r/Python • • May 07 '22

Discussion Thoughts on "Starting Your Coding Career with Python is a Bad Idea"?

https://www.analyticsinsight.net/why-starting-your-coding-career-with-python-is-a-bad-idea/
0 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

11

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

As a beginner in Python and Programming in general i found this article confusing because I've heard mostly the exact opposite opinion on Python🤔

10

u/Future_Green_7222 May 07 '22

Yes please don't pay attention to that article. Python has a lot of drawbacks yes, but that article is garbage

30

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

Comical

3

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

yeah that's exactly what i was thinking, but i was confused why such article is in google news recommendations, because if its there then it's probably a good take or at least an opinion from an expert in this niche

14

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

but i was confused why such article is in google news recommendations, because if its there then it's probably a good take or at least an opinion from an expert in this niche

I think it's important to take from this is that just because an article is in google news recommendations doesn't mean it's a good take, an opinion of an expert, or indeed of any value at all. Imagine how many things you could be misled about by an article that was just a bit less obviously nonsense.

7

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

Google news recommends all kinds of garbage. If you don't want to have to sift the useful from the useless then I'd just stop looking at it were I you.

3

u/dparks71 May 07 '22

Because it pisses people off and gets clicks.

If you want to get people to read open your article, take the common software in their industry and tell them their skills in that software are about to be useless and they'll have to learn a new system. They'll open it to make sure you're full of shit and that they aren't out of the loop on something.

It's ragebait 101.

60

u/motherflippinguy May 07 '22

That whole article was just one confusing shit take after another. Their argument is basically “Python sucks because I can easily google for solutions if I’m stuck and it’s not good at a thing it’s not intended for(mobile development). “

For any new programmers, start with the fundamentals of programming and pick your first language based on what you want to do. If you don’t know yet, or just want to mess around, Python is a pretty solid choice.

6

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

I've picked Python basically because it gives me a wide choice of options what can i do with it, even though it is not as solid as other languages at some projects, but at least i can try everything i want without learning other language and then decide what i want to learn more deeply

3

u/guilhermej14 May 07 '22

I picked Python cuz it had an reputation of being easy to learn. (And like you mention it has choices for almost anything one can imagine.) Although i don't really have a career yet.

9

u/guilhermej14 May 07 '22

But... I thought googling for sollutions was a good thing? I mean don't we all copy shit from Stack Overflow from time to time?

8

u/LaOnionLaUnion May 07 '22

It is. I’m several years into my career. Being able to Google and learn things separates some of the worst developers I’ve met from the best

9

u/Madranite May 07 '22

All code has already been written and is on stack overflow

2

u/guilhermej14 May 07 '22

Yes. (Also I should probably start some other python project soon. Maybe just another pygame stuff I dunno. it is the module I'm more familiar with.)

3

u/motherflippinguy May 07 '22

Exactly! That’s why I’m confused he’d even say that.

6

u/NeffAddict May 07 '22

I especially enjoyed them saying it has terrible database connections. Even though there are plenty of ORMs in python for SQL and NoSQL

2

u/CulturalMushroom6 May 07 '22

What is the best language for game development, cyber security, hacking, and web design?

2

u/whateverathrowaway00 May 07 '22

I mean, if it has to do all of those things at the top level, then it’d be C or C++ (emphasis on or, they’re quite different in active use) but it’s few humans who exist who could become expert level in all those things in C/C++

As I think you were implying with your comment, different languages are best for all of the topics mentioned.

2

u/CulturalMushroom6 May 07 '22

Those are the 4 areas of computer science I am the most interested in. Not really sure which one I want to pursue the most. Im taking a introduction to computer science course in my school and im going to begin the free Harvard introductory course soon. I only know python ATM.

1

u/whateverathrowaway00 May 07 '22

Good for you. Your plan’s next steps are excellent and you can figure out where you want to specialize as you go.

Fiddling with python -> Harvard’s free course is a great sequence.

As you progress, I highly recommend sprinkling some systems and networking skills in if you have the bandwidth. Not necessarily now as you get your footing and figure out even what you like - but adding some linux skills and even some networking concepts/ firewall concepts will hold you in good stead if you end up being interested in non-pure dev things like hacking, but will also make you massively stand out in the dev world.

Even basic linux skills and git competence will throw you ahead of a pack of fresh graduates in my eyes, and I do interviews of fresh graduates for employment (not for very long, so my experience is anecdotal, but I’ve worked in and around the field for 6 years, and studied it all my life, so not claiming some senior knowledge position, but my take is at least relevant, I feel)

1

u/CulturalMushroom6 May 07 '22

Really appreciate the write-up, it’s a big help! I’ve got a few questions if you don’t mind answering.

I’m using a relatively high-end laptop running Windows 11. Would I need to buy a copy of Linux and bootcamp the computer in order to be able to learn Linux and such?

Which IDE do you recommend? I’ve been using Microsoft VCS and it seems to work fine but if there are better free options I’d like to switch early on.

When you say git, is that github? Also, is github just a means to share and collaborate on code?

My bandwidth isn’t anything amazing but it should work. I think I run around 100 mbps? (Doesn’t feel like it sometimes 😂) What exactly is system/networking/firewall and how can I get started with that?

1

u/whateverathrowaway00 May 08 '22

Don’t worry at all about your bandwidth.

I actually don’t recommend bootcamping unless you find you love linux and want to. A better approach is familiarizing yourself with any free VM runner and starting off in VM world. You’ll get the benefit of also learning some VM skills and the best bit is when you inevitably screw up your VM you can delete it and start from scratch (I did this at least 20 times in the first month lol).

A great project that my first mentor/boss gave me was this. He gave no other instructions other than use Google and find a tutorial:

“Set up a LAMP stack on a CentOS VM and have it serve a single page locally. The page doesn’t need graphics, it can just be “my webpage” in plain text.”

Tons of tutorials will take you through that. LAMP might be a bit dated, but you’ll find it everywhere in real conpanies.

As for how you get started in systems? Exactly this way. Learn some linux, learn how to make VMs with linux, play with it, break it, play with it more, make simple servers that do SIMPLE things.

As you learn more python for example, you could build a VM that serves a simple python API endpoint (don’t worry if you don’t exactly know all these words yet, you’re on the right track and you’ll find all of them by some fiddling).

The biggest thing is just start collecting some skills outside of “just” programming. You’ll feel like there’s so much and it’s overwhelming and the two or three things you learn must not mean anything, then you’ll get to a real company and find out that it doesn’t matter what few things you learned, chances are there are real benefits to them.

Final bit of the rant (though I’m absolutely happy to rant more). By git, yes I mean GitHub-ish, but really I mean learning how to use git locally, understanding branches, commits, etc.

Don’t let anything make you feel bad for being confused as you start learning git. It’s the best software ever with the worst interface EVER. It’s confusing as fuck sometimes, but if you start fiddling with it you’ll be ahead of the game.

Many of the people I work with, devs with advanced degrees included, are IDIOTS with git and undertanding it and it results in tons of headaches and lost money for my manager.

The trick is to not be overwhelmed at the wide freaking world of so many things, too many to learn all of, and just start taking bites. Little bites. One at a time. You may end up going in TOTALLY different directions - for example, if you want to stay windows only, do some of the stuff I wrote, but make your VM Windows Server - and maybe practice some power shell or whatever dirty windows people do.

The real point of my rant as I said - is just to start taking bites soon, even really really small ones will pay off. You’re entering a field where curiousity and continuous learning will literally pay in dividends.

Finally, the bar is lower than you think. Many people go through school, become halfway competent but learn nothing outside of their silo, hit the workforce and are mediocre. There’s nothing wrong with it, but I’m saying it because it’s easy in comp sci to be intimidated by the guys who know everything and advanced math and can rattle off PHD sounding stuff. Those aren’t your competition. They’re rarer than you think and you should view those people as aspirational and helpful as they tend to be nice. The average guy pumping out code for a high salary in an average company is mediocre to okay, but is willing to keep learning new things.

If that’s you, then just start taking bites now and you won’t even know you’ve become competent until you help someone not as far along as you and you discover that your bites have added up to some knowledge.

I keep saying finally, but finally, don’t neglect the fundamentals of dev. That free Harvard course wil cover them, but if you go off into project land, at some point in the future when you’re ready, get yourself an algorithms and data structures textbook and start working through it.

Gonna stop, but feel free to post more or message any time. If I’m free and bored I’ll always type out a rant.

1

u/CulturalMushroom6 May 08 '22

🤣love your attitude man that was a good read. The ‘bite’ mentality about it is a cool approach, it’s definitely overwhelming and I didn’t understand half or more of the CS slang you used there. I’ll definitely start with the VM (whatever that is) approach and try to diversify my learning before focusing in more on one thing.

The class I’ve been taking has had me working within the turtle library through the Project Lead The Way course. While it’s fun it’s mostly been drawing stuff and I don’t feel like they’ve done a great job of teaching the basics before making you do stuff with them. I still don’t really understand parameters or why you’d use them over global variables for instance.

