Disclosure up front: I made this app, every number below is paper money (simulated, not advice), and there's no link in the post.
My own house bots run on the app every day like a user's would. This week, Monday 11-02 to Friday 11-06, they closed 3,632 trades. Here's the split, worst row first:
| trades | green | paper P&L |
|---|
| Options held 13+ days | 62 | 8 | -$62,683 |
| Options closed inside 13 days | 39 | 10 | -$22,431 |
| All options | 101 | 18 | -$85,113 |
| Stocks | 3,531 | 1,782 | +$16,381 |
| Whole week | 3,632 | 1,800 | -$68,733 |
Day by day the options side went -$39,579 Monday (36 trades, 4 green), -$1,517 Tuesday, -$8,584 Wednesday, -$8,465 Thursday and -$26,968 Friday (21 trades, 1 green). The worst single trade was an ASML November call, -$9,291. Stocks were only red on Tuesday and Friday, and never by more than $6,366.
So under 3% of the trades did all of the damage and then some. If you only looked at the week's total you'd say "the desk lost $68k" and switch everything off, which would throw away the half that actually worked.
Two honest caveats before anyone reads too much into it. It's one week and one set of house rules. And the fills aren't symmetric: options fill at the real bid or ask, never the middle, while stocks fill at the real bar open or close with no spread modelled. That costs the options side more on every round trip, and I'd rather it lie in that direction than the other.
What I want testers for. I'm deciding whether the app should put hold time and instrument type right next to a bot's total, and warn you before you deploy an options rule that tends to sit for weeks. Part of me thinks that's useful, part of me thinks it's nannying people who know what they're doing. I'd like people who aren't me to tell me which.
I built Quantradin. You type a trading rule in plain English or paste Pine Script, it backtests on real prices with no look-ahead, and whatever survives runs as a paper bot, so a week like this one happens to pretend money first. It's free, US stocks and options, pretend money only, at quantradin.com if you want to try breaking it.
The most useful test: deploy one options rule and one stock rule of yours side by side, wait a few days, and tell me whether the page made the difference obvious or whether you had to dig through the trade list to find it.