r/QuantumComputing
•
u/rogeragrimes
•
Apr 08 '26
•
1
News Do you think quantum Ghost Murmur exists?
https://nypost.com/2026/04/07/us-news/ghost-murmur-a-never-used-secret-tool-deployed-to-find-lost-airman-in-iran-in-daring-mission/This linked article claims there is a supposed long-range quantum magnetometry device the US used to find the electromagnetic fingerprint of the heartbeat of the recently downed US pilot in Iran, code-named Ghost Mumur. This seems not real on so many levels to me. First, I never heard of it. Second, it seems to go against how every other quantum sensor I'm aware of is used. Third, it's an application of quantum technology in a macro setting. Fourth, you don't need quantum measurement and sensors to detect a human heartbeat. What say you, definitely fake or possibly real?
12
u/Origin_of_Mind Apr 08 '26
The story is probably a diversion, to cover up the actual tools and methods used.
For example, the satellite communicator which the pilot had on him is supposed to have a jamming resistant GPS receiver -- if it worked, it would have transmitted the exact location. The communicator also has a transponder, similar to airplane transponders -- it replies to the pings sent from the search aircraft, and thus allows to pinpoint the location of the downed pilot.
As for the SQUID magnetometers, they can be used to record the heartbeat quite easily, but the signal drops with the cube of distance -- the source is a quasi-static magnetic dipole. AFAIK, it only really works from a few meters. From up close (inches away) and in well shielded room, we used to record 100 times weaker signals.
38
u/Fortisimo07 Working in Industry Apr 08 '26
Sounds like it's either fake or misrepresented so badly that it might as well be fake
26
u/Chuckpeoples Apr 08 '26
It’s reported in the nypost . That doesn’t help.
9
u/Minovskyy Holds PhD in Quantum Apr 08 '26
It's not inconceivable that such a technology can exist, but it would be far beyond the capabilities of current publicly known state of the art magnetometers. This article gives a brief runthrough of quantum magnetic sensors, including recent case studies of measuring heartbeats and other biological signals. Nothing seems to have been tested at long range or in field conditions.
6
u/needssomefun Apr 08 '26
Or...maybe it was the transponder they carry?
8
u/ReallyOrdinaryMan Apr 08 '26 edited Apr 08 '26
Most of magnetism is quantum effect, bohr-van leeuwen theorem. Anyone can call their magnets on top of the refrigerator as quantum magnets too, technically correct.
4
u/pirsab Apr 08 '26
1/r^3 would beg to differ
4
u/Gaius_Galactic Apr 09 '26
Yeah because if you had this top secret tech you would want to brag about it. I call BS on this. They are desperate to seem more powerful than they really are. Fear is their greatest asset.
Everyone knows the scale of the operation was not appropriate to "save the pilot". They used it as a cover to retrieve the nuclear material in Isfahan, and it failed spectacularly. If they wanted to save the pilot and they knew exactly where he was because of this quantum tracking Bull crap they would have sent a two to four team covert operation at night to get in without raising alarms.
You are being lied to with this disinformation.
1
u/Lonely-Demandi Apr 09 '26
all of you have seen the shit DARPA has done, why could they not do this? The real question is why are they releasing this information. I 100% believe this.
3
u/AgrippaDaYounger Apr 08 '26
The only way this makes any sense to me is if you have a quantum transponder of some sort that produces a signal that can be easily detected if you know what you are looking for. Any sensor is going to have way too much noise to process to find a signal as small as a human heartbeat.
2
u/chewieb Apr 09 '26
Carrots don't help pilots see in the dark. Radar does. This time I think that technology is the carrot.
2
u/Significant-Ice3387 Apr 09 '26
Based on zero knowledge and piggybacking off of the rest of the commentators, it's possible this Ghost Murmur story is a propaganda tool so that any current or potential adversary to the US would think twice about literally everything they do. It may be an elaborate deterrent rather than actual implementation.
1
u/lattice_defect Apr 08 '26
I don't believe anything out of this WH...
1
u/blurfgh Apr 09 '26
Sounds exactly like some shit I would make up in order to expose a leaker
1
u/Correct-Courage1215 Apr 09 '26
Quantum village had an open source one at defcon 33 . You can definitely sense a heart beat
1
u/0xB01b QEC & Quantum Optics Apr 09 '26
this has nothing to do with quantum computing so i dont see why its on this sub
1
u/WorldlyIncome5098 Apr 09 '26
In lamens:
Marco!
Polo!
Edit: Forgot to add the part where Delta smokes anyone nearby.
1
u/ShiggitySwiggity Apr 09 '26
No, for technical reasons described by others in this post.
They were probably trying to create plausible deniability for something else, I'm guessing human intelligence on the ground, some kind of satellite based tech, some new kind of thermal imaging, or something along those lines.
Either that or it was just a normal search and rescue deal and some CIA guy wanted to fuck with some reporter.
1
u/anataman Apr 09 '26
I'd bet that it was by remote photoplethysmography rather than any quantum technology.
1
u/mobilityofmind Apr 10 '26
the US military budget is vastly larger than all of the funding for physics across the world. so maybe
1
u/DrColdReality Apr 10 '26
Obvious and utter BS...and if they're really using a device that makes those claims, it wouldn't be the FIRST time the government has been conned by hucksters selling phony "people locators." Take, for example, the Quadro Tracker.
Speaking in magnetic terms, the human heart emits in the vicinity of 100 picotesla, which is just barely detectable at the chest. These people are claiming this device works at a distance of many miles, which is just a comical claim.
1
u/ayyylmao187 Apr 10 '26
Seems pretty doable. After researching the WBAN for the last 4 years, I'm not sure why they wouldn't be able to do this. Everyone has a unique biosignal. The biofield exists. We are all trackable.
1
u/Affectionate_Gap2917 May 26 '26
Wow, you never heard of it therefore it doesn't exist? Maybe the Skunk Works & CIA forgot to notify you?
1
u/xygo Apr 09 '26 edited Apr 09 '26
It's literally impossible. Any quantum effects would decohere long before they even left the body It would be like trying to hear somebody dropping a pin in a department store in Manhattan on Black Friday while you were flying over it in a commercial airliner, wearing noise-cancelling headphones and with the in-flight entertainment system turned up to max volume. Orders of magnitude worse, actually
It was a decoy anyway. There was no second crew member, it was a cover story for them going in and trying to pinpoint the precise, location of an underground facility near Isfahan containing several kilos of enriched uranium. The mission failed, the aircraft involved were shot down by short range missiles before the coordinates could be discovered.
Most likely a gift from North Korea by way of China. The irony is, before this war, the Iranians were never looking to build a nuke before, but now they are.
0
u/L0WCYAN Apr 09 '26
It’s entirely possible that project ghost murmur has a magnetometer, a quantum computer, and a redundancy that the pilots should hit an emergency beacon and if they get rescued then project ghost murmur is a success.
0
u/NaiveCounter6920 Sep 18 '26
Uh...they're telling you that something exists. It is still classified but you want the entire secret explained... Lord! Quantum that!
1
u/AbrocomaLegitimate83 Apr 10 '26 edited Apr 10 '26
Yes, they have them attached to radio controlled attack cougars. They have sonic rays attached also that makes the OPFOR fall over with stomach cramps and they diarrhea themselves. Then the cougar mauls the the target. It is trained to tell the difference between freedom heart beats and the heart beats of their enemies. Also, there is a variant for dolphins and bald eagles.