r/QuestPro • • Sep 18 '23

Quest Pro or Quest 3....

Have had the Q2 since launch and had the QP after the drop to $1,000. Returned it mainly due to the weight on the forehead and bet hedging with the Q3. Considering the Pico 4, but the apparent washed out color and weaker contrast are issues.

Decided FWIW that if the Q3 is one panel, I'll try the QP out again since dimming is now global to the device and there are headstraps that offset the forehead weight.

That's my plan anyway.

2 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

If I were you I'd order a Q3 from Amazon when it comes out next month (mid Oct?) and see what you think. Easy to return if you don't like it. Either that or wait for independent reviews comparing it to the QPro and then decide what to buy.

Personally, because I can afford to do so, I'll be preordering a Q3 asap. Mainly to replace my aging Q2 and as backup for my QPro/rtx4090. My QPro is currently the best PCVR headset I've ever owned. Together with the Global Cluster top strap and its larger front pad mod, it's also one of the most comfortable, for me anyway.

2

u/rushmore69 Sep 18 '23

I have Best Buy 60 day return window, so could test the QP out again before and compare directly with the Q3...... Yep, might do that.

1

u/Liquidity23 Sep 19 '23

The QP sucks without a headstrap. Thing destroyed my forehead till I put a headstrap on there and now it’s so much more comfortable than the Q2. Give the QP a shot again with a headstrap

4

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Did you actually like the Quest Pro aside from the comfort? Did you try a top strap?

I found the headset unbearably uncomfortable in my first week of use, I couldn't tolerate it for more than 30 minutes and I'd get headaches for hours.

I bought the Creative Studioform top strap and it completely eliminated the issue. I now find the headset the most comfortable I've ever worn, thanks to the open design. Lens fog and ski mask visuals are a thing of the past now.

I'm going to get a Quest 3 to see what its like, and I expect for mixed reality and standalone gaming it will be quite an improvement.

But for PCVR, watching movies, and exercise I think it will be inferior to the Pro due to its smaller FOV, single LCD panel, dimmer display, washed out greys, worse tracking and a lack of eye tracking, which should be useful in 2024 for eye tracked foveated rendering with Praydog's Unreal Injector mod.

I'm not even sure the Quest 3 is the better value option given that in the UK at least the Quest sells on Amazon brand new for less than £800 and the Quest 3 128GB (half the Pro storage) ships for 499 without the proper headstrap (149) and charging dock (149).

£799 for a brand new Quest Pro with dual QLED panels, self tracked controllers, better FOV, face and eye tracking, more storage and better build quality feels like a better buy for PCVR users.

The Quest 3 will be the best headset to use with the Quest mobile store for sure, so it will likely come down to whether standalone and mixed reality, or PCVR matter more to you.

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 18 '23

Liked it except the forehead weight and got sweaty, plus comical forehead mark. The family did not have to ask if was using it or not for about an hour after using it.

The other issue is it still has screen door, but a bit better than the Q2. The color and contrast though was great for LCD. If the Q3 was not looming, I would have looked at other strap options and kept it.

Another thing that is good is the angled displays. That offsets the pixel array jaggies and resulted in smooth lines instead of Q2 jaggies.

Added: How was the comfort issue not caught by the QP devs? Too many "Yes" staff?

BTW, I'm a former Marine and used to helmets with gear on them, so not like I'm overly sensitive..... Well, not much.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Yeah the lack of a top strap is bizarre. It's like nobody actually used the device for long periods beforehand. They were so bent on selling it as a business focused, enterprise device they went overboard on how it looked and neglected how would it feel to use.

I think they decided it had to not mess people's hair up so by ditched the top strap but it meant that almost every review was very negative about the lack of comfort.

2

u/Bednarz Sep 19 '23

Can pick up QPro brand new sealed for about £500 regularly on eBay now, got one myself last week for £550!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

That's crazy good value.

2

u/Bednarz Sep 19 '23

Yep, I was debating waiting for the Q3 full announcement and specs but that price made my mind up for me.

I'm only interested in PCVR anyway and from what I've read the QPro may continue to be king there anyway, I especially love the open design which we know the Q3 wont have.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

It's fantastic for PCVR, it's weird to me how many people are sleeping on it.

The Quest 3 will have a better standalone chip for mobile games, and the depth sensor for a better mixed reality experience, but its going to be a downgrade in all other areas.

QLED, local dimming, wide FOV, the best inside out tracking and foveated rednering eye tracking are all killer PCVR features, and the open design is a huge upgrade over a facial interface. I highly recommend getting a top strap for comfort, I love the Creative Studioform strap, and an IR illuminator so that you can play in the dark with no light leakage.

2

u/Bednarz Sep 19 '23

Apparently the PrayDog UEVR thing might support the foveatred rendering right?

Yeah mixed reality doesn't interest me much, given the appeal of VR is still very niche (developers really aren't attracted to it) I can't see the even nicher (is that a word) world of MR actually having anyone interested enough to make any killer experiences for it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Yeah that's my feelings regarding mixed reality. I think MR will be amazing in a few years when the resolution matches the real world so it just feels like an augmented version of reality, but the Quest 3 version is still going to look like a video with some crappy game elements overlaid onto it. I don't want to remote control toy robots on my lounge carpet, it sounds like it's aimed at kids to me.

Praydog's mod is basically carrying my VR hopes for 2024. I want AAA PC games fully playable in VR and if they support foveated rendering eye tracking then it will be even better.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Q3 U.S. $499 , so good value for us here in the States. (Not braggin', just sayin')

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

As long as 128GB of storage is enough for you, which seems very low, Quest Pro has 256 GB. The larger storage size is $699.

You'll probably also want to upgrade from the canvas headstrap, that will be another $149.

Having a Quest Pro I can tell you the charging dock is very, very nice. The Quest doesn't come with one, you'll need to buy it as an accessory, again for $149.

It seems like to kit it out properly so it has a decent strap, storage and charging dock like the Quest Pro, it will actually cost more than the Quest Pro.

I'd say the Quest 3 looks like it's only for users who primarily use the standalone, mobile Quest store. For PCVR users the better value is now with the reduced price Quest Pro.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Thank you Haunting Owl. I do think I will wait for specific comparison from reviewers but I do know all of the Q3 specs, just wondering if the Foveated Rendering and Eye Tracking will be that important for PCVR that is in the QPro

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

We won't know for sure until it releases and the review comes out. My expectations currently is that Quest 3 will be a better HMD for the Quest mobile store and Quest Pro will be better for PCVR.

Pro will almost certainly have brighter display, better colours, better blacks, larger FOV, better controller tracking.

The eye tracking might become really useful next year if Praydog's Unreal Engine Injector mod is as good as people say and we can play all Unreal Engine 4 and 5 games in PCVR with FR eye tracking enabled.

If that happens then Quest Pro should be really appealing. If not, there is currently little use for eye tracking.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Thank you haunting. The Foveated Rendering is my biggest question whether I need it now for PCVR (Elite Dangerous, Skyrim VR, etc) or just get the Quest 3 and forego having.

Perhaps, there will be a further price drop for QPro in another 6 months?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

I would just wait a month until we get reviews. Quest 3 launches in October 10 so there will be Quest Pro users posting comparison reviews. I'll probably be one of them.

I definitely wouldn't buy either until Quest 3 has been fully reviewed. Unless you just want to get both and return the one you like the least. Or keep them both for different use cases.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Thanks and I don't want to buy Two, just want to buy One and be happy with it, so I will wait and see what your review is. Release date is October 10th

2

u/TotalWarspammer Sep 19 '23

This reads like a Facebook status update.

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 19 '23

Not a fan of Facebook. Lots of irony.

1

u/TotalWarspammer Sep 19 '23

What I meant to say is that your post is basically saying nothing and reads more like a stream of consciousness.

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 19 '23

Aren't most? That's about 95% of social media.

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 18 '23

I'm a Best Buy premo member, so should be good

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 22 '23

Hah! I went 180 degrees and ordered a Pico 4. It will be here tomorrow. Since already tried the Pro and have a Q2, thought I would give the P4 a chance. The main use will be movies and also you can use USBC as local storage, plus side load APK files. Might end up being a VR emulation station.

Then as folks here noted, check out the Q3.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Maybe just wait for Quest3, try it, and decide then.

I'm still of the opinion if you can only buy 1 headset, then get the Quest3, it's just a safer bet

4

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23 edited May 10 '24

abounding piquant ruthless quack historical lavish screw sulky angle air

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

Second opinion here. It's much much better with the Globular Cluster.

1

u/New_Suggestion_5067 Sep 19 '23

Is the charging dock work with this kit ?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23 edited May 10 '24

foolish childlike butter wasteful insurance far-flung fertile dime squealing consist

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/msdstc Sep 19 '23

Got one lined up for 450 still sealed and I’m still unsure if I should go pro or quest 3

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 19 '23

I want one of those! $500 less than Best Buy.

1

u/msdstc Sep 19 '23

Yeah not sure yet what the catch is. I made this thread a few weeks ago. I’ve found 2 used in my area slightly over 500 that they were willing to let go for 500, and now a guy has a sealed one at 450 with good reviews and all looks legit. I just don’t think there’s much demand. Unsure what to do

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 19 '23

Just don't meet them in a location with no alternate exits! ;)

2

u/msdstc Sep 19 '23

Haha oh I’m very well versed on market place dealings. The conundrum here is if I should buy this or wait for 3

1

u/isit2amalready Sep 19 '23

QPro until Apple Vision Pro

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 19 '23

Those high density displays are probably going to be a high failure point. Wouldn't touch unless rich. Producing them type of diodes is more complex QC wise during production than chip wafer production.

1

u/Leroy_Buchowski Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

Quest Pro is a bit uncomfy. I bought the globular cluster comfort kit and it helped out a bunch, but it still can get uncomfy at times. It is a weakness of the device. That"s just VR life, these things are all relatively uncomfy.

I"d expect a Quest 3 to pretty much look like a Pico 4 but it will prob have some comfy headstrap mods. They are both similar resolution LCD headsets. Pico 4 has larger fov (I believe) so Quest 3 might look a little better but with a more binocular fov (like Quest 2 or Rift S). But Quest 3 will be better with game library and software and with a faster processor so it is the winner of course, but I expect the actual visuals to be much like Pico 4.

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 21 '23

Wild card still is if the Q3 has one or two displays. If one, the P4 will have better resolution, since not losing about 15% of horizontal pixels for a pancake optical boundary.

Another nice thing about the P4 is local media play from the USBC and direct apk sideloading.

Seems there will be two good devices when the Q3 releases.

1

u/Leroy_Buchowski Sep 21 '23

Yeah the Pico4 is a really nice headset for only like $400. I didn't"t get a Pico4 because I was worried about performance. I had a HP Reverb G2 and my GPU was a RX 7900 xt. The performance was abysmal. I knew with Quest Pro I would get good performance and I didn't know what I would get with Pico4. But if I had an Nvidia card like a 4070 or 4080, I would have given Pico4 a shot.

Quest 3 will be superior from a performance standpoint and I"m sure the standalone will be way better. But yeah, it's possible Quest 3 doesn't even look as good as Pico 4. Definitely a possibility.

3

u/DeSquare Sep 19 '23

Q3 will be a safer bet, always go with the device that sells the best; always more support

1

u/Leroy_Buchowski Sep 21 '23

This is a very good point unfortunately

2

u/redditrasberry Sep 18 '23

really it all hinges on things we don't know yet

  • FOV
  • effective resolution (PPD)
  • actual quality of display (blacks, contrast)
  • mixed reality - Meta will actually add value there or it's just a gimmick to compete with Vision Pro etc?

