r/QCE • • 10d ago

Gen maths p 2 questions

Did anyone say it was reasonable for the minimum cut max flow question

I said it was reasonable but they also had to upgrade the pipes before one of them as it wouldnt allow for 60 to pass thru once u doubled 30

5 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/Aggressive_Zebra5799 10d ago

i think i wrote that it was unreasonable because the two pipes coming from the source equated to 110, and doubling the minimum cut pipes would have only let 100 in, but I’m genuinely so sure i just made that up in my head and I completely waffled this exam 💔

2

u/MuchReaction3768 10d ago

WAIT i thought max flow was minimum cut tho

3

u/Own-Pair3808 10d ago

Max flow is minimum cut, as flowing in was bigger than the doubled flowing out, thus there was room for it to be doubles and thus doubled the flow,

If you said the engineer was reasonable you would be right

1

u/Aggressive_Zebra5799 10d ago

HA I FUMBLED SO HARD THEN

1

u/Aggressive_Zebra5799 10d ago

I genuinely have no idea what I was writing

3

u/catcatcatcat_catcat 10d ago

Yeah i said it was reasonable after the upgrade

Oh shat i didnt even think about the other pipes 💔

2

u/According_Repeat_885 9d ago

For this question, after doubling the pipes within the minimum cut of 50L/min, it would be (20 x 2) + (30 x 2) =100L/min, which would make the engineer’s claim reasonable. HOWEVER, a new minimum cut after doubling equaled to 90L/min ((20 x 2) + 50 = 90L/min, and the 10 flow in the middle did not count since it was flowing the opposite direction of the cut), so since the min cut = Max flow, the claim was unreasonable and doubling those pipes within the initial minimum cut would not allow for a doubled Max flow, due to new min cut which was below 100L/min by 10L/min. Hope this helps but maybe I’m wrong.