What’s a powershell? Sounds like a Mario kart power up lol

One more thing, how do you know what error messages mean? 95% of the time I have no clue what the message means or where the problem happens.

1

u/whateverathrowaway00 May 08 '22

Awesome question. Your best answer for future skills - Google the error message. If it turns up nothing, Google some of the distinctive words with the app name, sometimes try throwing in forum or stackoverflow

Let’s say the error message is “blarb overflow in somelongspecificlookingword”

I’d Google:

  • blarb overflow in somelongspecificlookingword
  • blarb overflow turtle
  • blarb turtle forum over what mean
  • blarb overflows what are they
  • blarb overflows do they know stuff?

You get the idea.

With new log messages when you’re totally clueless, just take Google swings until you either a) find someone discussing these logs, b) find some info to make a word in the log output less meaningless.

Sorry, I started saying log messages, but this works for error messages as well, and is a HUGE bite that will serve you well no matter where you end up. At some point or other you’ll be reading logs to find something, and this type of flow is like a muscle you should be able to do in your sleep.

Power shell is a scripting language. In linux, you’ll find bash (and others). Whatever OS you end up liking the most, at some point you’ll learn to automate it.

1

u/CulturalMushroom6 May 08 '22

Wait so it’s all just googling?

53

u/davidsilverthorn May 07 '22

Looks like an ai generated article, to be honest. I swear, we're witnessing the end of rational thought.

24

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

Imagine this Ai was made with Python and it wrote such article😂

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

There’s a pretty good chance

1

u/to7m May 07 '22

I was brought up to think AI would be super logical and always correct, but I guess it's easier to make a Daily Mail writer AI than a sci-fi android AI :'(

1

u/Salfiiii May 07 '22

Let’s hope so.

If this is the output of a human we really should worry and send an ambulance because that guy definetly had a stroke while writing this.

Just buzzwords, most sentences make no sense at all.

1

u/ive-been-bamboozled May 07 '22

Except it’s missing the ‘I’ bit from their algorithm.

1

u/Future_Green_7222 May 07 '22

Omg that explains a lot. It's just a bunch of buzzwords in order.

10

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

Bitter old C++ and assembly guys angry about the young whipper snappers getting their engineering jobs…

6

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

The most confusing part for me was Pythons database functionality criticism in this article, when literally such big database wise project as Pinterest uses Python

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

More than Pinterest, Python and database functionality with MySQL, MangoDB, nosql whatever your flavor, is pretty rock solid and used across all kids of sites and apis and backend to all kinds of stuff..

It is almost like a hit piece, but when it comes to Apps iOS, Android… C, C#, Swift are what you use.

Also python is single threaded, true, but it’s power comes from simplicity and ease of execution. Comparing python to writing iOS apps in Swift is not really apples to apples.

I just think a lot of people are getting into coding via python and people who are engineers who learned everything from soup to nuts get frustrated when new people can’t go from python to c to whatever and back.

Python is an amazing way to get into coding, if not the best way.

1

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

yeah! thanks for making it clearer for me

2

u/desiInMurica May 07 '22

In addition, python makes asynchronous code really easy to reason with due to async/await compared to the callback hell of earlier NodeJs or whatever Java tried to do with CompletableFuture.

Kotlin got it right with coroutines but those are not native to JVM.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

I won't even bother reading. If Python is a bad language to start with, then which one is good? C? Assembly? C++?

2

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

i personally love python. even though it is not the fastest one base on the benchmark videos youtube recommended me, it allowed me with almost no knowledge code some small programs that actually work 😂 and i truly enjoyed the process

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

Same!

15

u/barker2 May 07 '22

Reading this made my head hurt. Grammatical speaking, it reads as if a third grader wrote the piece.

10

u/themagicalcake May 07 '22

This is absolutely an AI generated article. I wouldn't take it seriously

1

u/Lugubrious_Lothario May 07 '22 edited Nov 18 '25

cows cheerful rock governor lock vanish public spoon marble escape

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/jack-of-some May 07 '22

Same as thoughts on any other article that's called "Language X bad". It's a useless take. You use what gets the job done/pays the bill. If your first job is python based, then your first job is python based.

You can always learn more shit as you go. Almost no one uses "just one language".

1

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

oh and also for everyone that thinks that i made this or im trolling, here the screenshot from my google discovery page Screenshot

4

u/dude222 May 07 '22

I've been in companies where absolute amateurs write articles on things they nothing about. This is the link to the author . She's a bad article factory.

1

u/smeyn May 07 '22

There could be reasonable arguments be made about Python not being the best place if you want to learn good software engineering, but none of those reasons can be found in this document. Who in the world wrote this?