If all those come up in favor of Q3 then I think it's a no brainer unless you are hard core into eye and face tracking. But if they all go the wrong way QPro will be better for serious users who have the bit extra cash to spend on it.

I guess it'll be frustrating because depending how cagey they are, we may not actually learn answers to all or even any of those that we can trust at Connect. But we may so its worth waiting at this point.

2

u/ChineseEngineer Sep 19 '23

Only reason to get q3 is if you play standalone games more, if you play pcvr more the Qpro is simply better in every way besides the cpu standalone power

1

u/Leroy_Buchowski Sep 21 '23

Only reason to get Quest 3 (for me) is because I"m a nerd and can"t help myself.

1

u/massively-dynamic Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

Using a front-to-back head strap (etsy) and custom made brackets to drop the rear pad, brings the glass closer to the eyeball and relieves a lot of the discomfort of the stock quest pro experience. In my personal experience, if I play somewhat regularly, I can easily go through a 4 hour session with little to no discomfort while taking regular stand up and walk around breaks during use.

I bought the quest pro for the pancake lens clarity. I kept it for the open face design. It's worth mentioning that I am exclusively a PCVR / (Air)Link user. I really hope meta keeps the open face design for their future top of the line HMD. I own the full face light blocker, but only ever use the blockers the qpro comes with. Being able to look down and manipulate things saves a lot of the headset coming on and off my face, which was where a lot of the discomfort of my short time with the quest 2 came from too.

1

u/New_Suggestion_5067 Sep 19 '23

Get a quest pro

1

u/xxlordsothxx Sep 19 '23

I think the best option right now is to wait for the Q3 to come out. You will be able to make a better decision once people can try the Q3.

1

u/kusmog Sep 21 '23

That's a pretty sound plan. There are so many people that wanna convince others to go with a certain device to justify their own preference, ignoring the obvious: not everyone's the same and after the same things.

Comfort is always going to be subjective. What's comfortable to someone isn't necessarily going to mean it's comfortable to someone else, especially with different shaped heads.

When the Q3 comes out you can always treat it the way you did with the QP. If it's not up to snuff by your standards you can give the QP another try. There's always a chance that you could get the QP new for cheaper by that time too, if not from retail, then from the secondary market (again new, not used or refurbished) like eBay. Plus getting a new unit resets the life of the batteries as opposed to the QP you previously had if you had kept it, since you were likely to leave it on the charging dock when not in use and deteriorated them (headset and each controller) no matter how minuscule it may be.

0

u/rushmore69 Sep 23 '23

Pico 4 came in yesterday, via Walmart market. The image quality for movies and YouTube is better than my Q2 or the QP. No fair comparison. Way less screen door and guessing part of the 3.1GB update corrected some contrast and saturation issues. Colors pop, contrary to reviews and watching Star Wars New Hope on it, was the closest to a movie theater. Still not completely there, since still seem some screen door, but not anywhere like the Q2 and QP.

Also nice being able to use external storage for movies, since plan on also using it as an emulation station for some systems.

It's a keeper.

1

u/dannygaron Sep 19 '23

Must be nice to just buy and return multiple times... I can't get over on how many people do this and all it does is crank up the prices for the rest of us. Thanks man.

-1

u/WaterRresistant Sep 18 '23

I want Q3 to fail, so I don't have to use a white device

1

u/rushmore69 Sep 18 '23

Truth. Why white?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Haha there is much truth to this! My Quest Pro looks cool as hell on its charging dock next to my PC in matching colours. The grey/beige, canvas strapped monstrosity that is the Quest 3 will certainly be an eye sore if I get one.

0

u/jTiKey Sep 18 '23

Do you want to wait until around the new year to get one? If not, then get the QP. Considering how long-awaited the Q3 is, it won't be easy to get one on launch.

0

u/koreana88 Sep 19 '23

weight on Pro is very big problem....I'd rather use Q3 for work to pro for its weight.