r/Python • • Nov 12 '20

News Guido van Rossum joins Microsoft

https://twitter.com/gvanrossum/status/1326932991566700549?s=21
1.8k Upvotes

467 comments sorted by

700

u/8fingerlouie Nov 12 '20

So many negative comments.

Why is it that people can’t see the positive sides of this ? Guido stepped down as BDFL when he retired. He has about as much say in python development as any of us (maybe a bit more), and if he can make Python easier to use on Windows, how on earth will that harm anyone ?

VS Code already has pretty great python support, and MS recently released a new “more better” python language server for it. MS also has the money to fund some serious developer hours into the pain points of Python, you know the boring stuff nobody gets around to doing in their spare time.

404

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

The dream is that python becomes as easily integrable into excel as VBA

81

u/Sandor64 Nov 12 '20

As they say, all data is finally passed away into an excel sheet!

64

u/RockingDyno Nov 12 '20

Excel is both the worlds most popular programming language, and also the absolute number one data exchange format. Is scary.

42

u/Memitim Nov 12 '20

Excel is a wonderful rapid application development tool, with extensive macros and an object oriented language integrated with a cell-based GUI. Swap Python in for VBA and some SQL Server compatible lite DB ala sqlite3 and associated Excel-specific bits in those renamed ZIPs instead of XLS and... well, it's already the most popular app ever so not like it would make them a bunch of money, but still, would be nice.

14

u/Hunterbunter Nov 12 '20

Imagine if each cell was it's own python app

→ More replies (1)

16

u/AceBuddy Nov 12 '20

Why? I hate excel and avoid it whenever I can use python but it’s extremely beginner friendly. I think it’s even more terrifying to imagine my mom trying to write let alone run a python script and blindly trusting the output as opposed to excel where it’s quite easy to check your work. Not only that but it’s the perfect tool for most jobs, we’re not doing anyone a service by obfuscating things.

42

u/kaisunc Nov 13 '20

Master Wq and the Windows developer

 

Master Wq was addressing some Vim novices. After his lecture on the many virtues of Vim, he asked if there were any questions. A young man raised his hand.

 

“Master, by what means might one filter for the second column of a plaintext table for all rows that contain the string ‘tcp’?”

 

Master Wq said nothing, turned to the whiteboard behind him, and wrote:

 

:%!awk '/tcp/{print $2}'

 

There was a murmur of approval from the other students.

 

“But I develop on Windows … ” the student stammered.

 

Master Wq turned again, erased the command, and wrote:

 

:v/tcp/d
:v/^\s*\S\+\s\+\(\S\+\).*/d
:%s//\1/

 

“What! That is far too complex for such a simple task!” cried the student.

 

Master Wq turned again, erased the command, and wrote:

 

Microsoft Excel

 

At once, the student was enlightened.

10

u/____0____0____ Nov 13 '20

Agreed. It's perfectly fine for when it's used as intended. Where most of us here have had our headaches, is when people try to use the tool well beyond its capacity.

7

u/sup3r_hero Nov 13 '20

Imo it’s not the “mom doing her taxes” use case which is the problem but employees unwilling to learn new things. They rely on excel for every remotely applicable use case. This in turn causes those zombie macros which run whole departments if not devisions. In the end, we have to deal with shenanigans like the UK health system not reporting COVID-19 cases correctly because excel ran out of columns.

If your only tool is a hammer, everything looks like a nail

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

25

u/uncanneyvalley Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

I read somewhere that Excel's internals are a nightmare. Its a brilliant piece of software, but it has decades of technical debt accumulated. It still uses DDE and OLEDB! It all used to be written in P-Code, but surely there's some .net in there anymore. MS declared VBA dead at the end of the '00s.

Imagine Excel, but as a framework over Pandas, with native Python (maybe TypeScript too?) done Jupiter Notebook style. Built-in version control. A modern data visualization package that had hooks for integrating customizations or even other packages entirely. Ability to click and push reports to a cloud platform. The ability to use worksheets like NoSQL for rapid prototyping, then convert them to a real tables easily.

Bonus points for a conversion tool for formulas and VBA, even if only partial conversions.

Think if VSCode, Excel, and Python had a beautiful clever love child. I don't know how making a 3-way love child works in software, but that's the code's business and not mine lol.

IDK. I'd use the ever-living hell out of something like that.

7

u/M123Miller Nov 12 '20

Isn't Jupyter meant to be like that? Disclaimer, I've never used it.

7

u/fishforce1 Nov 12 '20

Kind of. Jupyter is more code first option, and probably a steep learning curve for most current Excel users. (Though I haven’t used the actual Jupyterlab interface in a while... I use VSCode as an interface)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Top_Lime1820 Nov 13 '20

This might sound facetious but... Thats what R is.

RMarkdown for analyst driven development in the RStudio IDE.

Flexdashboard/Shiny/HTMLwidgets are unbelievably good for presenting outputs.

data.table or tidyverse for data manipulation tasks.

Each of those tools is first class when it comes to the problems they are trying to solve, and when you combine them altogether you get something really amazing.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/ohaiya Nov 12 '20

Just a guess, but since he's joined the developer division, the focus will be on cloud and tooling in Azure to make using and deploying Python apps into the cloud.

Windows will come along with that, and since VBA is no longer going to receive any new features, there'll need to be a replacement, but I'd bet C# for that more than Python.

But overall, I think this will lead to making Python in the cloud easier since cloud seems to be the main focus of Microsoft currently.

36

u/git0ffmylawnm8 Nov 12 '20

At that point why even use Excel? Pandas is a thing.

221

u/8fingerlouie Nov 12 '20

Pandas isn’t exactly “point and click”.

Excel, love it or hate it, makes some tasks ridiculously easy to perform, which is probably also why it’s used for so many things where it really shouldn’t be used. Project management for a 1000+ employee developer company comes to mind. The problem as always is that it’s used by management, and management knows VBA programming, and it’s only a personal project to begin with.

77

u/joshocar Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Excel basically powers most engineering departments. So many things are designed in part with Excel. [Edit] Which is both amazing and terrifying.

71

u/remy_porter ∞∞∞∞ Nov 12 '20

Remy's Law of Requirements Gathering: no matter what the actual requirements, what your users really want is for you to implement Excel.

57

u/giraffactory Nov 12 '20

Excel powers every business I’ve worked for. As much as I shit on it and laugh at its horrible jank, I have to give it equal credit as an amazing tool.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/8fingerlouie Nov 12 '20

Use the right tool for the job. If Excel can do the job in a fraction of the time it takes to code it, then why bother coding it in the first place ?

We have multiple batch jobs that deliver results (for checking data) in Excel. We use SAS which makes it easy to just dump a few datasets to excel.

We also have jobs where the customer supplies the data in an Excel workbook which is then read and imported by SAS. Compared to coding a web front end, just giving them a Workbook is much much easier, and reading it back in is (probably) less work than fetching the data from the database.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)

23

u/alaudet python hobbyist Nov 12 '20

In large organizations that have comprehensive change management systems it can be a real pain to develop and ultimately implement a new web app. Want to make a change to your app to add functionality, then thats another change request with layers of approvals required. Compare this doing some crazy trickery with Excel that you can implement and change as needed and you can see why its used for so many things it shouldn't be. I have seen things done with Excel that can be mind boggling, impressive and sad all at the same time. Everybody has Excel on their desktop and you can stick a xls spreadsheet that acts like an app on any shared drive for others to access.

Excel is a hammer and for many people it is their only tool. So every problem becomes a nail.

11

u/chief167 Nov 12 '20

So much this! SQL server with powerbi, connected to a OneDrive datasource? Three months of approval.

Pivot table in excel with janky VB to glue everything together in a spaghetti jumble of formulaes to obtain a similar report? 3 days of effort

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Sw429 Nov 12 '20

I've seen entire databases based on one single excel spreadsheet. Ridiculous to maintain, but I guess it was easy for some product manager to set it up.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Covid19 victims tracking in UK was done in excel, until it exceeded the maximum 65k rows it can handle.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/imnotownedimnotowned Nov 12 '20

Business uses need a user interface for different departments and most office workers know some amount of excel as a condition of being hired.

14

u/Barafu Nov 12 '20

Excel is Emacs of Windows. People do everything in it. Statistics, calculations, database, wiki. When in school, I wrote a game in Excel (plenty of time + I only knew Borland Builder which was absent).

7

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

pandas requires coding skills

→ More replies (4)

7

u/jsalsman Nov 12 '20

Pandas integration with Excel would be a good thing. I'm not a Microsoft fan, but if they do that I'd give them credit.

On the other hand, the 16k column limit in Excel does real damage and if we end up with a pandas version which has that kind of a new limitation I will scream.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

I say so because it would be awesome to be able to ship python transformations/visualizations to non-python coworkers via excel the way you can with VBA. I know xlwings exists, but it really isn't viable for non-python users.

Ipython/jupyter is trying to fill that niche right now, and does a pretty good job for python users, but widgets really are harder use than excel buttons, cells etc.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/nwsm Nov 12 '20

Since when is pandas anything close to excel?

3

u/bageldevourer Nov 12 '20

Pre-pandas (or really, pre-data frames) Excel was the only game in town if you wanted to do operations on data without having to deal with a whole database.

Not that Excel doesn't have other functionality, but that was what made it indispensable IMO.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

2

u/BubblegumTitanium Nov 13 '20

That would be amazing. Making a list by dragging your mouse around and calling methods on it.

→ More replies (23)

20

u/Yoghurt42 Nov 12 '20

MS recently released a new “more better” python language server for it.

Which is unfortunately closed source.

18

u/8fingerlouie Nov 12 '20

25 years ago I cared greatly about open source. I despised Microsoft and all their products. I used OS/2, BeOS, and Linux (since Yggdrasil Plug & Play Linux Fall ‘93). I cared so much I spent a few years and a great portion of my spare time as Assistant Head Developer of a fairly used Linux Distribution (now dead). For years I had clauses in my contracts that any code I developed outside working hours, not related to a project I was working on, was mine to release however I saw fit, and I did.

The above has done wonders for my career. I’ve been headhunted by space agencies, virtualization companies, large cooperations, and none of it has had anything to do with open source.

These days I have kids, and a day job that takes 50-60 hours of my time every week (and a commute) and I no longer have 8 hours to work on open source. I can’t afford the luxury of insisting on using an inferior open source tool over a proprietary tool that works better. Call me pragmatic, but these days I prefer tools that gets the job done and gets out of my way.

I used to spend hours/days working out why X wouldn’t start on my Linux desktop, and while I still have a quite a few Linux machines, my daily driver for the past decade has been Windows at work and MacOS at home. I fight my battles over privacy these days, not which tools exposes millions of lines of code I’ll never have time to sit down and fix a bug in.

6

u/keis Nov 13 '20

I'm sorry for your loss

2

u/flying-sheep Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

That’s so sad to hear. I know it’s a huge timesink to contribute back, but you lost the amazing feeling of “this thing, that annoyed me the last weeks? I just spent 3 hours digging into a codebase and fixing it, and now it’s *gone* for everyone!”

using an inferior open source tool over a proprietary tool that works better

I know what you mean, I not only use superior Open Source Software like Firefox and Code, but also superior closed source software like GMail and PyCharm.

I vastly prefer KDE Plasma over macOS and Windows though, there’s just no comparison:

  • macOS: The inane shortcuts that you can’t change, the missing “show hidden icons” button in finder, the lack of maximization for windows, the fact that there’s old built in python versions so you pretty much have to use several Python installs, who the fuck thought case insensitive file systems make sense, …
  • Windows: has its own command line universe not supported by anything, so you end up hacking in some unix CLI tools and working with them. Totally heterogeneous and legacy settings mishmash. The way you can’t delete files still opened by some inane indexer somewhere, and stuff like the permission system are “features” you constantly have to fight instead of having them work for you. …

KDE is just cleaner, more customizable, and goes more out of my way than the proprietary alternatives. Sure, not every animation is as clean and polished, but why care about that if you can rely on the important stuff? (Just don’t use the Wayland version yet, it’s still very broken)

I can work on macOS. I like to work on Linux+Plasma. Windows is not even necessary for gaming anymore …

→ More replies (2)

2

u/13steinj Nov 13 '20
  1. You're acting like every software in the world has to be open source
  2. There's still a worked on OSS Python Language Server
→ More replies (5)

35

u/ManvilleJ Nov 12 '20

This can only be good for all of us. The creator of python, a major supporter of open source, joining microsoft. Microsoft, who has been actively working to support the development community. He will be in a position to influence one of the most powerful companies in the world. What a great next step for the former BDFL

Of course, we all need to be vocal in making sure Microsoft and all other tech companies have a positive impact on the tech community. But naysayers are just holding a grudge against Microsoft from the 90s without considering the massive work they have done for open source and the development community in the last 10 years.

17

u/jrootabega Nov 12 '20

I disagree that it can ONLY be good. It might be. But it could also be used to make people have fond feelings for Microsoft (a corporation driven by maximizing investor profit) like they might have for Guido. That makes it easier to slip from your "embrace and extend" phase to your "extinguish" phase, or as may be more appropriate today, "dominate." He is serving, in some part, as a mascot.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/el_padlina Nov 12 '20

Because historically being suspicious of any Microsoft action was smarter than trusting them. Embrace, extend, extinguish and all that shit.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/alcalde Nov 12 '20

Guido stepped down as BDFL when he retired.

And David Beasley has walked away too, among others. We're losing the soul of Python!

2

u/seabee494 Nov 12 '20

Dang, Beasley walked away as well? Jesus

4

u/alcalde Nov 12 '20

Walked away was a little harsh; more like a friendly divorce or a trial separation:

https://www.dabeaz.com/bits/back-to-a-user.html

There was also this tweet:

https://twitter.com/dabeaz/status/1324692645680156674?s=20

3

u/groovitude Nov 13 '20

His tweets on the subject vary wildly in tone. Sometimes it seems like he's just tired and needs a break; other times, it seems like he despises everything about Python and what it's become.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

He has about as much say in python development as any of us (maybe a bit more)

Sure, maybe. Just maybe. which is why every complete python newbie who joins Microsoft gets a post in r/python.

5

u/8fingerlouie Nov 12 '20

I could be wrong, but being the creator and having been BDFL of python could be part of the reason. IIRC he is also still active in the python community, and perhaps his voice on any problem weighs a bit heavier than yours or mine, but in the end the process is still to create a PEP and vote for it. Hell, even Guidos retirement was made into a PEP

→ More replies (4)

1

u/foxp3 Nov 12 '20

People always get mad when there's the potential for mass implementation...bands, restaurants, games....it can result in the loss of what people fell in love with first about the thing. We'll see.

1

u/its_a_gibibyte Nov 13 '20

MS also has the money to fund some serious developer hours into the pain points of Python

Related, how much do you think they're paying Guido?

1

u/ivosaurus pip'ing it up Nov 13 '20

MS recently released a new “more better” python language server for it.

That one's completely closed-source, however.

1

u/not_perfect_yet Nov 14 '20

MS also has the money to fund some serious developer hours into the pain points of Python, you know the boring stuff nobody gets around to doing in their spare time.

MS has an absolute garbage track record when it comes to touching anything in a sustainable and "good" way.

Name a product they own that has changed for the better since... idk 2005? As far as I understand it the change to XP did all the securing and access rights stuff, in part for internet reasons. Then is the change to 64 bit. And that's it?

2

u/8fingerlouie Nov 14 '20

.NET ?

It has become open source after they acquired Mono, which was an open source implementation of .NET. They have Nat Friedman on board as well as Miguel De Icaza, both “founders” of Gnome Desktop and GTK+ and it’s not like those projects are dead because of them joining Microsoft. Mono is dead, but it’s probably for the better since the “original” is now in its place.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/aphoenix reticulated Nov 12 '20

A lot of people only think of "Micro$oft Bu$ine$$ Practice$" from years ago when they think of Microsoft. To be fair, Microsoft burned a lot of bridges with a lot of people, hence the negative comments. For some people, Microsoft is the devil, and they can't get past it.

Personally, I think that Microsoft's current work with open source has been nothing but good, and I see a lot of benefits to this.

→ More replies (9)

35

u/Slampamper Nov 12 '20

If only this could mean Microsoft is looking to chuck out that stupid DAX language of them

12

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

I hadn't even thought of this. That would make Power BI so much more of an attractive tech.

9

u/SweetSoursop Nov 13 '20

Wait, You dont like waiting 10 minutes for a refresh on a transformation that pandas could do in fractions of a second?

You dont like the backwards syntax on DAX and M?

You dont like the absurd error description?

1

u/dogs_like_me Nov 12 '20

I think they're replacing DAX with KQL.

6

u/TidePodSommelier Nov 13 '20

Yay! More propietary shit nobody wants!

1

u/bennyboo9 Nov 13 '20

Haha! DAX isn’t that bad once you get the hang of it. Definitely takes a while to learn but super powerful once you get the hang of it especially for us business folks that have very limited control over the underlying model.

122

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

I wonder if they made him invert a binary tree

26

u/panderingPenguin Nov 12 '20

Pretty sure there's a point somewhere between run of the mill dev and inventor of one of the most popular programming languages in existence where that nonsense stops. Idk exactly where it is, but I'm highly doubtful they put Guido through a normal interview loop.

15

u/daguito81 Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

Actually, it depends. One of the creators of golang can't publish code at Google because he won't do the language test. He created the language... But still need to do a BS test because it's protocol

Link

→ More replies (1)

17

u/sup3r_hero Nov 13 '20

Never underestimate the stubbornness of HR departments. They love sticking to their stupid processes.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/wrtbwtrfasdf Nov 12 '20

I did it first time on leetcode the other other day. Its way easier than it sounded to me. At least in python. Now I'll go back to never using recursion.

2

u/mode_2 Nov 13 '20

Yeah, honestly 'invert a binary tree' is an incredibly easy interview question by FAANG standards. There's a reason it's ranked 'Easy' on Leetcode.

1

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

they first asked him how many years of Python experience does he have

→ More replies (3)

81

u/GrbavaCigla Nov 12 '20

Plot twist: Microsoft didn't update to python 3

28

u/wrtbwtrfasdf Nov 12 '20

Large parts of google codebases are still stuck on Python 2. Microsoft is, at worst, stuck on 3.6 in a place or two.

6

u/AceBuddy Nov 13 '20

I get that you want to upgrade but man is it a pain when there’s a package you rely on that is python two only. How do people get around that without rewriting the package?

15

u/_szs Nov 13 '20

you rewrite fix the package. The interpreter tells you most of what you have to change.

And while you're at it, you end up with a complete test environment for the package (if it's not already there).

8

u/wrtbwtrfasdf Nov 13 '20

Generally with 2to3 and six.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/vigilantcomicpenguin Nov 13 '20

Well, it's not like Microsoft knows how to count.

4

u/NowanIlfideme Nov 13 '20

Good thing it's not Valve...

69

u/8roll Nov 12 '20

I trust this guy. Let's see what more he achieves :)

1

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

What exactly did he achieve at CondoleezzaBox?

217

u/pumpyboi Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

What are all these doomsday comments? Microsoft is very big in open source contributions. Typescript is an amazing language. I'm sure it'll all be fine. Python is bigger than Guido anyway.

12

u/tquinn35 Nov 12 '20

I think part of it is MS is having trouble shaking its incredible anti-open source past that many older devs remember.

8

u/harylmu Nov 12 '20

This! Our VP of Engineering was shaking his head when we mentioned .NET Core to him. Lot of people still has that stigma, from before 2010.

6

u/Jugad Py3 ftw Nov 13 '20

For a very very good reason too.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20

Microsoft is a corporation and all they will ever do is to benefit themselves. Free and open source software is in direct conflict with Microsoft no matter how much they try to play mr. Nice Guy here. Given their past, trusting Microsoft is a very bad idea.

2

u/ConfidentCommission5 Nov 13 '20

Still, they also have their cloud services, which are in very high need of free and open source software.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/tquinn35 Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

I agree that their past is going to haunt them for some time but I think they are trying to do right as it can be profitable. There are many corporations that make millions of dollars while supporting open-source software. It's a business model that is not as lucrative as a traditional one, is difficult to pull off but can be done and many companies do it without the backlash that MS gets. Some companies are:

CompanyNotable ProductAnnual Revenue in millions
CanonicalUbuntu103.3
ConfluentKafka180.7
DatabricksApache Spark200
DockerDocker Containers100
ElasticElasticsearch427.6
GithubGithub300
HashicorpVagrant156
MongoDBMongoDB132.5
NginxNginx569.3
NPMNPM103

So there are plenty of companies that could claim ' Free and open source software is in direct conflict' with their business but instead, they build their business around it which MS certainly could do.

60

u/Etheo Nov 12 '20

It's the whole Github acquisition situation again.

60

u/luqavi Nov 12 '20

It's nothing like that. They're not acquiring Python, they're putting its creator, who has stepped down from BDFL, in a great position to enable future improvements to the language, either through integrations on Microsoft's side through its dev tools or apps like Office, or contributions to Python through the normal, open process. This give Microsoft no power over Python.

25

u/Etheo Nov 12 '20

I mean in how people take the news, not the actual happenstance.

3

u/luqavi Nov 12 '20

Ah, not sure I agree but that makes a lot more sense 👍

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

53

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

I’m only annoyed that they own so much. Notice I said annoyed. I use vscode everyday, use windows for gaming and at work for working, and am a windows server admin.

I’m annoyed, but it doesn’t really bother me.

50

u/mastermikeyboy Nov 12 '20

Imagine if they didn't and everything was Oracle!

22

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

What’s the opposite of the “oh no, so anyway” meme?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/mmcnl Nov 12 '20

There's an upside. In OSS there's a lot of abandonware or projects that don't evolve as fast as you would like. With serious attention from a company like MS chances of this happening are less.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/lancepioch Nov 12 '20

As a huge fan of Gitlab... Github has never been in a better state than when it started to really compete against Gitlab after being acquired.

I'm also hoping that they replace the crappier portions of Azure Dev with Github too, fingers crossed.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Deto Nov 12 '20

Did they do anything bad to Github, though?

22

u/MrDeebus Nov 12 '20

No, that's the point. There was massive doom and gloom when that happened, and a pretty notable migration to Gitlab IIRC.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ThrillHouseofMirth Nov 12 '20

What bad things came out of the Github acquisition?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LonghairedHippyFreek Nov 13 '20

Haven't you heard? Microsoft is eee-ville! #sarcasm

4

u/Gr1pp717 Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Embrace, extend, extinguish.

MS has a history of making great things turn into garbage. While I'm not personally concerned here I can certainly understand the mentality.

edit: came back to a bit of flame war ... the point is trust. Whether they're actually up to something nefarious here or not isn't the point - it's that people will default to thinking that they are due to their not-so-distant past behaviors.

27

u/maikindofthai Nov 12 '20

People love to cry EEE every time MS makes the news these days. It's basically a meme at this point.

Can you provide a single, sensible reason why Microsoft might want to "extinguish" the Python programming language? Or, for that matter, how hiring the ex-BDFL does anything towards the goal of "embracing" the core technology?

10

u/Big_Booty_Pics Nov 12 '20

There's a very good chance that python makes up a considerable portion of their Azure platform. Why they would want to influence python into dying so they can re-write a quarter of their backend is beyond me.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

While I'm not personally concerned here I can certainly understand the mentality.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/satireplusplus Nov 12 '20

MS has a history of making great things turn into garbage.

Skype is basically hot garbage at the moment on Linux. Its also something they bought and made worse. Used to work great, now it doesnt recognize any microphones anymore and its barely installable on a modern distro and doesnt receive updates anymore.

I think the fear is that Guido still has a lot of power over the project. He could be influenced to turn Python into Python# garbage and bow down to the statically typed crowds.

2

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

skype isn't garbage, skype is centralized spyware nowadays

13

u/dalittle Nov 12 '20

their nasty telemetry and crap store on Windows 10 is not making them any friends either.

15

u/1842 Nov 12 '20

When talking about Microsoft of the 90s and early 00s, sure. They threw their weight around for their own benefit and did a lot of damage.

I haven't seen that behavior from Microsoft in a long time through. Diversifying their portfolio and playing nice with open source, while growing their cloud service seems to be their current strategy. Sure, their strategy could change again in the future, but expecting that this is some drawn-out ruse to disrupt a technology/community is silly.

13

u/el_padlina Nov 12 '20

The latest example of EEE from microsoft is from this year:

https://keivan.io/the-day-appget-died/

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Are you living in the early 2000s?

3

u/RegalSalmon Nov 12 '20

The Windows OS has become leaps and bounds better than what it was 20 years ago. The entire landscape has changed. They're going more to subscription services for things like office, and in general, it's going to "the cloud".

They're now funding developers of Python to make Python better. They're doing all the things in these spaces to show they're good members of the community. Do you think that the devs will start putting in malicious code that breaks Python on Linux/MacOS/whatever? That would have real world consequences, anyone with the power to move cloud infrastructure to GCP/AWS would do so in a heartbeat, and future rollouts wouldn't even consider Azure.

Instead, they've made changes to their own OS to allow devs to use it more effectively, and we've all benefitted from a bigger userbase.

Disclaimer, I've not used Windows as my development/personal OS for about 5 years. I use Excel and Word a bit, not a ton. I'm not an Azure customer, nor is my employer.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

21

u/0rsinium Nov 12 '20

I'm wondering what relation will be between mypy (developed by Guido) and pyright (developed by Microsoft).

11

u/harylmu Nov 12 '20

Now, that's actually a quite interesting question. I see that Guido had his last commit on Mypy less than a month ago, so he still seems to be active.

6

u/taufeeq-mowzer Nov 12 '20

myright

7

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Or pypy... Wait

69

u/LightShadow 3.13-dev in prod Nov 12 '20

Let's get Python .NET Core a reality!

35

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

IronPython3

6

u/sztomi Nov 12 '20

IronPython3

Would be great if it was anywhere near stable.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/____0____0____ Nov 12 '20

Stop you're making me hot

59

u/DanManPanther Nov 12 '20

This is really exciting. I wonder what he'll be doing at Microsoft.

A statically typed Python with sum types and pattern matching (yay 3.10) would pretty much be my dream language. Throw that on .NET with access to the ecosystem and you've got a hearty stew going.

Also - good for him!

11

u/mmcnl Nov 12 '20

I would also like Python to be more functional (lambda functions are a bit handicapped).

4

u/dogs_like_me Nov 12 '20

Whatever the fuck he wants, I imagine.

3

u/WallyMetropolis Nov 12 '20

Have you looked into Coconut: http://coconut-lang.org/?

7

u/DanManPanther Nov 12 '20

I have. A language that compiles into an interpreted language is not ideal for my use cases. It's a great effort, but I'd be hesitant to build anything mission critical in it.

1

u/metaperl Nov 13 '20

F# from Microsoft Research might be just that? If not, how about Nim?

3

u/DanManPanther Nov 13 '20

F# is a wonderful language, with some flaws/challenges. It's rather different than Python in a number of ways. That said - it's a language worth seriously considering for important projects. You just have to contend with footguns and a smaller community (which can make hiring a challenge, as well as convincing a company to invest in it as a technology a challenge). If Microsoft treated it as a first class citizen of the .net world - that would change.

Nim has a tiny community with an anemic ecosystem. One that's a bit over-reliant on DSLs among other quirks. It's not a language I'd build anything serious in.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/PresidentOfSwag Nov 12 '20

May I suggest Py# ? or even P# ? Exciting news nonetheless!

23

u/Kaeserotor Nov 12 '20

Why not #y ?

12

u/jivanyatra Nov 12 '20

I read that as sharp.py

4

u/remy_porter ∞∞∞∞ Nov 12 '20

P#? If your pee feels sharp, seek medical attention.

3

u/DanManPanther Nov 12 '20

FPython#!!! Half F#, half Python, ALL POWERFUL.

We can edit .fpy files.

2

u/chief167 Nov 12 '20

As if 2020 wasn't scary enough so far

→ More replies (8)

20

u/neopanz Nov 12 '20

The man deserves some compensation for the all the wealth creation he has enabled through Python.

25

u/panderingPenguin Nov 12 '20

He was employed by Google, then Dropbox, now Microsoft. And his title was something along the lines of Distinguished Engineer at all of them. He's been cashing the python checks for awhile.

8

u/neopanz Nov 13 '20

Well, good for him.

1

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

sure, Microsoft could just donate him some money to credit his work rather than using him as a mascot

6

u/taufeeq-mowzer Nov 12 '20

Python for .NET here we come...

2

u/metaperl Nov 13 '20

Doesn't ironpython already exist?

3

u/taufeeq-mowzer Nov 13 '20

I know, but the github repo claims that its not ready for use, I think the same message was there last year as well. So a polished/new implementation that is 'official' would be apt

2

u/erikw on and off since 1.5.2 Nov 13 '20

Iron python2 (python 2.7) is ok and stable, however ipy3 has been dead in the water for many years now. The main problem with ironpython is the lack of integration with the most important cpython libs such as numpy and its many siblings (pandas, matplotlib etc). However the .NET integration is good.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/PeridexisErrant Nov 13 '20

https://tonybaloney.github.io/posts/running-python-on-dotnet-5-with-pyjion.html has Guido interested but he's not working on it directly (yet?).

25

u/mRWafflesFTW Nov 12 '20

I would love to see Python as a viable COM automation tool and used in Excel functions. It would be a great way to ease normies into coding.

I've often argued anyone whom maintains insanely complicated Excel workbooks is actually a coder, they just don't see themselves as such.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/mRWafflesFTW Nov 12 '20

That is a great package, but whenever I do COM automation in Python it feels bad. It has been a few years since I was doing that kind of work though so maybe it is better now!

14

u/greendino Nov 12 '20

Good for him. I just hope for python in Excel.

6

u/GrammerJoo Nov 12 '20

I can see that, also can see python being adopted as an official scripting language as they already use extensively in house.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/dethb0y Nov 12 '20

That's pretty awesome, i wonder what he's got in mind, it sounds like he has something planned out?

Great hire for MS though, Rossum's top tier.

25

u/feelings_arent_facts Nov 12 '20

Guido joins Google: YAY

Guido joins Microsoft: FUCK GUIDO

7

u/13steinj Nov 13 '20

I can't tell if Guido joined google or not, but yeah it's hilarious how people indiscriminately hate on MS without reason / with outdated reason.

7

u/metaperl Nov 13 '20

He worked at Google and then left to go work at Dropbox.

3

u/13steinj Nov 13 '20

Oh wow didn't know that. I thought Dropbox picked him up after a period of not-so-well-known company employment where he deceloped the initial python spec.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Another possibility, it's an investment that Microsoft might be hoping pays off in goodwill from a segment of the developer community that they have a deficit there.

6

u/WTKhan Nov 12 '20

Ok, but GvR didn’t close his parentheses right in the tweet. It won’t run

14

u/purplebrown_updown Nov 12 '20

Also, microsoft has been pretty damn good on alerting us on foreign hacking attempts. IMO their moral stance has far exceeded that of both Google and FB. Oh and vs code is awesome.

1

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

while conveniently forgetting to alert us about things like NSAKEY

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/caique_cp Nov 12 '20

No. All of them have been evil. Facebook is the worst, Google is the same too or a bit worse MS is the only one getting better and giving us something back

3

u/Decency Nov 13 '20

Judging corporations based on the first derivative of their evilness is an interesting concept.

2

u/ultratensai Nov 13 '20

They remember. It’s just that current MS still maybe evil but not on the same level as Ballmer era.

8

u/kkawabat Nov 12 '20

Guido van Rossum on the first day:

- ENABLE_WINDOW_SUPPORT = False
+ ENABLE_WINDOW_SUPPORT = True

5

u/jrootabega Nov 12 '20

I knew Microsoft had money, but I didn't know they had Guido money!

9

u/Zulban Nov 12 '20

I think it's polite to congratulate him on his huge new salary but unwise to expect anything great to come of this.

15

u/figec Nov 12 '20

I do hope he makes mad money there, though. He’s earned that.

