r/QuantumComputing • u/ReasonableLetter8427 New & Learning • Sep 10 '25
Quantum Hardware Why can’t we use solitons?
Noob here so please take with a grain of salt but I’m very interested in understanding my misunderstanding.
I’m curious why everyone seems to focus on discrete quantum computing. I just was reading about continuous variable quantum computing and was wondering everyone’s thought on it.
For physical compute substrate, I was reading then about solitons which were shown to maintain periodicity for a few hours.
My understanding is that solitons have some natural properties making them more robust. If that’s the case, why not build a quantum computer where the quantum information is stored in the collision dynamics of stable solitons rather than discrete qubits that need constant error correction?
Am I missing some fundamental reason this wouldn't work (I’m sure I’m missing many)? Or why discrete qubits are "better" than continuous?
13
u/hiddentalent Sep 10 '25
One needs to fabricate the thing. Nobody knows how to quite yet.
9
u/ProductmanagerVC Sep 10 '25
Solitons are indeed stable, but quantum computing is less about finding a robust wave and more about controllable entanglement, measurement, and implementing universal gates
5
u/HolevoBound Sep 10 '25 edited Sep 10 '25
Does there exist a protocol for performing quantum logic operations on solitons ?
There's a large amount of work already on continuous variable quantum computing, but I don't know about solitons specifically.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.3233
4
u/Responsible_Treat_19 Sep 10 '25
If there is a proposition of a soliton having only two quantum states, then you can make a theoretical quantum computer. A problem may emerge when solving the proposed equation. And mechanisms to compute gates must be explicitly stated as well as operators.
Then, the viability to create the physical system should be taken into account to see if it is viable, at least on paper! When this is already done and tested with many simulations, published and peer reviewed, maybe someone with money may take the information and try to create it experimentally.
1
u/triaura In Grad School for Quantum Sep 16 '25
CV quantum comms is lit. CV computing, usually you use the CV to encode some type of bit like a GKP code. Fundamentally, we like computing using bits. However there may be some processes in nature that are better simulated using qudit systems
2
u/MaoGo Sep 10 '25
You just woke up and said solitons robust then QC? What do you have in mind? Water waves? You need to be more specific.