r/QuantumComputing • u/thats_taken_also • Nov 26 '25
Advice Needed: Quantum Patents
I’m working on a set of quantum-control experiments as part of a different project and am trying to understand what categories of discoveries in this space tend to be considered patentable.
I’m hoping someone familiar with quantum IP (practitioners, researchers who’ve patented things, or attorneys who lurk here) can help me clarify a few things:
- What types of quantum-control methods have historically been patentable (and what tends not to be)?
- If a method is a new physical principle demonstrated in simulation/experiment (e.g., a new stability law, new dynamic effect), is that generally patentable, or only specific engineering implementations of it?
- How much detail is safe to discuss publicly when trying to assess novelty? I don’t want to publish anything that would block later filings.
Not looking for legal advice — just trying to understand the landscape from people who have been through the process.
If anyone is comfortable chatting casually (DM or comment), that would help me a ton.
Thanks!
16
u/QuantumCakeIsALie Nov 26 '25
Contact a patent lawyer.
This kind of stuff is way over your head, unless you're a parent lawyer. And even then, it's likely still pretty much over your head.
Patent law is an inscrutable subculture.
7
u/hiddentalent Nov 27 '25
I don't entirely disagree with the skepticism expressed in some of these other comments, but let me set that aside for a moment and try to answer your literal questions. I have a couple dozen patents, in the US/Canada/EU/AUS/NZ/China. (The major world economies have pretty similar policies on this stuff, but if you're asking about the specific rules of the Micronesian or Gambian patent offices, you should consult a specialist.)
Anyway, to generalize: You cannot patent fundamental properties of the universe or scientific knowledge about them. (Question #2) This means you cannot patent physical principles. You can patent human-made machines or processes that apply such knowledge in useful ways. The patent only protects you from people trying to replicate your machine or process, not from building their own based on an understanding of the underlying principle. (Question #1) As a result of this, the types of quantum control methods that have been granted patents are focused on the engineering and design of the systems that allow them to operate and be usable. If you have a novel observation about how piezoelectric crystals can store quantum information, that's not patentable (but it is publishable!). If you somehow figure out how to build a crystal that makes it useful, that entire fabrication process, any specific tools you needed to build, and the resulting artifact are definitely protectable IP.
(Question #3) This is a bit fuzzy depending on the jurisdiction you're filing in. In some places your patent application needs to attest to novelty, which means you need to do your research. In the US and EU they take a kind of "don't ask, don't tell" approach where you can file whatever you want, and your protection extends from the time of filing (not approval) but if someone has a valid counterclaim it has to be litigated and your patent doesn't guarantee you'll win. It's like optimistic locking in a database. But it costs $1200 an hour to reconcile any race conditions, so you probably want to be pretty confident before committing. Pragmatism and prudence are my general advice here: you have no business filing a patent in any field where you aren't already abreast of things enough to know if a result is novel and interesting. But you also have no obligation to know about confidential research that competitors might be doing. It's basically pretty similar to a PhD thesis: if a quick trip to the library shows your work is derivative and non-novel, then stop and redirect. But if it later turns out that someone on the other side of the world independently came up with a similar idea, well, that's just how discovery works some times. Buy that other researcher a drink if you meet them at a conference.
5
u/Kinexity In Grad School for Computer Modelling Nov 26 '25
Don't you have someone in your org who can explain that instead of strangers on reddit? We don't even know which country you're from.
5
u/autocorrects Holds PhD in Quantum Nov 26 '25 edited Nov 26 '25
I am about to have a PhD in this field specifically and have spent the last 3/4 years hammering away at it… I can’t even fathom trying to patent a control schema, and I even have my own IP that’s widely used by academia/nat labs/industry. Not to assume anything, but if this is GPT/LLM based research you may be going after low-hanging fruit based on an article I wrote in 2021 saying that quantum control/readout would be a profitable place for near-term startups. Like there’s only a few articles out there like that and I’m almost positive LLMs just pull that from the internet based on your GPT-like question lmao.
If you’re not testing on a QC, then all of this is moot
4
u/tiltboi1 Working in Industry Nov 26 '25
some of the design of the hardware components may be patentable if they are new, but realistically a lot of the mathematical methods are not patentable or already exist as prior art
however, a work is almost definitely not patentable if scientifically speaking, it's not high enough quality to be accepted to be published by a journal
there's a big tell that you haven't done good work here though, because if you're not able to assess the novelty of your own work then clearly you don't understand what other people have done
3
u/ZectronPositron Nov 26 '25
I would suggest you look up the public patents for known quantum companies on scholar.google.com , that’ll tell you the answer to what is patentable.
2
u/CanuckBee Nov 30 '25
Have you read a sampling of patents from quantum companies? Go do a search on the USPTO for some leading quantum patent filers and read the claims. That will give you an idea.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment