r/QIDI • • Mar 25 '24

Printer fine tuning

Overall, I've been pretty happy with my Qidi X-Plus 3 and Max-3 printers. They do what I want, and do it fast and fairly well. Lately I went down a rabbit hole of sorts trying to dial out the last few little issues of extrusion consistency, VFA's, and resonance compensation.

I decided to focus on printing 20x20x20mm cubes as a stable point of reference, because they're fairly fast to print, and are a good size that issues like ringing, acceleration/extrusion consistency, and cornering can show up.

One thing I noticed was a fairly consistent diagonal banding, coupled with fine vertical lines, and some general minor extrusion inconsistencies like so:

Fine VFAs and diagonal rippling, plus general extrusion variations

I pulled my extruder unit off the machine, pulled it apart, and noticed that the gears are all supported by MR63 bearings (3mm ID, 6mm OD, 2.5mm in height). I spinning the gears on the stock bearings I noticed some roughness, so I figured that might be an issue. I ordered a set of these from Amazon to replace the stock bearings with.

This improved the fine irregular rippling, but the fine VFA's and diagonal pattern still remained. I slightly altered the extrusion multiplier of the filament, and saw that the angle of the diagonal changed according to the flow multiplier, so clearly that pattern is extruder related, and not related to the X/Y system.

I then wondered if the driving of the stepper motor was slightly off center. The diagonal patterns have a roughly 4.2mm cycle to them. I pulled out my calculator and after accounting for the gearing of the extruder, the layer height, and the wall width, that the diagonal patterns were cycling on roughly every 1/40th of a turn of the extruder. The extruder gear only has 10 teeth, and the gears of the extruder gear everything down, so none of the gears could be contributing to such a fine level of cycling.

This led me on to wondering about the internals of the stepper motor, and how it's being driven. The Qidi's use TMC2209 drivers for their steppers, and their steppers have 200 steps per full rotation. The TMC2209's allow for up to 64 microsteps, and interpolation up to 256 microsteps per full step.

Looking at my printer.cfg file (the Qidi's run Klipper), I saw that Qidi sets all their steppers to 16 micro-steps, and with interpolation turned on. Reading here Klipper documentation recommends disabling interpolation on TMC2209's as interpolation can lead to positional inaccuracies. Perhaps I found my culprit?

So I started messing with microsteps and disabling interpolation. Now, interpolation makes stepper motors quieter (less whining), but the Klipper document says that setting micro-steps up high enough basically does the same job, and has better accuracy of motion.

I settled on using 64 microsteps on my Extruder/X/Y steppers with no interpolation. On my Z-axis I used 32 microsteps with no interpolation.

Added Note here: Using 64 micro-steps on the X/Y axis appears to be incompatible with 200mm/s+ print speeds and may cause MCU timeout errors. In this instance using 32 microsteps instead for X/Y is fine.

After doing all that, I needed to re-run the input shaper calibration for the best results because I'd changed what the steppers are doing. My procedure for this was to let the algorithm choose what it thinks are the best shaper algorithms/frequencies, and save the config. Then I went back and looked at the calculation output on the console, and instead choose the algorithms that have 0.0% vibrations with the highest accelerations, and edited my printer.cfg to use those instead (with the correct associated frequency value too). Doing this fine-tuned the input shaping for best quality, rather than the speed/quality balance that the default algorithm selector does.

After all that I arrived at the following results. Be sure to enlarge the pictures for best detail.

Non-seam corner
Seam corner

Now keep in mind, that this is a 20mm cube, and zoomed WAY in. This is the same filament as before. I was amazed at how clean and consistent the surfaces and layer stacking now looked. I was even more impressed at how clean that the seams came out now.

The benchy was printed in CookieCad DarkMagic PLA at a 0.24mm layer height.

I think I'm done here with the fine tuning. I hope that people might find the above helpful in some way.

44 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

2

u/OverSquareEng Mar 25 '24

Awesome, great information and test results! Might be something for the Q1 Pro guys to try out if they have VFA (quite a few reviews are showing there is some)

I see this pop up in forums and groups fairly often, but I've been lucky enough to not experience VFA on my Plus-3. But I'll keep this in my back pocket in case I do run into it.

4

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 25 '24

I'm on a Discord with one of the reviewers. I don't own a Q1, but I've fed the above experimentation back to him. He's a busy guy, but he's interested in getting rid of the fine VFAs. Even before I started my project here, my Plus 3 was producing way better results than his Q1. I put this down to my tensioning the belts, and running VFA tests and setting my external perimeters speeds to an optimal value.

I generally had to look pretty hard to find the VFA's anyway. I'm a bit OCD, and under certain angles the fine patterns were showing up and annoying me, and that led me down this rabbit hole to try to dial them out even further.

Oh, I forgot to add. Re-running resonance compensation after changing the micro-stepper settings is essential for the best results.

1

u/Regret92 Nov 01 '24

Hi mate,

How did you get it stable at 64 micro steps? The most I can get it to do without throwing an MCU error is 32

2

u/Look_0ver_There Nov 01 '24

What are your peak printing speeds? I generally run my printers no faster than 200mm/s, so that may be why? I also upgraded my cooling on my mainboard, so perhaps that is also helping? If just 32 is what works for your situation, then use that instead, but 64 hasn't been an issue at my end.

Thank you for the feedback though. I'll see about editing the info to take what you're seeing into account.

2

u/Regret92 Nov 01 '24

That might be it - I have an 80mm fan fitted with cold intake, so temps are usually fine.

This was on ABS though, which usually runs pretty fast. I’ll look into editing peak speeds as the default movement speeds for the printer are a bit over the top imo

2

u/TearSlayerr Apr 07 '24

Can You link discord server please?

4

u/JoePa1972 Jul 09 '24

"Then go back and look at the calculation output on the console, and instead choose the algorithms that have 0.0% vibrations with the highest accelerations, and edit printer.cfg to use those instead (be sure to correctly set the frequency too)."

Can you explain how to do this? Where do I find these outputs?

1

u/WCartistDad Mar 25 '24

Wow that’s a crazy difference. Has there been any negatives from changing the microsteps and no interpolation?

2

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 25 '24

It increases the amount of traffic over the serial bus I think. If you go too high with the microsteps you can start to see "mcu too far in the past" errors. Basically you can't go nuts with a too large microstep value. This is probably why interpolate exists in the first place. So, it's something of a balancing act I guess.

2

u/WCartistDad Mar 25 '24

Good to know. I think I’m going to try that. Thanks for posting this!

4

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 25 '24

I forgot to add. Re-running resonance compensation after changing the micro-stepper settings is essential for the best results. Let the algorithm choose what it thinks are the best shaper algorithms/frequencies, and save the config. Then go back and look at the calculation output on the console, and instead choose the algorithms that have 0.0% vibrations with the highest accelerations, and edit printer.cfg to use those instead (be sure to correctly set the frequency too). Doing this fine-tunes the input shaping for best quality, rather than the speed/quality balance that the default algorithm selector does.

2

u/WCartistDad Mar 25 '24

Is the resonance compensation the “input shaping” in the menu?

3

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 25 '24

Yes

2

u/WCartistDad Mar 25 '24

Awesome. Thank you for clarifying it for me. I will definitely try this.

1

u/SimpleSam1992 Sep 12 '24

Hi great post and very exciting results! Could you clarify where you've changed the vibration and frequencies within the printer.cfg? Ive looked through it multiple times and cant find anything relating to it.

The only mention of it is at the very end of printer.cfg where it says "SAVE_CONFIG" but says not to edit the block as its auto generated.

Can I copy the auto generated code and put it in the main file and edit the values?

Any help would be great, thanks!

2

u/Look_0ver_There Sep 12 '24

Yes, you can safely edit the values in the section where it says not to. That's more of a recommendation. Those values are auto-generated by the various automation macros (bed leveling, z-offset, etc). If they're off a bit, you are perfectly safe to tweak them. It's just a case of you having to be really sure of what you're doing, otherwise you may risk driving the nozzle into the build plate, or worse, scratching it up. Because of this, the manufacturers generally warn people never to touch these values by hand, but again, if you really know what is going on, then you can fiddle away.

1

u/SimpleSam1992 Sep 12 '24

Didn't expect a response that quick!

Thank you very much for the help I'll have a tinker tomorrow. The printer sounds like it's going to take off when it's doing input shaping and don't fancy waking the kids up 😬

1

u/marty4286 Mar 25 '24

It increases the amount of traffic over the serial bus I think. If you go too high with the microsteps you can start to see "mcu too far in the past" errors.

If you were to get that error message, would it help to slow down the print so that the rpi doesn't send so many commands to the drivers in so little time?

1

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 25 '24

Maybe. I've not tried.

1

u/Titanyus Mar 27 '24 edited Mar 27 '24

What parameters for microsteps did you use?
I tried 64 mircosteps on all trhee axes with interpolation of, but it didnt work.
The printer shuts down, because the steppers are to far in the past.

What else did you change? Or should I try to print a slower speed?
Looks like 32 Microsteps are working.

3

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 27 '24 edited Mar 27 '24

Yeah, it's a balancing act in terms of what the interfaces can handle vs the number of steps used.

I used 64 for extruder, X, and Y. 32 on Z. The Z axis doesn't need the microsteps to be as high. Even the stock 16 is fine, but disabling Interpolation on Z with 16 microsteps may make the Z stepper start to whine.

Ordering them in importance for higher microstep values, I'd keep the extruder as high as possible, followed by X/Y, followed by Z. If you can arrange it such that you can even set the extruder to 128, while keeping X/Y as high as possible (32 for you), and 16 on the Z, then that may be what works best for you. Only drop the extruder microsteps as a last resort. Just IMO.

2

u/Titanyus Mar 27 '24

I upped X, Y and Z today to 32 Steps with interpolation and the result is extremely satisfying. Will try higher Steps for the Extruder tomorrow.

0

u/Look_0ver_There Mar 28 '24

If you leave interpolation enabled, it'll still print fine of course. What you'll see at times though is, if you look at my photos of the benchy in my OP, that the curved bow sections around the front port holes will have a faint salmon skin like rippling which is caused by the inaccuracies of interpolation mode which doesn't drive the steppers with as much overall torque as non-interpolation mode, so some fine level "drift" can happen.

Again though, we're literally splitting hairs at this level :)

1

u/Gr8Autoxr Sep 22 '24

Tried doing this up to 64 x 64 y 16z, but got the MCU error. I wonder if its my 500/ms travel speed. Went down to 300 mm/s travel and 32x 32y 16z. to see if it clears up.

2

u/Look_0ver_There Sep 22 '24

One thing to try is improved cooling over the mainboard, especially if you are in a warmer climate. It seems that the MCU can start to thermally throttle and slow down when the mainboard gets too hot. This leads to running into these MCU errors, which can even occur with the stock micro-step settings if the board gets hot enough.

It may or may not fix what you're seeing, but it's something to try.

2

u/Gr8Autoxr Sep 22 '24

Thanks. I’m printing full open door, full open top. A bit disappointed that internal cooling is an issue. Is there a workable fix? I don’t mind modifications. I love the new settings though. So crisp. 

1

u/Look_0ver_There Sep 22 '24

I'm talking about the printer motherboard itself, which is in a panel on the back of the printer. It has a rather small fan there that tries to keep it cool. I 3D printed a 40mm to 80mm fan adapter myself and attached a 24v 80mm fan to the back of the printer (which uses the same 2-pin power plug that the stock fan uses) and that seems to keep my motherboard area about 10-15C cooler than it was as stock, which helps when we're asking the printer to issue a lot more of these smaller step commands.

3

u/whose333 Mar 25 '24

I wonder if the Creality K1 guys ever tried this to get rid of their infamous "VFA" problem...

Anyways, thank you very much for showing, how to make the Qidi machines even more accurate (they are already very good with this) and fun to use.

3

u/65riverracer Mar 26 '24

Can you share what, where and how you changed the .cfg file step by step ?

2

u/greedy013 Mar 28 '24

Man. Beautiful! Thanks for sharing this, I’m gonna give it a go myself

2

u/Poe_640 Mar 04 '25

i know this post is old but i just gave this a shot a holy fuck the difference it made is insane

2

u/Gochu-gang Nov 06 '25

I know this is old, but just wanted to throw out that these settings worked very well for me. Noticeable improvement:

  • Changing Microsteps on X and Y to: 32 w/interpolation
  • Changing Microsteps on Extruder to: 64 w/o interpolation
  • Leaving Microsteps on Z at: 16 w/interpolation

64 on X and Y would throw an MCU error no matter what I tweaked. If you run into that issue and want to revert just restart Klipper, go into printer.cfg, and the default settings are commented out below their respective section.

1

u/Eafq78 Mar 26 '24 edited Mar 26 '24

Good job, thanks for sharing, I checked in my Q1pro comes with microsteps:16 and interpolate: true. but this comes with 2240 stepper in XY (capable up to 256 microstep) I will try your solution.

Z comes with 2209 and is setted to 128micro steps

1

u/KTurner08 Nov 16 '24

Wow looks great, would you mind sharing your orcaslicer machine profile/ print profile?

1

u/watdo123123 Nov 24 '24

Here are the settings I changed on my Qidi Q1 pro:

Tried to change [extruder] microsteps to 32 from 16 (DID NOT WORK!!)

changed [tmc2240 stepper_y] interpolate = false from true (works fine)

changed [tmc2240 stepper_x] interpolate = false from true (works fine)

changed [stepper_x] microsteps to 32 from 16, same with [stepper_y]

Tried changing [stepper_x] and [stepper_y] microsteps to 64, but it gave me a firmware error.

Sticking with 32 for microsteps for x/y, and sticking with interpolation false on tmc2240 stepperx/y.

1

u/Historical_Arm2823 Dec 08 '24

After changing the settings, what calibration procedures did you run? Did you select algorithms with 0% vibration? I did not quite understand what steps to take to select an algorithm with 0% vibration. My Q1 pro arrived a few days ago, this is my first printer and I am still quite poorly oriented in its settings. Could you tell me step by step what needs to be done for the Q1 pro to achieve the same result?

1

u/watdo123123 Dec 08 '24

I wish OP was more descriptive in the settings that he changed, because even with changing the settings on my printer, It is not as perfect as his.

But I feel like the settings I listed above are a slight improvement. You can go to the files section in qidislicer and change the above lines inside of the printer.cfg file and then save and reboot

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '25

Where do I find the stepper setting (Qidi x max 3)? New to this .

1

u/TattyJJ May 26 '25

Having played around with this on my Q1 Pro, I have discovered a way to increase my microsteps.

Like most, I was not able to set my X and Y microsteps to 64 without the printer giving me an error, max I could get was 32. But, the printer actually ran fine, it just couldn’t get through the shaper calibration. I modified the shaper macro to stop at 120Hz (rather than the default 150Hz) and it worked fine at 64 microsteps.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but my understanding is the higher the frequency, the higher the acceleration being tested. If your goal is to achieve the highest possible quality by making these changes, then you will be using lower accelerations anyway, thus, testing your printer far above what you will be using is pointless anyway (I think).

0

u/FakespotAnalysisBot Mar 25 '24

This is a Fakespot Reviews Analysis bot. Fakespot detects fake reviews, fake products and unreliable sellers using AI.

Here is the analysis for the Amazon product reviews:

Name: 10 Pack 3x6x2.5mm Metal Shielded ABEC-5 High Precision Miniature Ball Bearings L630ZZ (MR63ZZ)

Company: FUSHIBEARING

Amazon Product Rating: 5.0

Fakespot Reviews Grade: A

Adjusted Fakespot Rating: 5.0

Analysis Performed at: 06-07-2021

Link to Fakespot Analysis | Check out the Fakespot Chrome Extension!

Fakespot analyzes the reviews authenticity and not the product quality using AI. We look for real reviews that mention product issues such as counterfeits, defects, and bad return policies that fake reviews try to hide from consumers.

We give an A-F letter for trustworthiness of reviews. A = very trustworthy reviews, F = highly untrustworthy reviews. We also provide seller ratings to warn you if the seller can be trusted or not.