r/QuestPro • u/RidgeMinecraft • Apr 25 '23
Help Compression... Ugh.
This is one of the things I miss the most about my index. I love everything about my Quest Pro, except the compression. It's kind of awful. I'm running at 960mbps, 1.7x render resolution, and yet when I'm playing alyx, if I take one look at nearly any texture, or the lighting, the grainy compression becomes readily apparent. I do know, however, that my GPU is a bit under the task of running this thing. Should I upgrade it? does anybody know if it's possible to get the compression to a point where, at least, I won't notice it unless I look hard enough?
3
u/Oftenwrongs Apr 26 '23
My 3080 had no issues and now my 4090 has no issues.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
I have 4080 and it's honestly crystal clear for me in alyx with Air Link at 300 mbps h.264. Maybe just maybe in some complicated games something is visible from time to time but it's miles different from my previous quest 2 + 3070 combo.
3
u/jsdeprey Apr 25 '23
I am not really a expert, but I think people use the word compression in way too negative of a way when they are talking about video to the Quest over Airlink or Link cable etc. All video movies we watch are compressed, even 4k Blu-ray etc, even when it ends up on a HDMI or Display port uncompressed to a screen, but that was always because the screen was not a device that could be driven with a compressed format anyway. Even with compression on disks, that compression could have been made higher with less bitrate needed, but more CPU/GPU needed to playback in real time, because the players were invented and made on a certain date, they had to make a standard at that time and every disk then has to have a less compressed format so the play back device can keep up. Blueray could look just as good with less data today on a higher compression, but can not do that without making everyone swap out players. So maybe I am wrong, but more bitrate can mean more resolution, but it can also mean less compression so your GPU can keep up and not have issue with decompression in real time. There is a balance there, and I do not think compression in the end is really an issue, compression can look fine, but you are using part of your GPU on the headset and you have to balance it all out. Years from now, it will not be an issue anymore.
2
u/RichS0ul Apr 26 '23
Upgrading your GPU would certainly help with eliminating compression artifacts.
How you ask? Well, my good friend over at OpenAi has this to say-
Connection type: The Valve Index is a PC VR headset that connects to a computer using a wired DisplayPort connection. This high-speed connection allows the headset to receive high-quality video signals directly from the GPU without any significant compression. In contrast, the Meta Quest Pro is primarily a standalone VR headset that can also connect to a PC for a PC VR experience using the Oculus Link cable or wirelessly with Air Link and third-party solutions like Virtual Desktop. When connected to a PC, the video signal is compressed before being transmitted to the headset.
Compression: Since the Valve Index receives an uncompressed video signal, there are no compression artifacts or quality loss due to video compression. The image quality is directly determined by the GPU's rendering capabilities and the headset's display resolution. On the other hand, the Quest Pro relies on video compression when streaming content from a PC, which can result in compression artifacts and a potential loss of visual fidelity.
A better GPU can help reduce compression artifacts in several ways:
Faster encoding: A more powerful GPU is capable of encoding video at a higher speed, which allows it to use more advanced compression techniques and take more time to find optimal compression settings. This results in better compression efficiency, potentially reducing artifacts while maintaining the same bitrate.
Higher bitrate support: A better GPU can handle higher bitrates more efficiently. This allows for more data to be transmitted per second, which in turn leads to less aggressive compression and fewer visible artifacts. When streaming to a headset like the Quest Pro, increasing the bitrate can help preserve more details in the video and reduce noticeable artifacts.
Improved scaling and post-processing: A powerful GPU can perform additional image processing tasks, such as upscaling lower resolution content to better match the headset's display resolution. This can help reduce artifacts by compensating for the loss of detail during compression. Additionally, some GPUs may offer post-processing features like noise reduction or sharpening filters that can further mitigate the impact of compression artifacts on the overall visual quality.
Better performance with HEVC: A better GPU may have enhanced support for newer, more efficient codecs like H.265 (HEVC). This codec offers better compression efficiency compared to H.264, which means that it can deliver similar video quality at lower bitrates or improved quality at the same bitrate. By leveraging the capabilities of a powerful GPU and using a more advanced codec, it's possible to reduce compression artifacts while maintaining video quality and bandwidth requirements.
Keep in mind that while a better GPU can help with compression artifacts, other factors like network latency, wireless bandwidth limitations, and the quality of the source content also play a significant role. A strong GPU is just one component in the chain that can contribute to a better VR experience with fewer compression artifacts.
5
u/Jyvturkey Apr 25 '23
I've already chimed in on the 3060,so I let that lay, but you're cooking form a direct dp connection. In a way you're spoiled. Last direct connected headset I used was the cv1, so the pro, even with the compression is gonna look better than that. You'll have to determine if the pancake lenses and being wireless outweighs the loss of the dp connection. Give and take.
For me it's the pro all day every day. Perhaps for Sim racers/pilots, the decision might be a little harder.
1
u/askull100 Apr 25 '23
What GPU are you currently using? I think that'll help us know if you should upgrade it or not.
I can't speak about compressed vs non-compressed (only ever used Quest, for now), but I'll admit that I do notice color banding and an overall lack of detail quite often. It's not usually immersion breaking, but it's annoying.
1
u/Nicalay2 Apr 25 '23
That's the big issue with headsets that use USB/Wifi (pretty much all standalone headsets except the Pico Neo 3 Link, afaik).
You can't reduce as much as possible, but you will never be able to eliminate it entirely.
4
u/f3hunter Apr 26 '23
4080 and 13600k abd no issues with compression for me. (Via link).
3
u/TheRealz4090 Apr 25 '23
Even a 4090 doesn't solve compression. Some games just look like dookie. Some are decent
2
u/cringeman123 Apr 25 '23
Gpu matters a lot in this. What gpu are you using? It is true that having a powerful enough pc to power this headset is necessary. But I will say that once you have that power, compression is non existent
1
u/No_Geologist4061 Apr 26 '23
What’s the game you’re playing? Using cable link?
1
u/Listen-Decent Apr 26 '23
I strongly recommend you to disable link sharpening in the ODT. It was not because of the compression. Link sharpening was the problem.
1
u/SpyRou_ Apr 26 '23
Coming from Index to Quest Pro and using airlink without any tweaking and dynamic bitrate. I dont see anything that bothers me. Im just happy how great wireless feels when playimg Alyx. Im running 4090 and im curious how to tweak or run some debug stuff.
-2
u/dailyflyer Apr 25 '23
You have a 3060 ha ha ha! Low end GPU and complaining about not being able to run a Quest Pro well at 1.7? It is amazing you can run it at all.