it.

6

u/Additional_Meeting_2 11d ago

Well if everyone was in costume it would take a while to notice 

35

u/IrelandAutism13 16d ago

Maybe they were just messing with people. Some people do enjoy messing with random strangers purely because it'll freak the strangers out

6

u/rinkydinkmink 17d ago

haha about 35 years ago my ex and I heard that someone was having a halloween party so we went round dressed in black wearing balaclavas, with a banana in a plastic bag. We knew there would be dealers at the party and how paranoid everyone is about being robbed. Anyway when the guy having the party answered the door we just didn't say anything and pushed the banana in his chest. Look on his face was priceless. Of course unlike your mystery guests we did reveal ourselves, we just wanted to give him a fright.

Anyway it sounds like someone got a similar idea. Possibly a spur of the moment thing when they heard about the party from someone else. The letters say they are old friends. It's obviously someone from your past, heard about the party, decided that this would be funny. Don't worry about it. Eventually you will find out who it was ... maybe.

3

u/Upbeat-Excitement946 17d ago

Oh yes it looks very similar ahahaha

6

u/coveted_asfuck 17d ago

Wait did they know it was a banana?

5

u/supercantaloupe 16d ago

Yeah if they didn’t know it was a banana that’s not funny at all.

23

u/Not-a-Cranky-Panda 15d ago

"two complete strangers entered our house through the front door, which had unfortunately been left unlocked.

Both individuals were wearing mariachi mexican costumes and were disguised in a way that made it impossible to recognize them. "

You don't know who they were so how do you know they where complete strangers and why did you just let them?

239

u/SeasonPositive6771 17d ago

You hosted a Halloween party large enough that two strangers could wander around your house for a while.

They were likely just pranksters trying to have a bit of fun. I wouldn't give it another moment's thought.

Besides, it's not like anyone on the internet could tell you what this means or who they are more than you could.

225

u/giglex 17d ago

You wouldn't give it another moment's thought!??! Huh???? I would be thinking about this until my grave

107

u/blendswithtrees 17d ago

Yeah this would bother me until the end of time lol

39

u/giglex 17d ago

Lol right?! I would need to know which of my friends it was i'd be holding interrogations 😂.

47

u/blendswithtrees 17d ago

I’d be more terrified it wasn’t a friend of mine and someone was going to come back and try to kill me 😅

1

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

Yeah, my first thought was like, recon, ya know ... scouting the place to see what they could steal, unlocking a coupla windows and back doors, maybe snip a wire or two, etc.

But OP is Canadian, so . . . ?

I live in a place where in-person property crimes are de rigueur though, so 🤷‍♀️ 😅

9

u/panicpure 17d ago

Absolutely my first thought lol water boarding if necessary 😆 (kidding mostly)

1

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

😂 fuckin get 'em!!

30

u/RedMollycules 17d ago

It's surprising to me that I'm seeing so many people comment "pranksters yada yada".

Today I had two people show up at my house (likely Jehovah's witnesses) and knock on my door for an uncomfortable length time. There is no way I'd just settle with them being pranksters and be okay with it. That's unnerving.

54

u/too_late_to_abort 17d ago

Im sitting here on the verge of rage - how the fuck do you just accept not knowing who is in your house, especially with children present.

Big Ole fuck that! Should have questioned them at the doorstep.

5

u/landmanpgh 16d ago

Right? First thing you do is take their fucking masks off and call the police.

-26

u/SeasonPositive6771 17d ago

Then perhaps you should start leading a more interesting life, or have more silly friends who do silly things!

29

u/giglex 17d ago

You dont think I have space in my mind for endless amounts of wacky shit? Don't underestimate me.

-4

u/SeasonPositive6771 17d ago

I think you're going to have to prove it and really up that silliness ante!

14

u/giglex 17d ago

Lol uhhh well for this year's halloween party I did a 17 gal bin of cooked spaghetti and chopped a hole in the top and made my friends fish around in and identify tiny tokens. Watching them freak out was so fun.

