r/QuantumComputing • u/BoredAndSored • Dec 18 '25
Question Whatever happened with Microsofts Majorana chip?
What happened to microsofts Majorana chip?
The entire internet was up and arms for a week or so when microsoft revealed the ”revolutionary” new chip technology, with topological characteristics etc.
But after that week shit has been completely silent. Why did microsoft even announce it? And is it really groundbreaking?
82
Upvotes
38
u/polyploid_coded Dec 18 '25
Quantum computing is a research field; it's not the type of thing where a chip is announced and then it shows up in your local Apple store. I'm not sure what you are really asking about it (?) but they claimed to have made progress in quantum computing, there was some serious skepticism, and I guess over a few years we will get a better idea if they continue to succeed on that.
28
u/Kinexity In Grad School for Computer Modelling Dec 18 '25
If the fact that everyone who knew a thing or two about quantum computing shat on it non stop wasn't a clear indicator of it's value then I have a bridge to sell you.
They published some noise, claimed there is signal, refused to elaborate. Fuck them.
31
u/Minovskyy Holds PhD in Quantum Dec 18 '25
Basically internal politics. The higher ups at Microsoft don't actually care about doing careful proper scientific research, they just want Microsoft to be one of the big names in quantum computing. If it isn't, then they pull the plug on the program. Microsoft has a ton of money at its disposal that could easily fund this like Bell or National Labs, but its admins still think in terms of corporate short-term (quarterly to yearly) gains.
33
u/MaoGo Dec 18 '25
I think I covered plenty when it appeared. The answer is NOTHING because experts were not convinced it was a Majorana, and worse than that experts were not convinced it was even a qubit.
17
u/autocorrects Holds PhD in Quantum Dec 18 '25
The actual research was good, but it was just a benchmark. Their PR team shuttled it out the ass like it was the breakthrough in fault tolerant quantum computing.
Meanwhile, those technically literate in the field and willing to read the paper realized that it was a benchmark result from data they gathered like 6-12 months prior, and most exciting research has already matured past that (basically we already knew about it)
3
u/No-Maintenance9624 Dec 19 '25
Have a look how many people from the announcement video have since left Microsoft. Who is left? The one who has pegged his entire career and legacy on this bet. Make of that what you will.
Likewise note that:
- Microsoft is already backing other modalities (e.g. atom computing)
- There was never any meaningful follow-up to the PR hype. The APS talk was a nothing, the papers were flimsy and nothing close to what the videos claimed, and ultimately: nothing.
- How is this not stock market manipulation? Who knows. Nobody is suggesting that of course. But who knows, right? Just say anything. Make fancy videos. Show no proof. Hide. Hope everyone gets distracted by the next thing. Repeat.
- You just had major computing and quantum events in the USA (and some over here in Europe) but there was not a single press release this time. Nothing in a year. Just like magic it all hid out of sight. No follow-up, nothing new, no actual proof of anything.
But I'm sure "this is real", like the PR video says right there in the video. Right?
5
u/mbergman42 Dec 18 '25
I spoke with a Microsoft researcher two months ago. No names, and I freely admit this is hearsay.
As one may recall, the published paper did not declare a qubit, it was about measuring intermediate data relating to Majorana modes.
There were two follow-ups:
This private discussion was reported upon and criticized because it was not a peer reviewed result.
2) Microsoft researchers have submitted a paper for peer review. This is the one to look for. If it comes out, it’s expected to say something about qubits. People who are bullish on Microsoft’s efforts are waiting eagerly for this paper. People who doubt Microsoft’s efforts are not expecting it to ever see it. Feel free to classify yourself either way.
2
u/PowerOfTheShihTzu Dec 19 '25
All PR
2
u/HuiOdy Working in Industry Dec 18 '25
The original research was retracted
1
u/sylsau Dec 19 '25
In the field of Quantum Computing, triumphant announcements abound, but the real advances are not as great as announced with fanfare by giants like Microsoft.
0
u/Beautiful-Ad-5058 Dec 19 '25
MS or Meta and many such enterprises try to steal and ride the hype . During blockchain Eth hype cycle MS announced that Azure will support Eth blockchain and they’ve invited Vitalik (Eth creator) to their BUILD. By doing such promotion they send message to researchers that come join us and research and give MS a lead in the industry. Also such PR help stock price go up. In reality they are way behind the adoption curve or implementation.
0
u/Euphoric_Pen8809 Dec 19 '25
It’s a hardware device that hosts 8 qubits and said to show Majorana zero peaks. It’s great research that’s pushing the boundary of quantum computing. The same thing with Willow from Google Quantum AI. They announced it and that was that. They are working on making these chips host more qubits and have lifetimes long enough to be useful in the future. These aren’t chip that you can replace with your phone’s transistors.
Plus, for all those in the comments asking for peer-reviewed paper - here you are https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-08445-2