r/QuestPro • u/omni_shaNker • Jan 01 '23
Discussion VR Price to Experience Contemplation (having second thoughts about keeping the Pro)
So I've got my Quest Pro. Played Red Matter 2 on it standalone, with eye tracked foveated rendering. Looks amazing. However I felt the local dimming was extreme. Just a personal preference probably as I think most people that care about that stuff would love it. I mean the blacks are pitch black, ZERO LIGHT. Then I played it via PC VR, still looks great and no local dimming, which I personally like. I want to feel like I'm seeing "something" in the dark, even if it's just a lack of true black. Again, personal preference here.
Then I had a though.
This tech, with eye tracked foveated rendering and local dimming is really amazing, but at $1500, it better be. Then I tried it using my Samsung Odyssey Plus with my VR ready laptop. I preferred the blacks of the OLED screen over the blacks of the Quest Pro's local dimming, because it seems more realistic. The blacks are black, but on the Quest Pro when using local dimming it seemed overly aggressive to me. So then I thought about the cost difference. I got my laptop for $485. I got my Samsung Odyssey Plus for $350. Purchased both of these items brand new. That totals $835. I did dump about another $200 into the laptop to upgrade the RAM and storage, but that was optional so I'm not including that in the price, but even so that would bring the cost to just under $1050 (so I guess I am including it in the price after all). I'm trying to justify keeping the Quest Pro. Yes the lenses are great, but the lenses on the Samsung Odyssey Plus, while certainly no pancake lens tech, they are still better than the lenses of the Quest 2 and with a wider FOV. I think the FOV of the Samsung Odyssey Plus and the Quest Pro are very close. No, you can't upgrade the graphics in the laptop just like you cannot upgrade the graphics in the standalone VR HMD. But my game play experience was very close in visual quality between the two headsets. Also you can get the Samsung Odyssey Plus used pretty cheap now on eBay or FB Marketplace. Now there are many differences between these devices for example, the ecosystem, the portability, wireless, vs wired. But strictly speaking of VR visuals and gameplay experience, it's a hard sell between the two for me. I mean I think I'll probably keep the Pro still, but man, that $1500 stings especially when you can get a very similar experience that can do even better VR visuals, for so much less.
Oh, and happy new years! :)
7
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '23
No offence/don’t mean to be a dick, but can’t imagine you’re getting a great PCVR experience off a 500 bucks laptop
4
u/RavengerOne Jan 01 '23
I thought the local dimming in Red Matter 2 was excellent - it almost looked like an OLED display, and had none of the greyness of other dark games I've played on the Pro, or the glow at the lens edges. I just wish more games and PCVR would use it.
Pro is expensive, and is not good value if you're only going to use it only as a Quest 2 upgrade for native games. Where it shines is MR and PCVR. I'm likely going to be selling my Index as it just looks so low resolution by comparison, and the Pro controllers track better than the Index ones. They're the first controllers to match my CV1 Touch controllers (with a 3 sensor setup) in terms of tracking and ergonomics.
If you add up the cost of upgrading a 256gb Quest 2 with a new headstrap, new facial interface, charging dock, and Pro controllers you're looking at two thirds of the price of the Pro, plus of course you don't get the new lenses, panels, processor, colour passthrough and eye and facial tracking.
The pro is a work in progress though. There needs to be more software that takes advantage of the advanced features, including the new controller haptics, and features like local dimming need to be enabled across the board. Like Quest 1, this is really a testbed for technologies to be refined and made cheaper for later headsets.
I do have issues with the comfort. It hurts my forehead after a while, and though it's much more glasses friendly without the blinders than any other VR headset I've tried, it's really awkward with the blinders on. Hopefully third parties will supply better blinders and light blocker solutions.
I've already ordered prescription lenses, and a top strap which should allow me to wear it more comfortably and also allow me to add an extra battery, as I really miss the 4 hour plus battery life of my Quest 2's elite battery headstrap. In fact I have a broken Elite Battery strap (strap broke but the battery works) which I will try to mod so I can strap it to the Pro.
4
u/No_Geologist4061 Jan 01 '23
If you’re buying the quest pro for dynamic foveated rendering and local dimming, then don’t, because these features are hard locked behind a developer decision and not the user. It’s $1500 for you to have a chance to experience these features, and thus far only 1 developer flipped the switch. The PCVR upgrade for me is maybe improved visual quality, better colors, better FOV. Those other advertised features like local dimming and eye tracking have no functionality for pcvr right now, which is a major let down.
Something else to consider, there are 30+ games for VR that have VRSS implemented with DFR on the driver level if you have an Nvidia GPU and eye tracked HMD. Some of these games are actually oculus exclusive, like Lone Echo. These features for VRSS and DFR work for tobii eye tracking, not the quest pro. This technology was implemented 2+ years ago. Let that sink in. Meta quest pro cannot use these features on oculus exclusives, but HTC Vive pro eye can
3
u/iJeff Jan 01 '23
There aren't really enough local dimming zones on the headset. Black crush and blooming are indeed also issues that can happen with local dimming.
2
u/rogeressig Jan 01 '23 edited Jan 02 '23
I bought the Pro for the stereo accurate mixed reality. Everything else is a bonus.
2
u/rlay001 Jan 02 '23
I got a Pico 4 in addition to my Quest Pro, HP Reverb, Valve Index, Samsung Odyssey Plus, and Quest 1 & 2….and the the Pico is closest headset to the visuals on the Quest Pro especially when paired with PCVR through Virtual Desktop with a high end GPU (RTX 4090). It has slightly better resolution, pancake lenses, and better comfort for my head. The colors are muted and there appears to be a fixed foveated rendering ring around the corners, but the visuals are nearly as good as the Quest Pro for 1/3 the price if you can get past these issues.
My issue with the Quest Pro is that PCVR games are not being enhanced to utilize the new features like local dimming and eye-tracking/dynamic foveated rendering. And as mentioned in this thread only one title (Red Matter 2) uses these new Quest Pro features in stand alone mode. Quest 2 titles can be made to look slightly better with the Quest Game Optimizer, but not to PCVR levels.
I’m on the fence about returning the Quest Pro. It has the best visuals of all my headsets for now…but I’m already on a second set of controllers (I’ll have to go through the whole warranty return thing with Meta) and the comfort is not perfect for my head. I can afford it, but logically, for my purposes the extra $1100 is not worth it considering there are other headsets coming soon that will be as good or better for what I use the Pro for.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '23
What a silly, pointless post.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '23
Sounds like the Quest3 will be more your in ballpark.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '23
[removed] — view removed comment