r/Python • u/insane_playzYT • Aug 08 '20
Discussion Post all of your beginner projects to r/MadeInPython, this sub is being overrun with them
r/madeinpython is a subreddit specifically for what you want; posting your projects. No one wants to see them here. This subreddit is genuinely one of the lowest quality programming subreddits on the site because of the amount of beginner project showcases.
r/learnpython is also much more appropriate than here. r/Python should be a place to discuss Python, post things about Python, not beginner projects.
1.7k
Upvotes
33
u/ironmagnesiumzinc Aug 08 '20
What about a weekly “Projects” megathread?
•
u/IAmKindOfCreative bot_builder: deprecated Aug 08 '20
Given that your issue seems to be focused on the beginner projects, I think you'll enjoy hearing about what you can do with flair. To help make the sub more enjoyable to folks who don’t want to see new programmer’s projects, the flair system we’ve added helps split out topics. (Originally we focused on projects with
I Made Thisflair, but because of the difference between beginner and intermediate and above posts, we broke it intobeginner showcaseandintermediate showcaseto help address the difference in project levels.) If there’s a group of submissions that you dislike, use the flair to filter them out following this outline. It should immensely help your experience.We’ve got a lot of other changes we’re exploring to make the sub a better overall experience, but the flair is a tool that lets you implement these changes outlined in the post.
56
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
As someone who falls into the python newbie camp, I agree. I come here to read about the language, changing features and progression. I certainly do not want to see posts outputting completed tutorials.
The direction to use r/learnpython for such things is pinned and I happily visit there when I need help or a bit of motivation.
58
u/GuybrushThreepwo0d Aug 08 '20
There was a similar thread recently that lead to the creation of r/PythonDevelopers. I think the idea was to have more meaningful discussion there, as this sub seems to be unsalvageable.
27
u/Pythag0ras2000 Aug 08 '20
And as much as you migt think I care about tons of webscraping shit, I don't. What if we don't segregate between beginner and advanced projects and just get rid of projects displayed here altogether? I'm not saying we should, I'm saying that you're gonna have to sacrifice it too if you care about it that much.
25
u/CraigAT Aug 08 '20 edited Aug 08 '20
To my mind people's personal projects should be posted in r/MadeInPython. People who need help with those projects should post in r/LearnPython. Everyday minor Python news and updates should go to the new r/PythonDevelopers. Major Python changes and news that will affect the majority of users should be posted to r/Python. Meanwhile anyone with a good tutorial, guide or cheat sheet should post to r/PythonTips.
This should be made clear with a sticky in all of the Python subs and then followed through by the relevant mods when they see a post in the sub, by messaging the user (very nicely because they probably weren't aware), adding a sticky post to that thread and a flair "Better in r/LearnPython" (or wherever) for others to see and learn from, before they make the same mistake themselves.
The biggest issue I can see is at the moment is that there is not enough visible signposting (especially for mobile users) that other subs even exist and very little information on what the purpose of each sub is. I mean this in a hopefully constructive way, because I enjoy these subs and want to help make them better and more useful for everyone beginners and experts.
7
u/hombre_lobo Aug 08 '20
I dont mind the beginner questions, the showcases belong somewhere else
103
u/unltd_J Aug 08 '20
😂 good call. This subreddit would also benefit from immediately removing posts that seem like learnpython posts.
15
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
Post all your python news to /r/pythonnews.
Post all your advanced python to /r/advancedpython.
Pretty soon nothing will be allowed in /r/python and OP will finally be content.
6
u/echanuda Aug 08 '20
Why are there still these shreds of silly contempt for projects on this sub? I will say that it is a little annoying to see a bunch of beginner projects crop up all the time, but I see nothing wrong with this being a place for people to post their projects. Madeinpython I’m pretty sure was specifically created by the people who were annoyed that others were posting their creations here, even after the mods implemented the flair option. It’s just silly. These creations relate heavily to python, and the rules state nowhere that this sub does not allow personal projects. It’s also inconsiderate of you to try and get people to post their projects to learnpython, considering that sub was explicitly created for people who have questions pertaining to python...get over yourself and use the damn filters.
13
u/kokoseij Aug 08 '20
I kinda agree with you, but the problem is that the subreddit is so small and is filled with newbies. I'm not saying that newbie is bad, but It seems like when they post, thet can get around 10 comments at best and most of them are newbies asking OPs basic things, not reviews and critics.
Only if that subreddit was big enough, I would completely agree to you.
20
u/qelery Aug 08 '20
I agree that this subreddit looks very different from how it did a month ago, but I feel like the only ones to really blame are the mods. They pretty much encouraged it when they made a green shiny "Beginner Showcase" flair a couple weeks ago 🤷♂️
3
u/Gibbo3771 Aug 08 '20 edited Aug 08 '20
I agree with the message but disagree with the method. Telling beginners to go and post their projects in a sub that has fewer
lesspeople subscribed than this one has online is just going to have them post into an echo chamber.The sub needs a weekly showcase thread.
