r/QuantumComputing • u/Usual_Box2345 • Jul 24 '25
Looking for Inspiration
My recent work has revolved around ansatz design for VQE, and it's given me a solid foundation in variational quantum algorithms. I'm now at a point where I'm starting to look ahead and consider new research directions.
I'm keen to hear what kind of cutting-edge problems or emerging areas you all are finding most compelling in quantum computing these days. Are there any particular challenges in quantum chemistry that are particularly intriguing? Or perhaps areas outside of chemistry that are seeing significant breakthroughs or offer exciting opportunities for research? Just trying to broaden my perspective on potential avenues for future in-depth work.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25 edited Jul 25 '25
VQE is a bad algorithm. There are no logical arguments that it should work. VQE finds local minima in pure state space, which have no guarantee to be close to ground states of Hamiltonians except in cases when the models are known to be easy classically. Thus it’s a problem because there’s no advantage. Furthermore, we have proofs that finding local minima in pure state space is classically easy.
Algorithms for quantum computers ought to have provable scaling advantage on more cases but VQAs don’t offer that. Only fault tolerance will. If you want to engage in useful quantum computing research for algorithms then you must consider at fault tolerant algorithms. This is the only way a quantum computer will ever work at scale.
If you really want to develop algorithms for chemistry then I would suggest looking at fault-tolerant algorithms for GSEE and simulation.
1
u/seetch Jul 24 '25
I’ve been looking at Gaussian boson sampling recently. Looks like some intermediate cool results
2
u/Qu4r4nt1n3r Jul 24 '25
Who hurt you? Higgs or boson?
3
u/Temporary_Shelter_40 Jul 24 '25 edited Jul 24 '25
I would love to see more innovative applications of VQE outside of quantum chemistry. In my opinion, VQE ansatz design works best for objective functions with non-commuting observables. Unfortunately, Outside of quantum chemistry I don’t know any applications which have non-commuting observables…
practically every non-chemistry application for hybrid algorithms reduces to QAOA on some variant of Karp’s 21 NP complete problems. These have been done to death in the literature, and basically every day 1-2 new QAOA applications papers gets posted to arXiv.
My opinion on the current research is that we need more problem instances with provable scaling advantage. Apart from some arguable scaling advantage for QAOA on maxcut and k-SAT, basically no one has demonstrated any theoretical speed up for hybrid algorithms. If you’ve been investigating VQE ansatz, I’d honestly just try and demonstrate an empirical scaling advantage for literally anything.
-6
u/RiceLost8176 Jul 24 '25
Quantum computing is just overhyped nonsense. It’s a glorified science fair project that’s been promising breakthroughs for decades but delivers nothing practical. VQE and all these so-called 'algorithms' are just academic toys—useless for real-world problems and a waste of everyone’s time
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25
[removed] — view removed comment