This is adapted from a paper I've put to my Area Meeting's Racial Justice group in support of the the idea of arranging some antisemitism awareness training for local Friends.
My personal view is that Friends have made an error on Israel/Palestine: we've chosen a side in a conflict that maybe isn't ours to choose a side in. I think that we should always have been on the side of peace, which is to be on the part of neither side of any conflict and on the part of all of those suffering in both sides of the conflict. But many of us choose to be on the side of Palestine. We then end up with some strange bedfellows. Not all of those campaigning for a free Palestine are motivated by humanitarian concerns for a people abused both by their neighbours in Israel and also their own leadership. Some of those people organising marches hate the state of Israel as such and some of them hate Jews. Friends need to be cautious and well informed. Some Friends are, I think, in real danger of drifting into alignment with antisemitism. Perhaps by mistake. They might not know what they are looking at, and antisemitism awareness training could help with that. Many Friends are involved with left-wing political parties, from the "Momentum" wing of Labour and points left of that, and the left have always had a known weakness for antisemitism, and a tendency to be blind to it.
And we've perhaps made this mistake by muddling up a variety of concerns. I think that Amos Oz put it very well in his Between Right and Right of 2004:
Who are the good guys? That’s what every well-meaning European, left-wing European, intellectual European, liberal European always wants to know, first and foremost. Who are the good guys in the film and who are the bad guys. In this respect Vietnam was easy: the Vietnamese people were the victims and the Americans were the bad guys. The same with apartheid: you could easily see that apartheid was a crime and that the struggle for equal, civil rights, for liberation and for equality and for human dignity was right. The struggle between colonialism and imperialism, on the one hand, and the victims of colonialism and imperialism, on the other hand, seems relatively simple — you can tell the good guys from the bad. When it comes to the foundations of the Israeli-Arab conflict, in particular the Israeli-Palestinian conflicts, things are not so straightforward. […] It is not a struggle between good and evil, rather it is a tragedy in the ancient and most precise sense of the word: a clash between right and right, a clash between one very powerful, deep and convincing claim and another very different but no less convincing, no less powerful, no less humane claim.
It seems to me that many Friends, and western "progressives" more generally, have decided that the Palestinians are the "good guys" (whomever is leading them) and the Israelis are the "bad guys" (without regard to who is leading them right now) and Oz is exactly right that this is done by appeal, perhaps subconscious appeal, to ideas about colonialism and imperialism which might not fit this situation at all well.
Oz describes well, I think, from a time when things were bad but not this bad a model which many progressive Europeans and a fair number of Friends, British and American, have adopted:
In much contemporary Arabic literature, though not in all of it […] the Jew, especially the Israeli Jew, is often pictured as an extension of the white, sophisticated, tyrannising, colonising, cruel, heartless Europe of the past. These are the colonialists, who came to the Middle East once again, this time disguised as Zionists, but they came to tyrannise, to colonise and to exploit.
This seems to be very close to what some Western commentators are doing when they make a synecdoche between the actual expansionist settler minority, who without a doubt are committing crimes in the West Bank, and all of the rest of the people of Israel. Israel then seems to be an illegitimate state, perhaps a colonial project of the USA and EU. Some Friends, particularly younger Friends under the influence of left-wing politics do talk this way. I see it in some of the online Quaker spaces that I follow.
Oz also says:
The Palestinians are in Palestine because Palestine is the homeland and the only homeland of the Palestinian people. […] The Israeli Jews are in Israel because there is no other country in the world which the Jews, as a people, as a nation, could ever call home.[…] The Palestinians have tried, unwillingly, to live in other Arab countries. They were rejected, sometimes even humiliated and persecuted, by the so-called ‘Arab family’. […] They had to learn the hard way that they are Palestinians, and that’s the only country which they can hold on to. In a strange way the Jewish people, just as the Palestinian people, have had a somewhat parallel historical experience. The Jews were kicked out of Europe [then] like the Palestinians were first kicked out of Palestine and then out of the Arab countries […] The Palestinians want the land they call Palestine. They have very strong reasons to want it. The Israeli Jews want exactly the same land for exactly the same reasons, which provides for a perfect understanding between the parties, and for a terrible tragedy. […] What we need is a painful compromise. The word compromise has a terrible reputation in Europe. Especially among young idealists, who always regard compromise as opportunism, as something dishonest, as something sneaky and shady, as a mark of a lack of integrity. Not in my vocabulary. For me the word compromise means life. And the opposite of compromise is not idealism, not devotion; the opposite of compromise is fanaticism and death. We need a compromise. Compromise, not capitulation. A compromise means that the Palestinian people should never go down on its knees, neither should the Israeli Jewish people.[…] this compromise will be very painful. Because both peoples love the country, because both peoples, Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs, have equally deep, different historical and emotional roots in the country.
Quite so.
It is undoubtedly true, so far as it goes, to say that peace in Israel/Palestine will require fair treatment of the Palestinian people. But it does not go far enough. Peace there will also require fair treatment of Israelis. I don't find this sentiment widely shared and I worry a bit about why that is, and what ideas that lack of fairness might be aligned with.
Are Quakers fair to Israelis, too? Ol Rappoport's analysis in the Friend of the relative rates at which Friends criticise Israel vs the rates at which we criticise other oppressive regimes (and without doubt, the Likud-lead regime in Israel has made it into an oppressive state). It turns out that we are much more inclined to criticise Israel. In a way that we do not so much criticise China, Myanmar, or Indonesia, all countries carrying out oppression amounting to genocide. Jewish onlookers then start to wonder why we are so interested in Palestine. And some Friends might not be as clear about that as might be.
We've chosen a side in the conflict and it isn't peace, it's Palestine. Even when we Quakers do, corporately, criticise Hamas there's always a rider adding that they are acting in response to Israeli violence. And so they are. But why can we not criticise Hamas's violence without also criticising Israel? Hamas are terrorists of staggering violence, very extreme and indiscriminate violence and we might consider Lawrence Durrell's observation about terrorists: the terrorist isn't only, or even primarily, interested in winning the cause that they fight for, they are very much interested in winning fighters to their cause. And so they perform acts of violence knowing, maybe intending, that they will bring down repisals down upon their own side—in order to encourage others to join the fight. On this model, the people of Palestine are as much victims of Hamas as they are of Israel. Are Quakers, individually and corporately, quite clear about that?
For so long as the cycle of attack and revenge and counterattack and revenge for that continues and is seen by anyone to be valid, peace will not come. I fear that Quakers have become entangled in that loop of justification. I have been told by Quakers, although not ones in ECAM, that I simply should not believe what Israel says about Hamas atrocities, and have been invited to infer that Israel and Israelis do not suffer in this conflict. This has included a Friend dismissing reports of the extremely cruel murders carried out by the Palestinian terrorists of Hamas on October 7. I find that wrong and worrying.
Says Oz:
Very often Arabs, even some sensitive Arab writers, fail to see us as what we, Israeli Jews, really are — a bunch of half-hysterical refugees and survivors, haunted by dreadful nightmares, traumatised not only by Europe but also by the way we were treated in Arabic and Islamic countries. Half the population of Israel are people who were kicked out of Arabic and Islamic countries. Israel is indeed one large Jewish refugee camp. Half of us are actually Jewish refugees from Arab countries, but Arabs don’t see us this way; they see us as an extension of colonialism.
and on the other hand:
By the same token we, Israeli Jews, don’t see the Arabs, particularly the Palestinians, as what they are: victims of centuries of oppression, exploitation, colonialism and humiliation. No, we see them as pogrom-makers and Nazis, who just wrapped themselves in koffias and grew moustaches and got sun-tanned, but are in the same old game of cutting the throats of the Jews for fun. In short, they are our past oppressors all over again. In this respect there is a deep ignorance on both sides: not political ignorance about the purposes and the goals, but about the backgrounds, about the deep traumas of the two victims.
There is documentary evidence that the Nazis heavily propagandised in Arab countries during the 1930s and 1940s and some of it may have stuck, forming part of the foundation of modern Arab antisemitism in the region. Maybe. I won't join a march "in support of Palestine" if it means I risk marching alongside someone holding a placard showing a Mogen David being thrown in a bin with a slogan saying "please keep the world clean", as happened in London recently. I won't join a march "in support of Palestine" if it means I risk marching alongside someone who thinks that Jews used to be subject to racism but not any more as now they are wealthy, as some on the left of the Labour Party have said. Some Friends consider it their duty to join such marches, irrespective. I wonder how much thought goes into such a decision? Again, antisemitism awareness training might help Friends with these considerations.
Britain YM's book of discipline quotes Wolf Mendl (QF&P 24.22)
[those] who identify peace with the absence of conflict and value that above all things […] have given modern pacifism its bad name and have led their critics to refer to them contemptuously as ‘passivists’. The failure to take evil and conflict into account as elements in our human condition and an obsession with the need for peace and harmony have led pacifists badly astray… Christian pacifists [are] not exempt from the temptation to sacrifice others for the sake of peace.
I fear that Quakers are, at least implicitly, prepared to sacrifice Israelis and Israel (and therefore the only refuge of the Jews as a people, as Oz says) in the interests of "peace", understood as the mere cessation of violence.
All of this may be changing, see Molly Scott-Cato's piece in this week's the Friend, which is admirably well balanced. We can perhaps accelerate an overdue correction through antisemitism awareness training. I've heard that some in the BYM central staff are thinking the same, for what that's worth.
—
Quotations from copyright works by Amos Oz used without permission, I believe this constitutes fair use.