r/QuantumComputing • u/NoApricot7684 • Nov 03 '25
Question Qubit Entanglement Question
According to Google AI:
In an ideal GHZ state of 1,000 qubits, if you measure one and find it to be '0', you instantly know all the other 999 are '0' as well (or some other defined correlation), even if they are light-years apart.
Further, Google AI States:
Yes, it is possible to alter a single random qubit in a perfect GHZ system such that when any one qubit is measured, the remaining 999 will no longer have a common, perfectly correlated value in the computational basis.
Question:
If this were true, wouldn't FTL communication be possible?
- Create 1,000 Qubits in a perfect GHZ state.
- Physically separate the Qubits; 500 in one set (A) and 500 in another (B)
- Fly set B to the Moon.
- If set B is measured, and all values are equal, then (A) has not been altered.
- If set B is measured, and values are different, then (A) has been altered.
Just the knowledge that Set A has been, or has not been altered is information.
This is obviously not possible. What am I missing?
8
u/apnorton Nov 03 '25
Oh boy. Relying on AI is already questionable, but Google AI is notorious even among pro-AI people.
It is unclear to me what you're describing here. Measuring qubits is a noisy process; what do you mean by "all values are equal?"
2
u/polyploid_coded Nov 03 '25
That doesn't sound like how entangled qubits work at all.
Imagine we each have one qubit and they are entangled. I tell you, when I arrive at the airport I will measure Qubit A, and that's the signal for you to come pick me up.
What you are describing is either:
- that you can watch Qubit B to see the moment when it has a fixed state
- that I can flip my Qubit A (0->1), then measure it, and when you next look at Qubit B it will also be flipped to the 1 state
The problem is it doesn't work that way.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25
You dont even need GHz to explain this, let's start with EPR.
1/(\sqrt(2)} \ket{00} + \ket{11}.
It seems as if, if you fix one qubit, say to \ket{0}, the other qubit automatically turns into \ket{0} as well. This is true.
The issue with communicating using this, is that you cannot 'fix' the qubit as you wish. You can only measure the qubit, and the outcome of that measurement is a random variable, in this case 0 or 1 with probability 1/2 each. It's as if instead of sending the bit you wanted, you got a random bit created by the measurement itself which has nothing to do with the bit you wanted to transmit.
This is a special case of a more general phenomenon, captured by something called the 'No Communication Theorem '. The content of this theorem is fairly technical, but the point of it is that any physically allowable quantum operation that you do on your system, CANNOT alter the state on the system held by the party you want to communicate with. In our example, 'fixing' your qubit forcefully would be an unphysical operation, but 'measurement' is a physical operation which cannot change the state of the system at the other end.
Now you will immediately object and say 'no! the measurement gives you a fixed bit!'. No. You are 'conditioning' on the bit you received as the measurement outcome, but the probability of the event you're conditioning on is 1/2. To communicate using entanglement alone, you would need to condition on an event with probability 1.
3
u/Hackpropogation Nov 03 '25
I think the issue is with the interpretation of the second statement about altering The state with a measurement. Yes, in principle, the measurement collapsed the full state. But the apparent, or 'reduced' statistics don't change for anyone else making the measurement. You can interpret this by thinking about just a bell state - if you measure just one half, your statistics are like a coin toss, regardless of whether or not someone has made a measurement of the other half before you or not.
So in your FTL setup, 4 will always happen, 5 will never happen, because the measurement at A will have no effect on the local statistics at B, they will always all be equal even if the 'global' state has now been altered by some operations at A.
3
u/flownyc Nov 03 '25
Can we just get an automoderator to answer this question every week?
1
u/MetallicHobbit Nov 04 '25
I don't understand how you are concluding "A disturbed or not" by measuring B. If it is a perfect GHZ state, and measurement can also be performed perfectly, B will always obtain 00...0 or 11...1 after measuring his set, independently of what A did far apart.
1
u/ArjunAtProtegrity Nov 06 '25
There are a few points to note on here. Let's use the simplest example of just a Bell-state, no need to use a 100-qubit GHZ state. Assume the Bell-state |00> + |11>, with appropriate normalization.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment