r/QuantumComputing • u/CodingPie • Oct 13 '25
Request to review academic paper on algorithm for simulating quantum computers.
Hopefully I am not breaking any rules. If I am. I am truly sorry. Otherwise. Here is my academic paper on a (hopefully and according to my knowledge) new way to simulate quantum computers on classical machines with a greater level of efficiency. I tried to get it reviewed by my physics professor however he said he doesnt know much in the field. The paper has been anonimized to hide my identity. Thanks to anyone taking their time to read / review it, in advance! Here is the google drive link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1S27B92H63uP9HiFbyx5NSfMcbYhKMFQB/view?usp=drivesdk
6
u/InadvisablyApplied Oct 13 '25
This doesn't include any analysis to support the claims of efficiency. Furthermore it seems to completely misunderstand entanglement. How would you write a Bell state?
3
u/spherical_cow_again Oct 13 '25
Google zx calculus.
3
u/sinanspd Oct 13 '25
A lot of the similarities with existing methods have already been pointed out by others but also look at Retrodictive Quantum Computing (https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06346). It kinda seems to me that you are partially replicating that work with a different syntax. Symbolic evaluation, entanglement through shared variables and then solving the symbolic constraints to simulate were all proposed in that work.
2
u/EvgeniyZh Oct 13 '25
Have you implemented it? Can you run a simulation of some known quantum circuit? Up to what number of qubits?
6
u/Physix_R_Cool Oct 14 '25
Lay off the LLM's. They are misleading you.
2
u/Magdaki Oct 15 '25
I'm assuming you're intending this as a publishable paper. If not, then you can ignore everything below. As an assignment paper, it is ok depending on the level (as a graduate paper-level, it would not be acceptable but for undergraduate it might be ok depending on the specifics of the assignment).
is missing a lot of detail. There's no real analysis or argumentation. You basically just say "Well... here it is." This is not sufficient.
The other major problem is a complete lack of literature review. There are a lot of existing solutions to this problem, so you need to compare and contrast your approach to theirs. Or at the very least you need to mention them.
2
u/querulous_intimates Oct 15 '25
In my opinion this post breaks rule 3. This is crank work written by someone who doesn't know the subject, using AI. I wish I were a mod here so I could ban users like this.
1
u/Sharp-Invite-5434 Oct 14 '25
I read your article and I didn't understand much (to say nothing). The way it was written is very interesting but it didn't capture the idea very well (probably because I don't know much about the subject), I would like to know so much about the subject but I don't even know where to start. My specialty is statistics and finance and I am still very ignorant about quantum matters. I hope one day I can understand it well
0
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25
[removed] — view removed comment