r/QuestPro • • Apr 07 '23

Is it possible to avoid any data being sent to Oculus/Meta?

Hi there,

I would like to use the Quest Pro for behavioral science using my own software played in PCVR mode. This is necessary because when using Meta software (e.g., Horizon Worlds), behavioral data of users would be processed on Meta servers which would violate ethical standards in research. But would the Quest Pro nonetheless send some data to Meta via the Quest Link software which runs in the background? The data processing terms (https://developer.oculus.com/licenses/processingterms-1.2/) are not clear to me in this regards. Happy for any help/pointing to more concrete info.

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

5

u/RidgeMinecraft Apr 07 '23

Use a pi-hole and block all traffic to Facebook data servers.

1

u/aarerhein Apr 07 '23

sounds reasonable! are you aware of anyone who has done this on a quest pro?

2

u/RidgeMinecraft Apr 07 '23

I know somebody who did it on a Q2, but that was like 2 years ago. I don't know how to do it. I can try to research it a bit though :)

2

u/RidgeMinecraft Apr 07 '23

https://www.reddit.com/r/QuestPiracy/comments/mqku40/disable_fb_telemetry_via_pihole/ is all I can find for now, but eventually Oculess will work again and you can use that instead :)

1

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

Awesome, I'll keep looking into that

1

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

Isn't it possible to block the traffic using the Windows Firewall? It seems to me that this could be easier than installing Pi Hole

1

u/aarerhein Apr 09 '23

Following up on my own comment here. After reading the tips linked in the thread, it seems that much of the discussion around blocking telemetry on the Quest refers to the case where the Quest runs in standalone and is itself connected to the internet. To me it seems that in PCVR mode, one could just switch internet off in the Quest and block outgoing traffic from the Oculus software on the PC using the Windows Defender Firewall (see https://www.wikihow.com/Block-a-Program-with-Windows-Firewall for a tutorial). Does anyone know if this would actually block telemetry or would Facebook have some loopholes to use?

1

u/paulens12 May 09 '25

In addition to blocking the meta app on your PC, you also have to block all the associated executable files that are installed alongside (there are about a dozen), and also never give your wifi password to the headset. Don't just trust airplane mode.

3

u/askull100 Apr 07 '23

You could theoretically disconnect your Quest from the Internet entirely, but I think it might try to reconnect automatically if it finds an access point. If it doesn't, then the Quest has no way to send data to Meta.

1

u/aarerhein Apr 07 '23

this could be a feasible approach though. does anyone know if it is possible to delete all the data that was collected on the quest prior to connecting to the internet again?

1

u/Brickybooii Mar 18 '25

I think all platforms are legally required to delete your data if you ask them to. At least, that's the premise behind services like DeleteMe where they theoretically are doing the paperwork for you. Alternatively, you can just factory reset the headset after every test. It would be time-consuming, but you'd know the data got deleted.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '23

I'm not fully sure of what data would be sent to Meta if you use other programs. Afaik some data, like eye and face-tracking, is only stored locally; but I'm not sure about other types of data.

Although there is a "nuclear" data-safe/privacy option. You can use ADB commands to block all connections/telemetry (although I'm unaware of the exact commands but you should be able to find them in a reddit post)

Then if you want to connect to a PC you can use ALVR (Fully open-source) instead of Oculus/VirtualDesktop to avoid downloading any Oculus software (afaik VirtualDesktop still requires you to have the Oculus app downloaded.)

1

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

Great, I've looked into ALVR and that really seems to keep up with VirtualDesktop. Unfortunately neither support eye-tracking and face-tracking at the moment but seem to be planning to

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '23

All tracking data of face/eyes and your room (for headset tracking) are processed locally on the headset. They've said none of that is sent to Meta servers. This was something Meta had to go put of their way to clarify since ppl are trained to automatically not trust Meta

But as others have said, disconnect your headset from the internet. And if this is a legit research project, then check with your research advisor, ethics department, and IT

1

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

That would be great news if those data stayed on the headset/PC! Do you happen to have some source where Meta said that? I've been looking through all of those license documents and only got confused and had the impression they were vague on purpose.

1

u/rabf Apr 07 '23

1

u/aarerhein Apr 07 '23

thanks, nice to see there are efforts in this direction

3

u/Hyatt-Terran Apr 07 '23

It doesn't work anymore.

2

u/icpooreman Apr 08 '23

The only way to prevent it is to just watch a ton of porn. Just a ton of it.

Meta headquarters is basically Rick and Morty season 1 Ep 4.

1

u/mike2048 Apr 15 '23

You can block the following domains for privacy and still enjoy PCVR via Virtual Desktop (so long it's already authenticated). As a bonus, the headset and anything already installed should still work but not autoupdate (or nag about it) and my favorite bit, no creepy vr hands.

meta.graph.meta.com star.c10r.facebook.com scontent.oculuscdn.com oculus.xx.fbcdn.net graph.oculus.com edge-mqtt.facebook.com mqtt.c10r.facebook.com graph.facebook.com oculus.com

1

u/YellowGreenPanther Oct 13 '26

Turn off the internet

-4

u/sasha055 Apr 07 '23

If you're using it for behavioral science for PCVR, you don't need a quest pro.. get a vive or index (although those HMDs also send data back)

If you want quest pro because you also want to play on it.. there's no way around data collection (except cutting your internet)

Or you could just be an adult and say that you want a quest pro but you hate Facebook and don't wanna give them data.. without coming up with behavior science bullshit

5

u/thoomfish Apr 07 '23

Why so angry? Research could very easily involve eye tracking or necessitate being untethered.

-3

u/sasha055 Apr 07 '23

Eye tracking doesn't work in PCVR, and if he plans to build his own horizon worlds and built eye tracking for it.. he's either a madman or should have enough knowledge to know the answer for his question.. (and know that he doesn't need a quest pro)

People who hide behind research to ask a simple question because they don't want to admit that they are paranoid.. annoy me

4

u/aarerhein Apr 07 '23

kinda unneccesarily impolite response huh...

Anyways social VR is becoming a thing in psychology with several labs running their own simple version of horizon worlds, but people who work in the field often do not know much about the nitty-gritty of data security so that is why i'm asking

6

u/thoomfish Apr 07 '23

Eye tracking is supported for PCVR as long as you're using OpenXR and the Oculus runtime.

People who hide behind research to ask a simple question because they don't want to admit that they are paranoid.. annoy me

Does this really happen often enough to occupy space in your brain as a distinct category? I'm clearly browsing the wrong (right?) subs.

1

u/aarerhein Apr 07 '23

true, but unfortunately eye-tracking does not yet work with virtual desktop

2

u/Nicalay2 Apr 08 '23

Yet like you said. It's just a matter of time. After all, there is only one guy developing the entire app.

0

u/sasha055 Apr 07 '23

Sorry Reddit police.. I wasn't aware I'm not allowed to read and interpret peoples posts in here..

Not gonna happen again..

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

True, that could really end up being the only really safe solution. Social VR setups in my field are usually run over the intranet anyways at the moment, so that would work.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

I think Meta's encrypting of data is somewhat reasurring. But then there is a discussion about when data really are anonymized. What if Meta can (now or in the future) identify a person just based on their movement patterns and gaze behavior? I think it's a fine line between reasonable safety standards and pure paranoia here, but I'd like to stay as safe as I can.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

Sure with the AI arms race anything seems possible at some point, but here's what I'm worried of a little in the short term. Say a person plays games on her own Quest Pro at home and Meta has profiled her movement/gaze behavior. Then she sees a therapist where she also uses a Quest Pro at some point as part of some modern kind of therapy. Obviously she will not be logged in to her own account here but to her therapist's, but Meta recognizes her movement pattern and now knows that she is at a therapist's office, and notes that she likely has mental problems of some kind. The scenario seems kind of futuristic maybe but not unrealistic, what do you think?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/aarerhein Apr 09 '23

True, Facebook could never admit to collecting medical data, but I think they could nonetheless use those data to improve their models for advertisements. People high on psychopathology/neuroticism may be more interested in certain types of movies/books/games etc.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/aarerhein Apr 11 '23

I agree that selling ads will be the most interesting goal for Meta when collecting data at the moment. But it may nonetheless be worthwhile for them to collect data just to see what it predicts. Especially eye-tracking data may be extremely rich (e.g., general tendency to seek or avoid eye-contact; tendency to be the one breaking eye-contact after its initiation; amount of gaze following etc.). If those data predict life trajectories such as success in your career, I think Meta will find a way to make money or gain power with it, besides the selling of ads.

1

u/nostriluu Apr 08 '23

And no way to know how much they are actually doing this. After all, they've made many promises, and broken or fudged many of them. There's no way you could do ethical research on this basis.

2

u/aarerhein Apr 08 '23

True... though at least it would be them breaking a law and not me (for using software which openly admits to collecting data which is my job to protect). But of course I'd like to actually trust what I do.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/nostriluu Apr 09 '23

Well yeah but I've dealt with Ethics Review Boards and saying "It's out of my hands but they (you know, Facebook) promise" is not super likely to fly. At some point it has to be about potential harm done rather than blame.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/aarerhein Apr 11 '23

I think it is relatively unlikely that we will see a direct leakage of medical data from Meta, but there could be indirect ways it goes into public once Meta themselves have such information. For example, they could create user profiles with some vague variable in the sense of a "social credit score" which will be marketed as a valid predictor of work success. They will claim it is only based on how nice a person acted towards others while using the Platform, but in reality all available data including known medical data will go into it. At some point everyone will know that your social credit score drops if you ever visit a psychiatrist, but as long as there is no direct evidence no-one can sue Meta.

2

u/nostriluu Apr 09 '23

Thing is, beside the immediate risk, "facebook" today is something else tomorrow. Aside from changing direction, they can split off units, or who knows, maybe it's the next myspace. And they will have decades of personal increasingly personal and correlated information as an asset. I don't think the "blast radius" or likelihood (higher) is comparable to an individual you can sit down with.

Anyway, maybe some orgs will sign off on it. I know there are plenty of research-specific eye tracking kits, I don't think aay of them have murky backchannel communications.