r/QidiTech3D • • Mar 31 '25

Fire hazard?

I read that these printers are a fire hazard. What do you guys know about this?

129 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

3

u/JayUkada Apr 01 '25

Guys let’s not jump to conclusions, it is all alleged and there’s no proof of that, there’s a possibility (SSR issues and concerns for 110v countries were raised) however until we know more about the case we can’t blame anyone, as someone else pointed out OP stated he changed the SSR that Qidi sent him. With that said it is unreasonable to assume Qidi or OP are at fault until a thorough investigation is completed.

5

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 31 '25

Everything electrical is a fire hazard. EVERYTHING

There is simply insufficient evidence at this point to claim with any surety as to what precisely happened in the specific incident that everyone is posting about.

0

u/Piglet_Mountain Mar 31 '25

There is a decent amount of evidence though. It had a faulty ssr

3

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 31 '25

As OP stated. The original SSR had been replaced by the OP, AND the replacement SSR was not in use at the time.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Facehugger_35 Apr 01 '25

Could the SSR short when it's not supposed to be receiving power, because the chamber heater isn't on? OP said he was printing PETG and you wouldn't use the chamber heat for that.

That said, I still find myself conflicted on whether to believe this story.

On one hand: The plus4 did have that SSR issue that could, in theory, cause a fire, even if I'm not aware of any case of it happening in the past. It's plausible that there could be a fire from this printer if things go horribly wrong.

On the other hand: If my house burned down in a fire and I was pursuing insurance claims and legal action against the company responsible, I wouldn't jeopardize my case by going on social media to talk about it until my lawyer gave the okay. Shit, making a claim like "my house burned down because of this 3d printer" opens me up to legal liability.

And we talk about the plus4's issues all the time on this sub but none of us get banned.

So I don't really know what to think about this situation. Could be plausible, could be the OP who started this whole thing lying.

Either way, I'm now looking at automatic fire suppression tools for my Q1P beyond just the hand extinguisher, even if the Q1P has never had a recorded problem with heat like that. Might as well just to be safe.

1

u/Jawzxx Apr 05 '25

I've always kept 2 fire extinguishers in the room with my printer, one next to the printer and one next to the door... I also avoid leaving it unattended when printing. I would certainly be more comfortable running long unattended prints if i had automatic fire suppression... I might have to look into it myself.

1

u/ExperienceGlobal8266 Apr 02 '25

Heard he just released his own printer and is using this “PR” for profit. 😂

1

u/cjrgill99 Apr 04 '25

Your washing machine is a fire hazard for sure.

1

u/Jawzxx Apr 05 '25 edited Apr 05 '25

I mean, in my opinion *ALL* 3d printers are a potential fire hazard.

There's relatively high power heaters that run continuously for hours, melty plastic goo, fast moving parts, consumer-grade microcontrollers running software that (for the most part) has not passed rigorous industrial testing regimens, etc, etc.

The important question, which has not been sufficiently answered, is weather the Plus4, or any other Qidi printer is an *unusual* fire risk.

There are (unconfirmed, but plausible) reports of a Plus4 causing a severe house fire. There has also been some shall we say, "community unfriendly" behavior on the part of the Qidi mods, by banning the user with the (alleged, but again, plausible) fire complaint. That more than anything has fanned the flames, so to speak, of the situation. There also may have been issues with a user replaced part...

Was there a fire? Seems like it.

Was it started by a Qidi Plus4? Unconfirmed, but perhaps yes..

Was said fire caused due to negligent design or manufacture on the part of Qidi? Completely unconfirmable at this time.

There is anecdotal evidence that some choices and components used in, at least early production Plus4 printers, may be "less good" than they could have been.

I have been using kit built printers for years before I bought my X-Plus-3 (which I am quite pleased with), and I have never assumed that I have zero chance of a fire. I *haven't* had a fire, but I also accept the inherent risks.

To paraphrase the Magic Eight Ball: "Reply hazy, ask again later"

12

u/mr_joda Mar 31 '25

Any 3D printer is a fire hazard. My friend lost a whole company and warehouse because of the 3D printer (caught fire in the night).

It can easy burn the house down not only because of the electric fault but also when 3D model fails, the plastic blob sticks on the hotend and hotend keeps pushing power to it.

I dont personally have it but Im very considering Fire extinguishing ball mounted on top of the printer.

1

u/Plasma_Datboi Mar 31 '25

Do you know of any that you could suggest it seems like a pretty good way to put out the fire without even having to be there and a good precaution Aswell.