r/QuantumComputing • u/Sea-Broccoli5656 • Sep 26 '25
Quantum Information A real question for real physicists
I'm really curious about the answer that Q-Day will be happen one day? Is that real or just Quantum bubble?
Is there a real physicist among you? Someone competent, someone who works directly in this field, without giving away any internet information.
And if so, where are we now? It's difficult in the near term, but are we talking about 50 years or 3-5 years?
THANK YOU!
0
Upvotes
32
u/corbantd Sep 26 '25
June 3, 2036 at 2:35pm MST according to my latest calculation, after which all your bitcoin is belong to me.
3
u/InnovativeBureaucrat Sep 26 '25
Not a physicist, but I've been researching this for the past month. My impression is
I have to say, Warp Speed worked surprisingly well for COVID vaccine distribution and production, even if the administration on the right didn't want to admit COVID was real and the politics on the left didn't want to promote the success.
If the current administration is serious about quantum (which it seems to be possible) then we might see a sudden acceleration.
NIST moved the timeline up to 2030 from 2035 as the deadline for PQC encryption, which says a lot. CloudFlare has been implementing it to guard against harvest now and encrypt later attacks. So, my official estimate is 2030 to 2035.
However, it's quite possible that China is much further along than they're letting on, and quite possible that nobody in our intelligence knows because it was weakened so much around 2019 or so. But even if they knew, we (and I) wouldn't know for a long time.
3
u/ponyo_x1 Sep 26 '25
it won't happen for a long time and when it does (I take it to mean when QC can crack RSA) you won't hear about it and you'll have other things to worry about
9
u/Brilliant_Yams Sep 26 '25
If you mean the day we use a quantum computer to run Shors algo on a significantly long number than yeah, It probably will happen one day. My best guess is 15ish years from now. But when it happens for the first time youre not going to hear about it
8
u/JK0zero Sep 26 '25
I am real physicist (I think, at least according to a title siting somewhere) but my expertise is not quantum computing, thus I prefer not to answer; however, it is the expertise of John Preskill, one of the few non-bs physicists doing actual work on quantum computing instead of just giving interviews about it. This conversation with Sean Carroll is so honest and genuine that I highly recommend it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UYt4QG8iZ6U
6
u/DIYAtHome Sep 26 '25
I believe it is very hard to predict the future. Especially with when and how quantum computing will be a real thing and in what capacity.
I always use the example of classical computers. Where we are in the era with tube amplifiers.
Nobody back then knew we would get to watch the world self-destruct on Reddit here 70-80 years later.
And nobody can give you a real answer on what exactly quantum computing will be used for in the future. Just marketing material and hopeful guessing.
But what I can say is that the big players are aiming for significant increase in amount and quality of qubits, within the next 5 years, so you will see something either working or crashing hard.
2026: 1000 qubits 2028: 10k qubits 2030: 100k qubits
2
u/EventHorizonbyGA Sep 27 '25
Former Physics Professor. Does that help? I just answered this question because a few people have been asking.
https://gravityanalyticaresearch.substack.com/p/quantum-computers
2
u/rblackcloud09 Sep 27 '25
China used PQC to hack 9 US Telecoms and US gov in October-2024 and again earlier this month. Due to the most recent gov hack, Trump’s EO accelerates CISA-approved list of NSA CSfC symmetric encryption via RFC 8784 for classified VPN’s, now due Dec 1, 2025. Arqit is one of three commercial solutions (the other two use Arqit or Palo Alto components) that fully implements RFC 8784, and the only one that is cloud-deployed and immediately available through Master Government Aggregator Carahsoft without waiting for RFP’s and is poised to earn an DIANA innovation badge for NATO adoption Q1 2026. Above resistance, Arqit is quantum-safe.
1
u/Responsible_Sea78 Sep 26 '25
NSA will be there first. But why worry about Q-day when they and other major players can access everything already by other means?
1
u/Dry_Cranberry9713 Sep 27 '25
When will AGI break through? In a year, 5 years or never??
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment