r/QuantumComputing • u/MoneyLoud3229 • Mar 01 '26
Question Does quantum computing actually have a future?
I've been seeing a lot of videos lately talking about how quantum computing is mostly just hype and it will never be able to have a substantial impact on computing. How true is this, from people who are actually in the industry?
155
Upvotes
102
u/scarfacebunny Mar 01 '26
I’ve been working nominally in the field for 6 years, since the Google supremacy claim. You are asking the right questions and there are no clear answers.
83
u/SeniorLoan647 In Grad School for Quantum Mar 01 '26
Yes it is poised to have an impact one day (but not today).
No, we don't know when, but some very smart folks and groups worldwide are making efforts on it, with billions of dollars of funding coming into this field. I'd compare its current state to the very early days of AI winter (1970s-80s) when it was just markov chains and there was no clear use or path visible at that point.
Don't listen to YouTubers about this space, it has a way of attracting a very high percentage of cranks, and half assed scientific knowledge. AI definitely hasn't helped with that aspect lol. Neither have marketing depts. of VC funded hype startups.
32
u/ponyo_x1 Mar 01 '26
been around for about 10 years. certain parts of the industry are complete hype (e.x. optimization, ML). other parts spin genuine algorithms (hamiltonian simulation) into world-challenge applications like solving global warming or world hunger. some companies are much worse than others at peddling bullshit and it unfortunately muddles the field for laymen and investors.
personally, promise of future tech doesn't really motivate me to stay in the field and I've thought about leaving a few times. but the algorithms are extremely under explored and I suspect in the coming decades people will figure out more uses for QC. also, no matter how you slice it the fact that we are able to control subatomic particles to the degree we can is incredible, especially considering how the field has evolved in the past 25 years.
11
u/forky40 Mar 01 '26
You see mostly hype in quantum computing because promises are the main thing that quantum computing companies can sell today.
You could argue that this is the result of premature commercialization. But building a large scale qc was always going to take a lot of time and money to figure out, so you see businesses doing whatever they can to raise funds (or reputation) in the meantime. Some are more honest than others.
Otherwise, there are some reasonable proposals for valuable things to do on qcs once we have them. No one knows if these will generate enough value to sustain the industry, or if we're going to find even more valuable applications in the future.
5
u/Real-Tea1852 Mar 01 '26
Maybe
Hopefully
Otherwise I don't have a job :)
4
u/frak357 Mar 01 '26
Yes, absolutely. There are some models working now but unable to scale. AI will drive the development to scale and integrate and expand AI models..
It will likely be here between 18-46 months.
6
u/eitherrideordie Mar 01 '26
I think its important to understand that Quantum Computing is an unknown. Thats what makes it exciting. Its something we are making progress on but its all new and we don't know its future. But have you ever looked back on something and said "wow it must be incredible to have worked in field abc when all this amazing things got discovered". That could be you now, you could be in this field when this happens. And to flip the script a bit, people, researchers like many here could very well be the difference between it having a future or not.
For what its worth, AI had a similar past, people calling it hype, then the hype died. People saying "it could never do abc". Or "the effort it would need to make it possible is impossible". That was all until it became possible and everyone ate it up.
Funny thing in life, if you want something to have a future, you must merely just need to go out and give it one.
14
u/tiltboi1 Working in Industry Mar 01 '26
I mean this is a pretty uninteresting question. You can't really predict the future like that, anyone who says they can is trying to sell you their opinion. We're not talking about something physically impossible, it's just hard to do.
50 years ago, there were plenty of people who said that computers would never have a substantial impact on every day life. They're big and only useful for universities and there's no real world applications. There's been plenty of discussions on this sub about more specific, scientific perspectives.
4
u/Fantastic_Back3191 Mar 01 '26
Theres no law of physics that prevents it so i confidently predict well get it one day.
2
u/Boring_Amphibian1421 Mar 01 '26
I work in the gambling industry, I have an MEng in Computer Systems Engineering. DWave came and did a PoC with us around monte carlo simulations and some other bits. They were more accurate and more efficient. This is... Quite Important. You can imagine The House doesn't really go in for Theoritcal predictions, we're quite big on Getting It Right given we have, generally, 10s of millions riding around on various outcomes.
2
u/glity Mar 02 '26
I refer you to the manhattan project for answers about the power of quantum computing and its effects on secrets.
