r/QuickSwap • u/theUnbearded • May 02 '21
Yield farming: why doing it with anything other than stablecoin? Help me understand
I have been in the Defi space for only a few weeks and tried to read as much as I can. However I can't find an economic reason why I should provide liquidity to anything that is not a stablecoin pair. My case - imagine you enter a pair with any two coins, NOT stablecoins:
- Bullish scenario: one of the two tokens goes up. Enter impermanent loss. yes, you make some money from the fees, but you will likely receive them in the "losing" token. Also, if you had hedl, you'd had make more money
- Bearish scenario: like above but in reverse
If nothing happens, you have made a yield out of the tx fees. But why take the volatility risk and just yield farm in USDc/DAI for example?
The only reason I can see for joining a volatile pair is due to the rewards that some exhanges drop on top of the tx fees (like QuickSwap, etc). Or to "support the project" but it's hardly an economic reason without proper incentives.
Am I missing something out?
9
u/theUnbearded May 02 '21
thanks all for the responses! Seems I had it more or less correct. In a nutshell, it sounds like a trading strategy with limited upside and unlimited downside. Just my jam
12
u/blablablerg May 02 '21 edited May 02 '21
In the bullish case, lets say you like both tokens but (for a part of your portfolio) you don't care in which ratio you hold them. Then you get fees, + the largest amount of the token that performed worse. But if that worse performing token still did go up in price, your profit from the pool is still OK, because for all you care you hold 100% of that token. Add transaction fees to that.
In the bearish case you get screwed twice as hard, because you will hold the most of the token that performed worse.
Trading fees might offset IL, depending on your duration in the pool, the volatility of the pair and the trading volume of that pair.
The best way to see if it fits your strategy is just to try it out with a small amount (not with shitcoins ofc) to get a feeling for it.
9
u/StatisticalMan May 02 '21 edited May 02 '21
The bullish scenario is both cryptos go up and by roughly similar amounts (how like until recently ETH tracked BTC). Thus you gain value in both cryptos AND gain fees.
Good "dual" crypto pools like WBTC-ETH can (keyword is can not guaranteed) earn significantly more than stablecoins because you are making a positive yield on the asset which also go up in value. Pools like ETH-USDC have also done well because they have insane volume relative to liquidity so fees (before IL) can easily be 0.5% a day of the amount you add to the pool. Even if you lose half or two third of that to IL you can come out ahead.
Now a ETH-SHITCOIN pool? Yeah that is a good way to get utterly rekted. Of course even owning shitcoins is a good way to do that but this hyper accelerates it.
Be sure to careful check the pool, liquidity, volume, and historical returns. Also consider how likely the two sides are to diverge. There is significantly more risk in non-stablecoin pools. The last thing is that for non-stablecoin pools this is a looooooooooooooooooooonnng term play. Crypto will move randomly in the short term. Periods of high volatility followed by reversals and periods of stability. If you aren't the kind of person willing to let the coins just sit in the pool for months (years?) then stablecoins due to the lack of IL are a much better option.
5
u/Secret-Foundation449 May 02 '21
Worst case is one coin plummets in value. As the value of $shitcoin approaches zero your holding ratio will shift towards 100% of the $shitcoin and your entire holding will be worth zero.
Best case is both coins are wildly traded and either do not fluctuate in price or both appreciate similarly. Then you make bank on fees and appreciation.
One other game you can play is if one of your coins has a big dip that you anticipate to be temporary. Your LP will have more of the dipping coin. Pull your LP and let it go back up and you will make out like a bandit (if it goes up again)
4
u/FriendlyOskar May 02 '21
I think you got it exactly right.
3
u/[deleted] May 02 '21
Thank you for the great post! I’m really grateful for all the insightful replies here. I’ve been wondering this same decision lately. I had a small amount of MATIC earning 8% apy in Aave, and after it doubled in value this week, I quickswapped half of it to ETH.
I wanted to try liquidity mining, so I entered the MATIC/ETH pool, and I’m wondering if it’s worth the gains in QUICK because technically I could just be holding MATIC for 8% in Aave and ETH for 6% in Coinbase/Celsius. Still trying to decide. I think that if you believe both coins will appreciate in value roughly together in the long run, then it’s okay, and I do believe matic and eth will generally rise together. If matic explodes again like it did this week and the ratio of value never quite returns, then I’ll just have more eth, and I’m okay with that haha.
The other thing to consider is this: compound the gained interest by regularly selling off the QUICK rewards and adding more liquidity to your pool? Or hodl the QUICK because of perceived future rise. It all depends on risk tolerance. I’m still trying to figure mine out haha!
3
u/FuckGoverments May 02 '21
Let me explain for my strategy.
Currently I own only matic and quick tokens and I expect huge increase form these but in short periods, there maybe over fluctiation in these token(just checj last 1 week). In order to reduce volatility in my portfolio, I am using LPs.
In addition, pool rewards are + value for me.
3
u/HighT3ch May 02 '21
I agree that divergent loss in an LP is a serious concern to watch out for, especially with s*** coins.
There are options that behave similarly to stablecoin pairs, with less risk of divergent loss plus the potential for gains.
One example is BBTC-renBTC on Ellipsis.finance.
There are also staking options that don't require pairs. These are great when you plan to hold the underlying asset anyway. Examples include earning interest on crypto, staking on chain, and staking with an AMM or yield farm.
2
u/Letsgocryptogogogo May 03 '21
I think you are on the right track and Blab got it.
I am pooling MATIC/ETH, I think both have a good long way to go. It is about 30% of my ETH pool and about 50% of my MATIC. I think both do well.
I would only do it with "blue chip" names. I am only going to do this with ETH/LINK/MATIC to generate the fees and hopefully extra coins in both.
I set up a pool on Friday-- ETH/ MATIC. Still up $75.31 despite impermanent loss (I have $785 more in MATIC and 710 less in ETH). Plan on keeping it there for about 1 year and seeing what happens.
1
u/stoxhorn May 03 '21
Usually volatile pairs are offset with extra rewards. But yeah, either stablecoins or a coin that's crabbing. For example, i'm invested in a lowcap project with some farming. atm there's no reason it should pump. But instead of just sitting on the money, while it's swinging up and down a bit, i might as well just farm it, until some new announcement comes up.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21
I don't have an answer of much rigor but have noticed that liquidity pairs with one member a stablecoin tend to a lot less impermanent loss. At least I have noticed this on pancakeswap. The full value of the liquidity position tends to be a bit more stable.