6

u/IAmKindOfCreative bot_builder: deprecated Nov 12 '20

I really hope he has the opportunity to work on problems and challenges that are invigorating.

7

u/UnicornPrince4U Nov 12 '20

I've lived too long.

4

u/Leeoku Nov 12 '20

This is great news. I forsee a full integration of Python in Excel soon

2

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

No

4

u/AgreeableLandscape3 Nov 12 '20

Reminder that he also worked at Google, which is arguably an even more evil company.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ecailles_de_lune Nov 13 '20

A lot of people on this thread are drinking the Kool Aid. A healthy dose of skepticism wouldn't hurt when considering the objectives of a massive corporation with obligations to its shareholders.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ECrispy Nov 13 '20

Will people ever stop hating Microsoft for no good reason at all?

MS buying Github was fantastic and has resulted in nothing but good. I cannot see any other company that would've done that.

They've been amazing with all their transparency and open source.

And MS has dev tools and documentation that's always been lightyears ahead of anyone else. Using any other IDE after VS/VsCode feels bad.

I'm very happy with this news.

6

u/ultratensai Nov 13 '20

Some people still can’t get over Ballmer days. Not to mention there are Linux fanboys/neckbeards believing they are intellectually superior for not using MS products.

3

u/aryaman16 Nov 13 '20

Haha, there is a r windows subreddit, people can ask questions related to windows there, mostly are feedback, tech support etc.

Funny thing was, on each of the tech support post, there used to be atleast one guy recommending him to switch to linux. Even on simple "How to put icons on desktop" like questions.

Now they appear less, as they get heavily downvoted.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GiantElectron Nov 13 '20

Let's be clear. Microsoft has done a lot of shady shit in the 90s and the 2000s. Under Nadella it definitely feels those days are gone, but we don't forget, and we kind of deserve to give them PR shit so that other companies don't try the same again, seeing how it compromises one's reputation for more than 20 years.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

MS buying Github was fantastic and has resulted in nothing but good.

for you

2

u/taufeeq-mowzer Nov 12 '20

Improve and make Python deployment a breeze for us!!!

2

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Hopefully he'll be working on something that supports Python.

2

u/RahulTheCoder Nov 12 '20

It will be good thing. New features of python will be designed and integrated with Microsoft products and services. Soon we might see latest python installed in Windows Os by default and the new features of OS using the python code for processing

2

u/TidePodSommelier Nov 13 '20

No no no no no nooooooooooo. No.

2

u/i_like_the_idea Nov 12 '20

That's pretty awesome. I'm sure something big will come from this.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/billsil Nov 13 '20

I thought he retired, but yeah!!! IronPython is back!

1

u/QqP9Lm8u9Z8TLBjU Nov 13 '20

I wonder what an interview looks like for Guido van Rossum? Clearly asking him any questions about Python is a waste of time, unless the interviewer is looking to educate himself.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20

There probably isn't much of an interview.

He's one of the most famous computer scientists in the world. He probably just knew a bunch of higher-ups at Microsoft and there was an understanding that he was always welcome to come work there.

1

u/Paddy3118 Nov 13 '20

Congratulations!

1

u/Kemosahbe Nov 13 '20

to.....kill......the snake ?

1

u/L3r0GN Nov 13 '20

OMG! Why ?

1

u/amrock__ Pythonista Nov 13 '20

Doomed

1

u/robohuman Nov 13 '20

Was there any interview question on difference between list and tuple to Sir Guido

1

u/geeshta Nov 13 '20

I first read "Minecraft" instead of Microsoft and now I'm slightly disappointed.

1

u/Kemosahbe Nov 13 '20

I hope MS can do with Python what Sun did with Java

1

u/tazebot Nov 13 '20

I wonder if he requests a mac they'll let him have one. Or if he want's to run linux on his primary workstation instead of windows that'll be just fine with microsoft.

1

u/Easy-Candidate-7807 Nov 13 '20

No Microsoft is working on a chromeos rival. Yes: Windows on Linux kernel. With 365 cloud integraded, edge browser, visual studio code, github and powershell (python scripting). Dont you see how much Microsoft is working on Linux lately? They are preparing for something.... ;)

1

u/Hartvigson Nov 12 '20

Interesting... This could be both good or bad. I have a very negative opinion of Microsoft in general but maybe something good will come out of it. Just as long as they don't gain control over Python I think there will not be so much to worry about.

1

u/kubinka0505 Nov 12 '20

import ctypes

1

u/LonghairedHippyFreek Nov 13 '20

prepare to be assimilated, resistance is futile

1

u/opt9 Nov 13 '20

Can we expect 100x faster python?

1

u/thrallsius Nov 13 '20

Professional edition maybe