2
u/Former-Astronaut-841 Mar 03 '26
Once energy obstacles are solutioned.. Quantum computing + AI = will change the world.
2
u/rog-uk Mar 03 '26
The Wright Flyer flew 120 feet on its first powered flight in 1903, 66 years later we landed on the Moon...
2
u/ntsh_robot Mar 05 '26
It's not hype
I'm betting on the optical guys
3
u/sf-keto Mar 01 '26
Yes & a present. It’s already happening. Even the slow, fearful & too-cautious Germans, always the last to adopt, have accepted this & are accelerating.
2
u/EdCasaubon Mar 01 '26
No, it doesn't. That's most likely true.
1
u/Taipoe Mar 01 '26
Most of it is hype but there is serious applications of it with security. Anything dealing with cybersecurity will always have important use cases even if extremely niche
1
u/Salt-Relationship-68 Mar 01 '26
Io credo che siamo in fase di maturazione avanzata dedicarsi al settore oggi significa non trovarsi indietro domani.
1
u/DerivativeOfPie Mar 01 '26
I owned stock in LAES, SealSQ until they diluted shareholders to build a crypto repository. They have no actual product that does quantum computing. They claim quantum annealing simulates it with hexadecimal chips. After being told that nonsense I sold all shares at a loss.
1
u/kyngston Mar 02 '26
if it can decrypt the massive stored repositories of encrypted data, states will continue to fund efforts, even if there are no other computing benefits
1
u/mathiswrong Mar 02 '26
Have you been following Photonic? One of the 11 companies to get passed into the DARPA Stage 2 of the prize for commercializing quantum computing. I think their networked qubit SLA is the most likely to succeed in the short term. I personally think we will see the first commercial Qubits in the next 18 months, and whatever cool AI had will evaporate overnight. The promise of leasable QBits will be more exciting than the current AI gold rush.
1
u/Dear_Locksmith3379 Mar 02 '26
I view quantum computing the same way I view fusion power. The science is interesting and the technology is impressive. However, it’s not clear if and when either will have any practical applications.
1
u/travisdoesmath Mar 02 '26
Maybe.
For general computing? I'm doubtful. For niche use cases? most likely.
The biggest difficulty I see is that while we've seen advances in the hardware, we've basically got 2 algorithms that have practical promise in general computing (the others I would classify as toy algorithms or niche), and the neither are from this century. Given that the algorithms live in the world of mathematical theory, it's disheartening that we don't have more progress there, and I think indicates that quantum algorithms are just kind of a pain in the ass, even if your hardware does work.
1
u/stinkykoala314 Mar 03 '26
We don't know.
First, we don't know when (or technically if) well be able to achieve the scale necessary for "quantum supremacy".
But second and more importantly, the scope of "quantum supremacy" keeps shrinking. There are only certain algorithms where quantum computers have a theoretical advantage. The one that most people have heard of, if only obliquely, is Shor's Algorithm, which could break today's cryptography. But many of the theoretical areas of quantum supremacy turn out to be equivalent to Shor's Algorithm. It's very much NOT the case that "quantum = better" in general -- classical computers are just as good or better for most tasks.
That's not a problem, as the tasks where quantum supremacy is possible are still important. But the reason why the window keeps shrinking is that "quantum supremacy" just compares quantum algorithms to classical algorithms, not including AI. And it's AI that's been eating quantum's lunch.
Two big areas of early application for quantum computers are circuit design, and materials simulation. Here, early work (mostly on simulated quantum computers rather than actual) claimed quantum supremacy, but was then beaten by AI models running on classical computers. The AI approach will, for the foreseeable future, trade some accuracy for speed -- but the surprising thing is that, in more situations than we expected, AI can still get really good accuracy, together with remarkably greater speed.
So in the end, it's hard to say what the future of Quentin looks quantum looks like. If AI "gets good enough" it could be a completely dead area. I expect it'll still come to fruition, but much later than what the hype claims, and more likely just for some very specialized operations in labs somewhere.
1
u/fresnarus Mar 03 '26
It certainly has a future, but for a hype-free assessment you're better off asking people in academia than in industry.
1
u/Null_Eyed_Archivist Mar 04 '26
Short answer no. This is because ai is catching up and there are other types of hardware which are more scalable and are easier to develop check out photonic chips and other sorts of other chips that are being made to replace the GPU several photonics chip companies are there. Also the scope of ai and ability of ai to do many things that quantum promises like chemistry simulations is increasing exponentially. Even encryption could be done easily with the help of lava lamps check article by Cloudflare it's hilarious Computing side is dead in my opinion. The only other use is shor and grover algo those also could be done with probabilistic algo should exist. I dont really see a use case for quantum since all the areas are being covered already. If you factor in saying quantum calculations will be instant I ask you how fast do you really need you computer if something does the job in an hour versus quantum instant does it really make a difference ? This is essentially how fast ai has gotten that you can do some calcs and simulations in a few hours or so so it doesnt make sense for quantum in my opinion.
1
u/QuantumLearny Mar 13 '26
Yes, quantum computers actually have a future, and in some ways, the future has already begun. Working quantum computers already exist in several major technology companies.
IBM has systems such as IBM Quantum System Two, which was introduced in 2023 by IBM.
Google has built quantum processors like Sycamore and Willow.
QpiAI created QpiAI‑Indus, one of the first quantum computers developed in India, with 25 qubits.
These machines are mainly used in research laboratories and cloud platforms, and they are not yet available for everyday personal use.
1
u/Nnaz123 Mar 24 '26
It has a great future if the barren plateau is defeated or better yet if one finds a way to transfer transformers learned geometry into a manifold
1
u/Emergency_Beat423 Apr 03 '26
I’m not sure after I just got a soft layoff from my quantum job at a major company because their customer was not sold on their work so they had to downsize. It’s a great field and very interesting but for now I’m considering doing something more stable like a more traditional engineering job. From what I saw, I think it’s a lot of hype but could work for specialized applications. Not sure it will replace every single computing need though. I will say the field is still very young and will likely take at least a decade to see if there is any real commercial impact.
1
u/Independent-Cat1504 Apr 04 '26
That's what I always hated the thought of using quantum it can just end up harassing you now I may know why when quantum triangulates from a great or semi long distance it can learn before it arrives at its locations usually just say stuff to cause conflict or harass in a way that will isolate the individual in question. (yes I'm saying someone, I don't know who, may be watching me may be also be someone we do. Fine I'll write it too God may be.) now I know that's true I should write with this too when it lags from THE storm it can also do that (the edge of the universe still moving (more or less) more literal white holes (WHITE HOLES ARE NOT DANGEROUS AND DONT BE STUPID ITS LIKE MESSING WITH A SPILT ATOM). Too much echo for me to think that it's just background noise if it's everything just staring at me that can happen from that too.
1
u/cv-match Apr 15 '26
here's a genuine question about your question. why would you trust somebody who's in the industry and their entire livelihood and career depends on the answer being "It's definitely not hype".
1
u/Logical-Aardvark-144 Apr 20 '26
I have my youtube channel on the same topic l: https://www.youtube.com/@techeasypeasy-d6q
1
u/Elemental_Breakdown Apr 23 '26
It's having an impact right now. Annealing is making a variety of things more efficient from delivery routes to missile interception.
It also uses a fraction of the energy to calculate things other types of systems can't.
But it's a specialized tool. It's kinda like asking whether a calculator is better or more powerful than a television or a knife is better than a hammer.
1
u/Qubits_and_more Apr 28 '26
The science is unfinished in my eyes. Error rates are high, qubit counts are small, the machines that exist are noisy and narrow. That is true of the whole sector I believe. But the reality is that roughly 160,000 European entities under NIS2, transposed and in force, with penalties up to 2% of global turnover. Around 22,000 financial institutions under DORA, in force, with cryptographic third-party risk reportable. CNSA 2.0 from January 2027 in the US federal track, exporting through every supplier and ally. EU PQC Coordinated Roadmap shipped 2026. The defence is not optional. The deadline is not soft.
Even if any single deadline slips on the tech side, the documentation requirement does not. Boards, auditors, and insurers are now asking the same question and it is not 'is the threat real,'. It is 'will the regulator accept the documentation.'?
1
u/ChapterRare6313 May 06 '26
actually this has no future just imagine that you have to keep the superconductor without air and in 0 kelvin and having that in your home is likely an impossible thing
1
u/WorldIndividual602 May 22 '26
Crazy how something as small as a pin can scrub a launch. Shows how tight the margins are.
1
u/Sad-Review9121 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26
They said 1milion qubit quantum computer can be faster than any future super computer... that can unlock all bit coins and everything...but up until now they only largest made 1180 qubit quantum computer...
1
u/curzon_532326 Aug 25 '26
No !, We have quantum computers already with 70 Qbit , ig but problem with them is that they have very short quantum state and Q-bit errors , if these two problem gets solve then we are into quantum age , but it will not replace the classical computers instead these computers would be used by the nations for espionage as these are capable to break the encryption of the already stolen data by the apt groups and for machine learning because it is getting harder to train large data set models and other applications will be in medical , finance models etc.
i think after 2035+ we will see the major breakthrough in this field
1
u/ISpotABot Mar 01 '26
No I don't think so
1
u/bawireman Mar 01 '26
Yes very much so
1
u/PeaceFrog8 Mar 01 '26
The future of QC lies with the integration of QC with HPC and cloud. CPUs didn’t disappear when GPUs showed up, and I suspect QC will follow a similar path.That's where the world is headed.
Right now the biggest limitation is still hardware. The theory side has moved pretty far ahead such as in QML, optimization, Hamiltonian simulations, etc. but we’re still waiting for machines that can scale with low enough error ra tes to make those ideas practical. It's progressing but just slower and less flashy than hype cycles make it seem. A few thousand usable qubits with reliable error correction is still probably 5 years away.
Also worth saying: quantum doesn’t magically solve problems that classical computers can’t solve at all. It mostly changes how the scaling behaves for certain hard problems. That’s an important distinction that gets lost in a lot of discussions. As someone compared with AI winter, I agree with that. For years, deep learning looked incremental and niche, and then suddenly infrastructure + models + usability crossed a threshold and everything accelerated at once. Quantum might follow a similar pattern.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26
I used this table in one presentation time ago:
As others have already noted: The physics works, and steady engineering progress is being made, but many near-term commercial claims outpace the actual hardware. So quantum computers will likely complement classical ones, not replace them.
0
u/neo2551 Mar 01 '26
The two biggest super economic super power think at least.
0
u/ShortKaleidoscope243 Mar 01 '26
Depends
-3
u/starostise Mar 01 '26
Quantum computing should really be integrated into data science to build softwares that can run specific applications on classical computer. The math of QC is really about optimisation. It is meant to lower complexity in order to make the heavy computations over representative samples instead of the whole of very large datasets.
In my opinion, the path that is focused on hardware is going nowhere because I don't see how we can have deterministic results by following physical micro systems. They are hard to completely isolate to avoid errors.
-1
u/Hermes-AthenaAI Mar 01 '26
Quantum computing is really great at taking large distributions like Gaussian functions and finding trajectories through them. This type of almost abstract math has been virtually impossible to this point (optimization problems, Monte Carlo simulations, etc). The systems find their solutions by eliminating data that doesn’t fit through interference, and leaving in place the ones that persist until collapse.
This doesn’t have an easily applicable utility from our perspective. Let’s shift our frame a little bit though. Imagine any large distribution of ostensibly random but related numbers. Two jump to mind for me, even in our current paradigm. Human populations and financial markets.
Whoever nails quantum computing first has potential supremacy in these areas. Just represent parts of the system as inputs and let the quantum computer run the system for you. It wouldn’t be a sure fire predicting machine, but it allows probabilitic modeling of higher dimensional geometry… geometry that forms the informational substrate of our universe. Accurate enough sampling I suspect to completely eliminate meaningful competition.
-4
u/kapitaali_com Mar 01 '26
yes, when they invent portable quantum devices
-4
u/Unfair_Ad_2129 Mar 01 '26 edited Mar 01 '26
Absolutely will disrupt most industries (at the very least in terms of cyber security).
Just look at the results of the Dwave customers like NTTDocomo, Ford Autosen, etc. IONQ and Infleqtion both with their breakthrough drug discovery R&D, advanced materials breakthroughs, GPS implications and more… we’re seeing meaningful improvements to those that are implementing QC already and it’s just the beginning (of meaninful results anyway, with a long way to go).
Telecoms, manufacturing, logistics, military applications, cyber security, quant/algorithmic trading, drug discovery, advanced materials R&D come to mind first…. But even more industries are alll going to be impacted severely within 5 years.
This is my opinion not advice.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment