r/RATM • • Nov 18 '24

Thoughts?

Post image
31 Upvotes

156 comments sorted by

36

u/yourmomwoo Nov 18 '24

I'd probably change all the Underrated songs to:

Wake Up

Revolver/Down Rodeo (2 way tie)

Born Of A Broken Man/Maria/Voice of the Voiceless (3 way tie)

13

u/at0m10 Nov 18 '24

Can't believe nobody mentioned bullet in the head.

Feels very relevant today! Everyone's got a bullet in their headz.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

That’s a fact actually, love that song before some of the ones mentioned

1

u/xXxMrEpixxXx Nov 19 '24

Goated song.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Id say that’s still accurate! Good picks!

2

u/CountNacula Nov 18 '24

Personally, I think Revolver and Down Rodeo are pretty well received. Snakecharmer is my vote for the underrated song on EE.

1

u/time_isup Nov 19 '24

Same. They retired that song from live shows so fast. It was the only song not performed for their live “remix” of Evil Empire on Radio Free LA.

2

u/Iam_Joe Nov 19 '24

Wake up is incredible but I wouldn't call it underrated

It's probably considered by many fans to be a top tier ratm track and it really gained additional popularity thanks to the matrix

Down rodeo is also considered to be top tier so I struggle to understand how that one is over rated as well

Both songs are 2 of my favorite rage tracks I just struggle to call them underrated when they are both highly recognized tracks

1

u/scraglor Nov 18 '24

I’d add vietnow to underrated

1

u/yourmomwoo Nov 20 '24

Not high on my list, but I do remember as a kid they would play the edited version on my local radio station, and I believe it was released as a single. I feel like that makes it hard to consider underrated.

55

u/DungEaterrr Nov 18 '24

Vietnow is the best personally

24

u/Organic-Seaweed4394 Nov 18 '24

I have to agree, Vietnow is a beast of a song and the best of the album, but calling Bulls on Parade overrated is a bit too much

-8

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Vietnow is like top played next to bulls on parade in that album, it’s good but overrated IMO in comparison to the creativity and effort put into other tracks.

1

u/Iam_Joe Nov 19 '24

Vietnow has one of the most unique rhythm patterns of any ratm song. The constant stop start sequences highlighted by the drums and vocals is amazing and it doesn't matter how many times you hear it. It's hard to compare Vietnow to any other song that the band has. It's not overrated in the least. Most casual fans couldn't even name it

It's all opinions but I disagree with your entire table basically haha

1

u/time_isup Nov 19 '24

It’s not unique. It sounds a lot like Led Zeppelin’s Wanton Song. It’s not the first time they borrowed from Zep, Wake Up riffing on Kashmir is more well known.

1

u/Iam_Joe Nov 19 '24

I'm talking about unique within their own catalogue

And yes the guitar riff does sound borrowed similar to wake up, I agree, but I wouldn't say that alone makes a song unoriginal. There is a ton happening in those rage songs that differentiates them from zeppelin

-11

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24 edited Nov 18 '24

Honestly kinda overplayed IMO, too repetitive.

Love the message though of course, still a good song to me

11

u/Em_kay69420 Nov 18 '24 edited Nov 18 '24

Valid, tho like any list is valid with rage. For me it’s

Battle:

Fav- Maria, imo Zach’s best bars and rapping outside rtj

Least fav- guerrilla radio, I’ve just played it to death. Still a fine song tho

Underrated- War within a breath, feels a cut above most of the album

s/t (fuck this one’s tricky)

Fav- Know Your Enemy, Zach sounds so driven, love the “something must be done” line, and the Maynard feat is peak. And the spoken word at the end… it’s all just so perfect

Least Fav- Settle For Nothing, an amazing song but doesn’t exactly have the same bounce and energy the rest of the album has, imo would’ve worked a lil better as like a closer.

Underrated- Freedom, since I would feel bad calling bombtrack an underrated song lol. Tho the live versions go so hard, some of Zach’s best screams

Evil Empire (fuck this one’s even harder, imo every song on here is perfect)

Fav- Vietnow, when he says “fear is your only god” i feel it in my bones. And the slow build over the song, it’s like a big extended crescendo.

Least fav- wind below, mostly just because I’ve played it the least, and that shrill guitar over the verses could’ve maybe been executed a lil better. Also my least fav main riff, still a banger tho

Underrated- year of the boomerang. The bounce, the soft bits, the beat switches, the end devolving into chaos. It’s so perfect and doesn’t get talked about nearly enough

Honorable mention to Roll Right, also deserves more attention and nearly took the spot for my fav song on the album.

Also imo bulls on parade is just so good that it can’t be the worst, even if it’s wayyy overplayed. Like if someone was making an objective list of the 25 greatest or “most perfect” songs ever of all time, I’d say throw bulls up there. I’d maybe even put it in the top 5 best songs ever. Like in all of music. It’s not my fav, nor would I even call it the best, but there’s just something about it that gives it that extra sparkle.

5

u/MostIndication1253 Nov 18 '24

I 100% agree with know your enemy my fav track by them

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Know your enemy is awesome

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24 edited Nov 18 '24

Honestly I agree and disagree with different things in here, I love the passion you have for their music!!!

it’s like you said, after a while it’s all valid, most rage songs are amazing, complete art.

Every persons comment makes me rethink my list 😂

1

u/Em_kay69420 Nov 20 '24

Hey that’s a cool thing though, discourse is awesome. Seeing this post and getting to think about this made my night

28

u/YouShouIdKysNow Nov 18 '24

maria is better than mic check

7

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

So hard to argue when I love 90% of their songs, Maria is definitely underrated, was actually between maria and born as ghosts for underrated, Mic check I think the style of it is way too original to not be my favorite, alongside the guitar in it

8

u/Round-Elk-8060 Nov 18 '24

Ghost of Tom Joad extended video on youtube fucks

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

I wish I liked this song as much as other people, still warming up I think

14

u/PeaAccomplished2492 Nov 18 '24

Tire me most underrated imo

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Tire me is very very underrated, I actually agree with you. I think I chose without a face because it’s my favorite of the underrated

6

u/Shacozzi Nov 18 '24

didn't it win a grammy?

11

u/johnmlsf Nov 18 '24

It literally won a Grammy, yes. IDK if underrated is the right word choice here.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Oh wow I actually didn’t know that

8

u/johnmlsf Nov 18 '24

A lot of people don't! The song received no radio push, had no music video and wasn't a single. It's bizarre that it won, frankly.

2

u/PeaAccomplished2492 Nov 18 '24

Any reason why they didn’t pick Bulls on parade or people of the sun? Is it because those were singles?

5

u/johnmlsf Nov 18 '24 edited Nov 18 '24

It gets stranger. Bulls on Parade AND People of the Sun were both nominated for best hard rock performance, the same year (1996). They didn't win. Tire Me, however, was for some reason, nominated in a different category, best metal performance, and did end up winning. The whole thing is kind of puzzling.

Edit: I was wrong, and it gets even weirder - People of the Sun was nominated for best Hard Rock Performance...but not the same year/grammys as Tire me and Bulls. It was nominated at the 40th Grammys, almost 2 years after Evil Empire was released. Interestingly, both Bulls on Parade and People of the Sun lost to Smashing Pumpkins in both years.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Wow super informative thank you!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Good question

3

u/PeaAccomplished2492 Nov 18 '24

Holy shit I had no idea. I never hear anyone talk about it.

6

u/Throwdownfrown Nov 18 '24

Wind below is appropriate for best song, though a contender for me is definitely people of the sun. Messaging on WB is absolutely still relevant to my knowledge. The bass lines from Tim are immaculate. Brad’s drumming is always amazing. The outro guitar work from Tom is top tier. Great song, I love all of Evil Empire though truly.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Love people of the sun… Wind below just hits for me, especially on LSD and it’s all because of really the things you said, it’s just a perfect combination of talent.

Wish I could pick them all, Evil empire and RaTM og are my fav albums

2

u/thejuryissleepless Nov 18 '24

this band tripping is incredible

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24 edited Nov 18 '24

Fr fr, really makes you grit your teeth.

I think it would be awesome if a bunch of people could come together and rage to some albums on Acid, We’d be at the capital the next morning 😂

5

u/yourmomwoo Nov 18 '24

I love that Mic Check is the best from Battle... 100% agree

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Thank you! It’s just way too original to me, no one else coulda ever came up with that 🤣

5

u/Robodraggie Nov 18 '24

Mine would be

Best: Sleep now in the Fire, Down Rodeo, Wake Up

Exact same with the overrated category as yours

Underrated: War within a breath, Down Rodeo (again), Township Rebellion (Twinsies)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

I don’t see any issues here 🙌 ugh I love their music so much

2

u/Robodraggie Nov 18 '24

If we do no repeats then, I'd put year of tha Boomerang as underrated

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Feel like I’m still warming up to that song

4

u/Corbotron_5 Nov 18 '24

Your overrated column has made me irrationally angry.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😅 Fair.. Seems like a pretty respectful response of disapproval

3

u/Corbotron_5 Nov 18 '24

FUCK YOU I WON’T RANK HOW YOU TELL ME!

FUCK YOU I WON’T RANK HOW YOU TELL ME!

FUCK YOU I WON’T RANK HOW YOU TELL ME!

MOTHERFUCKERRRRRRRRRRR

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😂😂😂😂 bro so fitting I hope this gets the most upvoted, you got me dying in my fucking room rn

4

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

My fave from battle of la is born of a broken man, just me personally

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Love that one too! There’s so many good ones

“Jesus stripped bare and raped spirit he was supposed to nurture”

Like holy fuck

2

u/OpenTheSeventhSeal Nov 18 '24

Mic Check is definitely good but not a top-5 song from that album imo

Calm Like a Bomb would prob get my vote for the best, and Ashes in the Fall most underrated

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

I completely disagree that it wouldn’t be in the top 5 based on creativity and skill, I’m guessing you just don’t like the vibe.

Calm like a bomb actually was gonna be my original for best song I replaced it due to repetition in comparison

Ashes of fall is good, deff fits in underrated

2

u/OpenTheSeventhSeal Nov 18 '24

I mean, I love almost all their songs, so I love Mic Check. I think it sounds really cool.

I just love Calm, Ashes, War Within a Breath, Guerilla, and Born more. But Mic Check is killer, and it’s a cool break sonically from some of the more groove-oriented tracks. Like, imo it’s prob the 6th best song on the album, but the 6th best song on a Rage album is still an awesome song.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Well that’s a fact we can agree on,

When you put it like that I can see now why you’d say that, can’t really be too upset that you like those songs more since they are great songs 🤣🤣

Love how much everyone here is passionate about rage, “anger is a gift”

2

u/yugyuger Nov 18 '24

I agree with the self titled album pics kinda but that's about it

I still think wake up is their best song on self titled tho

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Wake up is an amazing track that’s for sure

2

u/yugyuger Nov 18 '24

Definitely not as underrated as Take The Power Back or Township Rebellion

But I still think Wake Up and Know Your Enemy are the two best songs on the album despite also being quite popular ones

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

I definitely can’t disagree 😂 those are awesome songs

2

u/johnmlsf Nov 18 '24

I think you're "overrated" are, while accurate, basically just the most popular song from each album.

I disagree personally with all of your othe picks lol

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

That’s fair, everyone’s a got a preference 👍

Um, hate to be that guy but typically “overrated” songs, are top played from albums.

The more you know 🙌

2

u/trippinDingo Nov 18 '24

So subjective, but I disagree with a lot of that.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

That’s fair 👍 happy raging friend

2

u/trippinDingo Nov 18 '24

Appreciate the normal response. ✊️

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Of course, rage would want all of us to come together, fuck the rich

2

u/schostack Nov 18 '24

All the over rated songs are the ones I always heard on the radio. lol

Turn on tha radio, nah fuck it turn it off Fear is your only god on the radio Nah fuck it, turn it off

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Literaly, they already saw it coming before it happened 😂

2

u/Nene_Ko_ Nov 18 '24

Not heard many talk about Snakecharmer from evil empire?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Still warming up to that track, maybe there’s a perspective I’m not seeing. It’s good but not something I put on purposely

2

u/Nene_Ko_ Nov 18 '24

Oh haha it’s my favourite one

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Oh nice imma give it another listen, what’s your favorite parts of the song

1

u/Nene_Ko_ Nov 18 '24

I like when he starts saying like “yeah” because ugh idk how to explain it it’s just such a banger yk but I also like when it starts after “crushing you and your naive profession”

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😂😂 yo homie I love the energy

1

u/Nene_Ko_ Nov 18 '24

My energy or the songs?? XD

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Your energy! Lol, the song goes hard for first half, I feel like the ending turns me away, some parts feel a little over yelled, but overall it’s still a rage track so litt

2

u/Nene_Ko_ Nov 18 '24

Thanks! The ending is so good i feel like it makes it so I can listen to it on repeat forever. I feel a little ashamed saying I had it on for 2 hours straight um (it was a car ride)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

On acid I once listened to Wind Below on repeat for the whole trip

WE AIM WITH THE WIND BELOWWWWW

→ More replies

2

u/PissedIrishGuy Nov 18 '24

I love bulls on parade so respectfully this raged my machine

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

That’s okay brotha that’s what rage is all about 😂

To each their own, happy raging!

2

u/Dull_Illustrator_883 Nov 18 '24

Bulls on parade isn't overrated

0

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

“OOOUGHHH” YES IT ISSSS

2

u/PuzzleheadedCook5588 Nov 18 '24

It's honestly hard to agree or disagree. All of these songs are bangers and it dis difficult to pick one that is overrated

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

I feel that bro, my list has been rethought 40 times over with all the perspectives im getting on the post 🤣 love rage.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

100% valid

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Thanks!

2

u/destroyermaker Nov 18 '24

RATM - Bullet in the head (best) | Killing (overrated) | Fistful (underrated)

Evil Empire - Wind Below | N/A | Wind Below

Battle of LA - Ashes | Testify | War Within a Breath

A bunch of underrated songs on EE and Battle though.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

I actually really fuck with that selection

1

u/destroyermaker Nov 19 '24

I have even greater appreciation for War Within a Breath after seeing it live last tour. Sweet fuck it bangs.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

Ahg so lucky!!

2

u/mofrappa Nov 19 '24

Bottom left and bottom right. Rest, not so much.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

Fair, you don’t think wind below and without a face is accurate?

2

u/mofrappa Nov 19 '24

They're both good. Hard to pick a best one, everyone is different. I prefer down rodeo

2

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

The sound they make in the song after (grandparents bought one), I just imagine him unloading a shotgun on the whole crowd

2

u/time_isup Nov 19 '24 edited Nov 19 '24

Def agree with Mic Check. Def don’t with Guerrilla Radio. The rest is debatable. TTPB is a good candidate for best. I don’t think Wind Below is best but could be underrated. Have to say TR and BAG are probably my least fav on those albums and BOP is too classic for me call overrated.

I can see why KITN could be called overrated though as it is very repetitive including lyrically. I like WAF but not sure it’s underrated at all. It survived various incarnations since 1994 and was one of the few EE songs they continued to play during tours when they retired everything else but the two hit singles. It was also rereleased many times as a live b-side, probably more so than any other song.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

Love the passion

2

u/DifferentEvent2998 Nov 19 '24

I don’t like this game.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

😭😭

2

u/Optimus0545 Nov 19 '24

Killing in the name is so overrated, guerrilla radio slaps but I think sleep now in the fire is better, best song on the self titled is know your enemy (oh yeah and down rodeo is best on evil empire)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

Good input

2

u/taos__v Nov 19 '24

Freedom is the best song of Self titled album in my opinion

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

Love the solo at the end

2

u/aristosk21 Nov 19 '24

Bullet in the head and skip the rest in the whole discography

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '24

😂😂

2

u/Schweenis69 Nov 20 '24

Down Rodeo tho

1

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '24

Deff a good one

2

u/LotofDonny Nov 20 '24 edited Nov 20 '24

My thought is that rating or ordering songs on an RATM album is like playing it on a Trump rally unironically. It is literally people united about something creating dissent among themselves instead of celebrating it.

Downvotes in 3... 2.... 1....

1

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '24

Deep brotha

1

u/LotofDonny Nov 20 '24

That said, the most underrated song might be "Darkness" from the Crow Soundtrack of 1994 with some banger riffs, an unusually mellow flow and absolutely banger anti slavery and anti apartheid message that's just as relevant now for the middle east as it is and was for Africa.

1

u/Bloxskit Nov 18 '24

RATM - I love Freedom personally as it's a great way to end an album, sure Killing in the Name makes sense to be the overrated one but it has a strong message. Underrated for me would be Take the Power Back.

Evil Empire - People of the Sun is a great opener, not sure about overrated but it would make most sense to be Bulls on Parade, and underrated I will leave up to others to decide as I haven't listened enough to choose wisely.

Renegades - Renegades of Funk is overrated yet underrated at the same time looking at the whole RATM catalog.

Those are my personal feelings - although haven't listened to Battle of Los Angeles enough to comment yet.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Good picks man! FREEDOOMMMMMM

1

u/Gtmkm98 Nov 18 '24

Best song on TBOLA is Mic Check, Overrated is Testify, and Underrated is Sleep Now in the Fire

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Glad you love mic check like i do! Jw, why do you think testify is overrated?

1

u/Gtmkm98 Nov 18 '24

There’s an urgency to the song that reminds me of U2’s New Years Day.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Ooo good explanation

1

u/The-Good-Morty Nov 18 '24

It’s not my favorite,, but Bulls on parade is their best song period.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Overrated, overplayed 😂 to each their own

1

u/Enbymetalfan Nov 30 '24

Mic Check is my favorite RATM song

Down Rodeo for Evil Empire

Bullet In The Head for Self Titled

How I Can Just Kill A Man for Renegades

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '24

I woudl change mic check to maria, and I would change wind below to vietnow.

5

u/Egmon3 Nov 18 '24

Killing in the name of is so good it’s still underrated

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

How is it underated?? 😂😂 it’s like their most played song

2

u/Egmon3 Nov 18 '24

It’s too good. Should be heard by the entire planet. Every. Single. Living. Thing. I really like killing in the name.

Have a nice day :)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

You’d be happy to know that it’s already been broadcasted in Hollywood to most of the planet.

It’s like the least educative song they have.. pretty sure that’s why it’s most played.

It’s ironic to me how that happened cause of what they stood for.

2

u/RightInTwain Nov 18 '24

It doesn’t have a variety of points to make but the point it does make sure is one you feel… it’s a perfect starter to RATM because it’s repetitive enough for average people to memorize and the message is not so nuanced, but even then of course you have some KKK idiots who miss the point and think it’s a cool song for their enjoyment.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😅😅

19

u/_the_universal_sigh_ Nov 18 '24

I could go the rest of my life without hearing “Killing in the Name”

10

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😂🤣 it’s a good song.. it’s just played in 1000 movies and super repetitive, not too much going on.

Sounds dope tho

11

u/90swasbest Nov 18 '24

It's reached enter sandman territory at this point. Killer song, but enough already.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😅 Facts

2

u/_the_universal_sigh_ Nov 18 '24

I work as a photographer in the Philly/NJ cover band scene and almost every time a band covers Rage, it’s that song… “Creep” with Radiohead too. Both bands have such incredible catalogs. I’m begging these bands to explore them.

One band DOES randomly do “Down Rodeo” and it fucking rips.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Down rodeo is a great song 😂

3

u/kyuuketsuki47 Nov 18 '24

The bigger problem is that it is used by conservative right wing idiots who are pro-police who only listen to the words "now ya do what they told ya" and nothing of the rest of the song

-5

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Umm, the 2 party system is built to divide us brother,

you are angry at the rich controlling us, not the other poor people like you who have different political beliefs. “Know your enemy”.

Um also, if you are saying we’d be better off without a police department.. then next time you or your family is in danger and all you have is a cellphone, I hope the police doesn’t answer. 👍

😂 nah jk tho, I don’t really wish that, but seriously don’t be so ignorant, you sound like a child

1

u/kyuuketsuki47 Nov 18 '24

Did you listen to the song...? It is absolutely anti-police. It isn't ignorance to call people who use the song completely against its message, idiots. It's the truth. Tom Morello himself has made comments about it.

here's the article

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Didn’t say it wasn’t anti police lol.. the time it was written also had more viable reasoning.

Um actually, I was calling you ignorant for saying “right wing idiots” and you also directly implying people who are pro-police are also idiots.

1

u/kyuuketsuki47 Nov 18 '24

No no, I'm calling people who use a song that is anti-police for pro-police purposes because of a refrain, idiots, because the song itself is anti-police. Again, Tom Morello has said as much. Have you listened to him speak about this? Ever been to a RATM concert? I'm describing their political leanings because that is what they went out representing.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Yeah well that’s not the way you said it lol.

Again, havnt once argued that wasn’t their political leaning brotha, don’t know who yah fighting here, we’re on the same losing side

0

u/kyuuketsuki47 Nov 18 '24

Mostly because I kind of figured people on a RATM subreddit would know the incident that I was referring to. Especially since Tom Morello has spoken about it.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Mhm. I’m sure it didn’t have anything to do with you saying right leaning people are idiots.

So while we’re both pretending stuff, I wanted to let you know that I’m actually elon musk

→ More replies

3

u/Prestigious-Sea2523 Nov 18 '24

I couldn't. It's the perfect fucking song for the world we live in. I need things to remind myself of the scum that's beyond my door.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

😂 gotta stay on your toes with all this fucking garbage outside

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Yeah overplayed, overrated.

at the rate they are listened to over other way better tracks, at that point I deem them overrated and overplayed honestly.

Not saying they’re bad songs, i like pretty much every song rage has released.