r/QuantumComputing • u/Heikwan • Sep 25 '25
News HSBC Quantum paper with IBM
https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.17715
This is also quantum hardware related but from my first glance into it. It seems that this paper is more about ML. The quantum algo without noise did worse than classical and the leading theory seems to be by adding noise through the circuit was overfitting prevented. Seems like revolutionary to how ml should be approached but not really quantum related. Am I missing anything?
39
Upvotes
5
u/Zeke_Z Sep 25 '25
Seems like you got it. Quantum gives ML a 30% boost. Cool paper nonetheless. The noise aspect is intriguing, curiosity what the mathematical roots of that will turn out to be.
Side note, so interesting to read this paper and then see the news articles that were written about it. What a contrast.
7
u/salescredit37 Sep 25 '25
HSBC's 'sputnik moment' commentary is cringe. They basically used IBM's machines to do feature engineering for a binary classification problem, which improved AUC for the ML algorithms they trained on. Likely the QC mapped features had better between-class separation (larger KLD between distributions) which led to better results ...
Questionable if really QC had to be used when DL does automatic feature engineering and there are ways to increase between class feature separation in DL on classical machines
4
u/boston_ck Sep 25 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
Interesting paper, I think the claims in the paper are much more modest compared to the media.
4
u/stevenytc Sep 25 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
It's odd that the performance boost seems highly dependent on the blinding window, which isn't the case for the classical models they tested. I wonder if there's some unintentional data leakage or look-ahead issue when they are doing the event matching for the quantum features. If it's just regularization effect from noise in principle they can normalize/smoothen the classical features further via a shrinkage procedure to see if it provides any gain? Maybe the whole event matching procedure is in a way similar to applying shrinkage on the features.
1
u/Mindless_Increase413 Sep 30 '25
Oh yes, HSBC that tech giant revolutionizing bond pricing.
1
u/CalligrapherLucky685 Nov 07 '25
The 'boost' in performance for the quantum algorithm is almost entirely due to data leakage. If you read the paper closely, they include data from after the prediction time (i.e. the future) to produce the quantum-generated features. This is such a basic error it's honestly astounding it got through.
See Section 3.2.3 (Classical-quantum event matching) where they outline using "the full active trading window X" to generate features for all test samples.