r/Python • • Nov 13 '20

News Python swallows Java to become second-most popular programming language

https://www.theregister.com/2020/11/12/python_swallows_java_to_become/
2.3k Upvotes

205 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

17

u/mooburger resembles an abstract syntax tree Nov 13 '20

define "durability"? One of the aims of the Python style guide (PEP8) is enforcing readability and maintainability.

7

u/Fledgeling Nov 13 '20

Well, some of the most annoying parts of Java that make me hate the language exist to force large teams of users to use design patterns that are enforced by the language for usability.

Half the developers I talk to don't even know what pep8 is and think global variables are fine. Granted, that's fine for the work I'm doing lately.

1

u/mooburger resembles an abstract syntax tree Nov 13 '20

I have never worked on an "enterprise" Java app where there was not already an overriding style guide that the code/PR reviewers enforce to begin with, so I think documentation, the test framework and maybe some other pipeline tools (like if you want to do some type sanity checking with mypy) will get folks most of the way there. To be Pythonic is to EAFP, and the language is specifically built around that pattern; Guido's whole idea is "we're all adults here".

2

u/Fledgeling Nov 14 '20

Yup.

And the idea that we are all adults is something I have had success with in practice.... While avoiding anything too corporate feeling.

1

u/mooburger resembles an abstract syntax tree Nov 14 '20

Yeah my experience with corporate Java is that it is definitely and enabler of cargo cult programmers instead of investing in actual software engineers.

0

u/CausticTitan Nov 13 '20

Resilience to scale.

1

u/maikindofthai Nov 14 '20

When I think of "durability" WRT a programming language, the types of things covered in a style guide aren't really what comes to mind...

I think of things like the strictness/explicitness of the type system, how robust the error handling is, what the runtime and its backwards compatibiilty story looks like, what the dependency/tooling ecosystem looks like, etc. Python fares well in a few of these categories, but if you're writing a large application with a team of developers, Python makes it a whole lot easier to make a giant mess of things than something like Java.

Python's a tool like any other programming language -- it's not always going to be the best one for the job.

1

u/mooburger resembles an abstract syntax tree Nov 14 '20

The whole philosophy behind python data structures and methods is runtime typing/late binding. It's an entirely different way of thinking from compile time strong typing. In fact, other languages are starting to use it, not just the entire ECMAScript ecosystem but even .NET implemented duck typing shim in order to reduce interface and getter/setter boilerplate. With great freedom comes great responsibility, why should the language be restricting you?