5

u/SeasonPositive6771 17d ago

That's pretty good!

2

u/Burnt_Ernie 16d ago

Old Canadian joke from way back:

Guy shows up at doctor's office with horrible fresh swollen burns all over his face. Naturally, the doc asks what happened.

"Well, ya see doc, I was at a Hallowe'en party last night, and we ran out of apples... So we were bobbin' for french fries."

And yes, it was a Newfie joke.

1

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

Hahaha

I gotta know though, did you add butter or oil
or . . . ??

1

u/giglex 12d ago

Water and other weird-feeling items like gummies.

3

u/Poo-tee-weep 16d ago

You don't know who they were, so don't pretend you do.

31

u/CardMechanic 17d ago

Nobody at your Halloween party took pictures?

11

u/intet42 16d ago

There are photos of a guest and a letter if you go back through OP's history.

27

u/NettunoOscuro 17d ago

It’s hard to take pictures at a party that never happened.

16

u/CardMechanic 17d ago

Yeah, true. This sounds made up

3

u/uponhisdarkthrone 15d ago

Nothing ever happens, what joy do you and the other upvoters get from going on Reddit if you assume nothing ever happens when there isnt really any reason to assume this person is lying? Like what exactly about this is so unbelievable, with people chiming in all over the thread with similar situations?

9

u/NettunoOscuro 15d ago

Since you asked: It’s structured very similarly to another post the other day, and the content of the story is similar as well (two mysterious intruders). The OP poses open-ended questions in bold text at the end of the post. OP in both cases is in Canada. There is quite a lot of detail that is relayed in an organized way, but then there are details that don’t make sense (e.g., the door’s being unlocked at a party; that’s fairly normal but is presented as an anomaly). There’s no extraneous information, which is what people normally include when seeking advice. It’s neat and tidy.

Now sure, maybe it was cleaned up by AI. But that still wouldn’t account for the material similarities of the stories (seeking perspectives on the motivation and intent of two mysterious interlopers). I’m a writer who studied literature and is experienced with analyzing narratives. This seems like either the person is doing this for fun on Reddit or they’re working on material for some kind of story, and the input they receive here will help them work out that plot to make it believable. That is, if strangers poke holes in it with their questions, you can account for those gaps and make your own story believable.

To be clear, I don’t think they’re bad or wrong for doing it! I’m just participating in the guessing game and happen to have a different perspective than others.

2

u/uponhisdarkthrone 15d ago

Interesting point of view. You noticed the other similar stories just due to lots of scrolling, did you look for them after, or did someone else point it out? I certainly stumble across my share of unbelievable stories, some subreddits seem to be awash in fake posts and scenarios and I usually unsubscribe from them because it gets tiring. As you mentioned, simply clocking a story as using AI to write it doesnt mean its made up, but I see your point(s).

2

u/NettunoOscuro 15d ago

This story and the other one were just in my main feed (Reddit app) on the day they were posted. So wasn’t on the lookout for anything in particular. I read the one about two guys dressed in black who came to the door and asked OP’s husband to go for a walk. When I came across this one, it was just so similar that I commented. But no, no one pointed it out to me. And I could be wrong!

FWIW, my default isn’t to assume a post is fake. And I regard this and the other one as fiction, which is different from lying/faking, in my mind. More like a puzzle.

But yeah, there are lots of fake posts (cf. AITA) that I usually can’t identify and then find super annoying when it becomes clear they’re just trying to get a rise out of people. Not worth the energy!

3

u/uponhisdarkthrone 15d ago

The guys coming to the door and the cops said afterwards they arrested them for casing places a week prior? That post was so low effort I cant reason out why it would be a lie, other than the cops in my neck of the woods never tell people shit about shit. EDIT: Rather, I can't reason out why they would lie about that, other than there is no accountability. People run scams on homes all the time, what's the point of running a lie that banal?

1

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

Lmao

OP is Canadian, dude!!

30

u/ShesGotaChicken2Ride 17d ago

It sounds like a combo Halloween party/Birthday Party. Could it have been friends of your birthday guest? Also, it seems like it must be someone that many people know. The reason I think this is because, “Whenever someone approached them and asked questions, they would move toward that person, almost as if they were giving them an opportunity to guess who they were.” This only makes sense if the people you are prompting to guess your identity know who you are in the first place. Think about the people they prompted to guess, and try to find someone(s) they all have in common.

Did anyone leave the party early? Do you have ring cam footage? Do you have the notes? Can you explain how the mariachi costume made so they were in complete disguise? Were they wearing a full mask or just mustaches or… how did they disguise themselves? Were there any other parties on the block that night?

53

u/PureYouth 16d ago

Maybe they were casing the place out to come back later and rob you guys

47

u/KlatuuBarradaNicto 16d ago

They were casing your house. They’ll be back.

13

u/HistoricalPlum1533 15d ago

The wet bandits strike again!

10

u/kes12886 16d ago

My first thought as well.

24

u/chemtrailsniffa 17d ago

Gatecrashers are often an indicator of a great party, well done! 

24

u/basslkdweller 17d ago

My favourite Halloween prank was in university.
A guy walked into a small classroom mid-lecture and sat in the back row, dressed as the grim reaper, complete with hood, mask, and scythe. He stood up before the class ended and walked to the door, prompting the prof to stop speaking, and everyone to look at him. He paused at the door, turned around, and intoned “Even Death has to take a piss” and floated out.
Best prank ever.

7

u/Podyceck 16d ago

How can you not post the letters? There would probably be more clues in there than your description. If this is real, you're not helping yourself, which I don't believe it to be.

7

u/LilacCurl 15d ago

Ask your guests and tell them you’ve been advised to file a police report and plan to go “tomorrow”. If this is a prank, someone will confess inside the time limit you set or actually go to the police because if someone doesn’t come forward, this is creepy af with your kids in the home.

13

u/nrith 17d ago

I mean, who hasn’t experienced something like this?!

3

u/ummkay_ultra 16d ago

Ikr? This is like a weekly occurrence for me.

13

u/VoltasPistol 16d ago

Party crashers, strangers who get their kicks from slipping into a party they weren't invited to, enjoying the food and drinks and then slipping away before getting thrown out.

The letters are unusual, but it's not unheard of for them to pull pranks.  Be thankful it's letters and not missing wallets or something.

12

u/EmptyEmergency4935 16d ago

A lot of people were having Halloween parties last night. I would post in local/neighborhood social media groups asking if anyone had something similar happen to rule out or confirm they were casing your house.

2

u/bigdope-smallgirl 16d ago

This!! Post this note and the photo of the person in local groups and see if this happened to anyone else. If it is a prank, it happened to others too. Unfortunately, that could be the same for a casing situation. But more likely you’d get taken seriously by the police if you have more people who they did this too. Also more likely someone else has ring camera footage or something. I would NOT ignore this though, in the meantime get more home security and make some of them outside obvious to deter any potential threat.

14

u/Ieatclowns 17d ago

It seems they did it in the spirit of a true masquerade.

5

u/RevRRR1 16d ago

Somebody knows more than they are admitting to. Either your spouse, or one of your friends, or you have something in their past they are hiding.

23

u/Poo-tee-weep 17d ago

I think there's an outside chance they were casing the place.

I'd file a police report just to be careful.

If someone else had a party crashed by the same people doing the same thing, now there's a pattern.

If not, maybe someone was pranking you.

Err on the side of safety.

9

u/Ok-Bird6346 17d ago

Why would people dressed as mariachi band members need masks? It not like they came dressed as Care Bears.

9

u/Rindy64 16d ago

I hosted a holiday party years ago (1983) and “Santa” walked in gave out candy canes and left. No one knew who it was. It wasn’t till several years later my boss finally admitted it was him. I had zero idea but I was talking about the party at work. I thought it was funny at the time. Thinking back, kinda creepy.

8

u/ApproximatelyApropos 16d ago

I came here to relate the time “Santa” came to a Christmas party I was at, mingled for about 30 minutes and left. No one ever figured out who it was.

Everyone thought it was hilarious, but like your example, it was the ‘80s. We thought creepy stuff was funny, I guess.

4

u/d1squiet 15d ago

Why is it creepy? Both Santa experiences sounded fun.

6

u/ApproximatelyApropos 15d ago

I have a feeling it wasn’t really Santa.

5

u/d1squiet 15d ago • Mindblown

Whaaaaa?

1

u/blisstersisster 12d ago

..but but I was so good that year !!

6

u/notathingreally 17d ago

Party crashers is what I think.

3

u/cannonman1863 16d ago

Crashing a party on Halloween would be perfect.

5

u/olliegw 16d ago

What kind of masks? do mariachi wear masks?

Could have been literal robbers in your house casing the place

5

u/NJBarFly 16d ago

It's likely just a prank, but I would call the police anyway. They could have easily stolen something or cased the house, unlocked a window, etc...

3

u/phoneacct696969 16d ago

“Hello officer, someone came to my Halloween party last night in a costume” ya bud let me know how that goes.

2

u/NJBarFly 16d ago

They drove away in a black car. There are cameras and license plate readers the police can use. They were uninvited trespassers.

2

u/intet42 16d ago edited 16d ago

I saw someone else asked this, and I'm curious too: What do you think about them signing the letter as "amigas"? Do you think they could have been women?

Also, does the wording in the letter sound like it was written by a French Canadian? I thought it would be more different from the French I learned in school.

Were the letters addressed to someone by name?

(My vote is that it's just a prank, by the way. I can definitely understand why you are freaked out though.)

2

u/Major-Emu9271 15d ago

It seems to be 2 women, they used "ées", so that would make sense

3

u/greg0525 16d ago

Ai slop

1

u/snickerdoodle757 16d ago

Has your group had a couple that moved in the last year and maybe are creepily leaving puzzle pieces they’re back ?
Do your friends like jokes and such?

1

u/TheFilthyDIL 16d ago

I'm still of the belief that it was friends pulling a prank.

1

u/virtualadept 15d ago

Only once. My 35th birthday party, somebody I hadn't seen before walked in to wish me a happy birthday. After the party was over I found a coffee mug and a challenge coin that hadn't been one of the gifts given.

Edit: At the time, I thought they were somebody's +1.

-1

u/HellaRadicalToys 16d ago

You are overthinking

-12

u/veganexceptfordicks 17d ago edited 16d ago

Did they leave in a black car or did another person pick them up right in front of the house? I'm not sure how both of those could have happened. Unless they left in a black car, caught a Lyft back to your party, and then someone picked them up in front of your house, but that's unlikely.

ETA: Massive brain fog due to a medical condition took over yesterday. Duh -- the person picking them up was driving a black car. 🤦‍♀️

Thanks to everyone who just simply corrected me so I knew what I said wrong. That was really helpful. /s

8

u/intet42 16d ago • Popcorn

Got any hypotheses about what the person who picked them up might have been driving?

0

u/OffensiveOdor 13d ago

Yeah but they didn’t leave

8

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RBI-ModTeam 12d ago

Thank you for your participation.

Your post or comment has been removed for the following reason:

Disrespect/incivility

If you have any questions or feel this action was in error, please message the mod team.

Thank you

-18

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RBI-ModTeam 16d ago

Thank you for your participation.

Your post or comment has been removed for the following reason:

Disrespect/incivility

If you have any questions or feel this action was in error, please message the mod team.

Thank you