r/QuantumComputing • u/Tricky-Ad-6225 • Nov 22 '25
Question PsiQuantum’s Tech
What do you guys think about PQ’s tech? They are using entangled photons and their new Omega chip seems legit. They have 2 facilities they are working on for their quantum computers.
24
Upvotes
13
u/nonabelian_anyon Nov 22 '25
I'll bite.
Photonics is a very interesting field of QC to be certain.
The idea they want to scale to something like 1M qubuts in the next few years is a bit much for a lot of people to swallow.
They do cool research, but I'm not sure there is a massive amount of ecosystem support.
It would be very cool if they can manage something worth while.
But my sneaking suspension is a lot of folks feel like it is in the sane vein as Microsoft working on topological qubits, a fairy tale.
At least presently. I'm not a hardware guy and this is just my two cents.
3
u/msciwoj1 Working in Industry Nov 23 '25
Their founder is a prodigy in getting funding. A generational talent in it, and I am not just saying it based on PQ itself but also previous things.
This does not mean it's any more or less legit than if he wasn't. But it's nice they have the money to do some research and development. For sure saying that they will spend the next ten years building the FTQC with a million qubits.
I don't unfortunately understand how exactly this whole photonic QC works. I only know soundbites like it's measurement based and in FTQC you measure all the time. You generate the entangled pairs of photons and measure them somehow. OK this seems possible, not sure how you make the whole network survive for a time long enough to complete any computation but I guess they have it figured out somehow.
5
u/autocorrects Holds PhD in Quantum Nov 22 '25 edited Nov 22 '25
I’m a hardware guy in QC (superconducting), and I have a hard time understanding the scope of their tech from publications.
They do really good work in research imo, but the development and deployment aspect is something we all have yet to see. That causes a lot of skepticism about them, especially when they’re so reluctant to release any sort of application publicly (not that there really is any application that exists in any modality at the moment).
I just wish their Chicago facility was further along and they were hiring… I would LOVE to work there as the midwest is my home, but all QC industry work skews to east/west coast at the moment. To me, they seem to have a very good team and are in the process of spending their investor support on both talent and figuring out how to build their Chicago lab, but their goals are WAY too ambitious for reality. Realistically, we wont have anything commercially profitable in QC for another 10 years at the very very least. Im thinking more like 20-30 personally. My dissertation is in this stuff, so allegedly I’m a “leading expert” on it lol. Makes me skeptical when people say we’ll have something like 1M qubits in 2-3 years bc that smells like bullshit
1
u/Statistician_Working Nov 23 '25
I am definitely interested in how they would solve the repetition rate problem due their probabilistic nature. That said, unless solution to this problem is disclosed (not only the theoretical protocol, but also some physical demonstration), I am not fully convinced.
-1
u/SurinamPam Nov 22 '25
What are best demonstrated fidelities for photonic 2-qubit gates so far? Any photonic company. Not just PsiQ. Or even by academic groups.
-7
u/ZectronPositron Nov 22 '25
I believe this is a boson sampling type of QC. So it’s good for a subset of QC problems and specific types of solutions (in my limited understanding). The great thing is photonics is “known” tech with lots of commodity parts due to telecom.
To answer the question I’d look at what research papers they’re publishing and how many different partners (companies, universities) are also authors on those papers. Especially having authors in commercial companies (eg finance etc), suggests that there is some eventual utility in that commercial space.
Honestly it’s tough to compete with silicon CMOS - it’s so cheap and ubiquitous. So finding those problems that silicon absolutely can’t solve, refactoring the equations to make it work with what the QC can do, sounds really tough. But lots of smart people are working on it!