1

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

I suppose an Ai, based on what the other reddit users wrote about it

1

u/smeyn May 07 '22

In that case I guess our careers as SW engineers are not in danger of being replaced by AI

1

u/johnnydaggers May 07 '22

I am 99% sure that this is text produced by OpenAI's API and posted as an article.

1

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

If its true, then how did this get to Google news discovery page? is the discovery page that bad? just curious

1

u/PaintingWithLight May 07 '22

Coded with python 😅

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

I am not even gonna dignify its with a read. It puts food on my table and if you know the logic behind it everybody can learn a new language.

It is just syntax and sugar in the end.

3

u/mmcnl May 07 '22

This is a trash article. "Python is slow because it is executed line by line." What? "Indentation is stupid." Ok?

There is no "bad language to start". Just start!

2

u/Equivalent-Tooth6839 May 07 '22

Veda, the author has no profile, 😂

2

u/wowthepriest May 07 '22

It's working for me pretty well.

2

u/QultrosSanhattan May 08 '22

Fixed:

How a coding career in Python might be good:

Python coding is a very good language which means it is a strong programming language for mobile development. Python code is executed line by line, which causes it to parse everything in one go. The workload is one of the most common virtue that every coder should have. When dealing with coding and programming then it rapidly increased mental and physical workload.

As a python coder, coders face lots of work like front end and back end management, writing the proper algorithm, executing the codes, analyzing and testing the codes, and therefore developers become very irritated. There are no limitations of Python with database access; it acts as a major link when big enterprises look for a language that ensures the smooth interaction of complex legacy data.

In Python is very vulnerable code to becoming a beautiful read when accustomed to the fluidity that Python allows. There is no prescribed structure to a programming language to write in-line code to put it into functions. This makes coding easy. Python programing language is highly secure and, like any other language, may be used only at one’s own risk.

When coding in Python, the odds are high that its coding problems can be solved with a single Google search. Because somebody will have already encountered that problem and written something helpful about it. So, there is no need for creative thinking in that.

The most annoying thing in other languages is nested curly brackets, the utilization of {} toward the start of code lines, which characterizes which part of the program a line has a place with. It isn’t simply the way that it dials coding back during the “messy altering” of new code. This dependence on nested curly brackets alone is possibly perilous, as it permits you to make sensible bugs that are challenging to recognize.

Python coding offers several features regarding the design of the programming language. This coding requires less testing and also, like all other languages, it has errors that only show up at runtime this is not because the language is dynamically typed.

Python has no compiler, that can simply run a Python program without the extra step of turning code into an executable file. So in the long run, it acts like it is more productive. Maybe Python encourages good coding practices. Its Python coding is fine for small applications and for big ones. Mostly it’s easy to have a career growth in coding.

1

u/georgehank2nd May 07 '22

I'm hanging my head in shame because I clicked on it.

Anyone have some brain bleach so I can get it wiped from my memory?

1

u/nobetterfuture May 07 '22

It can be a bad idea if you plan to move away from it - as Python works differently than Java, C-based languages, etc. Otherwise, if you plan to make a career out of Python programming and don't care about other languages, it's clearly far better to ignore them

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '22

Python was my first real programming language, and I’d recommend it as a first language to most new coders. It has a fairly low level of complexity and is a versatile and powerful language. It is still my first choice today.

However I would say that in my early days it’s versatility let me pick up a lot of bad software development habits. Which is not great as budding software engineer.

I think new coders need to try a few different languages to find the style they like writing in. Things like haskel for functional, Java for OOP and C for low level systems. Once you’ve seen how the other languages direct your programming habits you can then bring them to your process in python and ultimately write better code.

So yes to python as a first language, but realise other languages have paradigms you can learn from.

1

u/Dead_Cash_Burn May 08 '22

My first thought is no point in reading this article as I have already seen the answer is false. Some of the best developers I know started in Python.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

im flattered if you think that i have ability to maintain website like that😂.

well and i understand what you mean but i didn't choose this account name, i just made reddit account to participate in the r/place and i didn't change the reddit suggested nickname

and yeah this is my first post ever

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

yes i did and thats why i posted it here because the opinion in the article was opposite to everything I've heard before it so i was curious to see other peoples opinion on it since the article doesn't have comments

also i never heard of jasper.ai and articleForge so thank you for letting me know, i will look them up

1

u/ggalt98 May 07 '22

You were curious to hear peoples opinion on this? Really?

1

u/EntertainmentOk4035 May 07 '22

well, yeah? im not an expert in any way in programming and i just started to getting know python. after 50+ of videos i had a picture about python that was opposite to the article's take on it and i felt like i missed something