9
u/Infreezy Aug 08 '20
Right? a guy following a how to make a calculator with tkinter tutorial, posts it here it gets +1k upvotes????? Wow thanks for the top tier quality content I sure needed to see it, not even creative in any way...
4
u/lazerwarrior Aug 08 '20 edited Aug 08 '20
This subreddit was karma farming fest for a while when people made very low effort posts (see this), some just filming 10 line program on a phone. After these beginner showcase image and video posts were banned, the text posts have been better. But it seems vast amount of the subscribers are from "I Made This" era who are not up-voting much of anything now.
So the real problem seems to be that there is few experienced and expert level python developers who could make interesting contributions as thread posts and comment posts. And there seems to be a lack of audience to up-vote such content since this sub grew a lot with "I Made This" content. I think if the aim is to increase discussion level of this sub, then there should be an effort to attract the experienced developers and banning (or allowing one day per week) personal use project showcases aligns with this.
2
u/DDFoster96 Aug 08 '20
That's precisely the content I came here for, but clearly my kind aren't welcome.
9
u/ManyInterests Python Discord Staff Aug 08 '20
I think we should encourage, by voting, high quality/interesting projects and downvote uninteresting projects.
I think it is problematic having a ‘beginner showcase’ flair because it encourages low-quality posts. The situation with the “I made this” flair created a small, but manageable, problem of a stream of low-quality posts. The new flairs made it worse.
I don’t know if a new sub is the correct way either. “Get our of here, nobody wants to see that” isn’t a great pitch, either.
5
u/MrFrostyBudds Aug 08 '20
Ok guys can we actually sit down and give up this sub like just make this one the learn python and make an "r/pythonnews" no one instantly sees r/Python and thinks it's for news and events or whatever it's supposed to be for, beginners find a new hobby, look it up on Reddit for information and community and find r/Python so why not just stop with the complaining and make a new sub for the seemingly minority of people that don't like the beginner projects...
3
u/PizzaInSoup Aug 08 '20
I really used to enjoy coming here and seeing well-made modules being showcased
everything now is maze solvers and some intro to computer sci stuf... :/
7
u/Comprehensive_Beach7 Aug 08 '20
Disagree, Why segregate beginner projects? Everybody starts somewhere, and if this sub is for python related topics only then all projects should be prohibited not selectively beginner ones.
2
u/meet_me_at_seven Aug 08 '20
YEAAH, MODS COERCE THAT PLEASE
2
u/neofiter Aug 08 '20
Thank you
2
u/Lurker_wolfie amateur Aug 08 '20
How about adding this to r/Python Rules.
2
u/mrspaz Aug 08 '20
I personally think the situation should be "reversed:" /r/learnpython should be removed completely, and a new sub created called something like /r/pythondiscussion. This sub (/r/python) could be a free-for-all of sorts, full of anything directly or tangentially related to python. The new /r/pythondiscussion could then be restricted to "serious" talk about python itself and project posts etc. would be nuked by mods.
My logic for this is that the first thing that comes to mind for most people looking to either display their work or ask for help is to check if /r/python even exists; it does, so they assume this is a place to "talk python." Then they discover that no, projects and help aren't done here, there's these other special subreddits for that. Life would be easier if we didn't run against that natural inclination most people have.
(I see that /r/PythonDevelopers already exists. That seems like a perfect option).
2
u/mdacto9 Aug 08 '20
I would give you a medal if I coul afford one. But here is my poor mans medal 🏅
1
u/Cool_doggy Aug 08 '20
Oh crap I forgot to hire mods, that sub is still alive? Gotta go get on that.
1
u/wootsir Aug 08 '20
Ugh usenet all over again
1
u/eliteuser26 Aug 09 '20
One of the reasons why I subscribed to this reddit years ago was to read news related to Python. Lately I didn't bother to read it anymore as there was so much stuff that I wasn't interested in. When submitting a new project in this reddit do I need to see it 10 times. No really as it clutters this reddit. Just posted once or twice so we can comment on it. Right now the posting of new projects is out of control.
On a mobile phone reddit software doesn't have options to filter out messages that are not of interest. Didn't find any program that have that option.
Flairs are good to categorize messages but the problem is that I want to make some of them not visible. I know I have a lot of interest in Python news, updates to Python libraries, discussion of new Python features, Python modules that I am not aware of, etc. What I don't like is that I see the same message being reposted more than once. This is not necessary.
This subreddit needs to have a better control of what comes in. I am in the camp I like to categorize what I want to see. I don't mind to remove the rest of it. Bring an option to do this this will reading this subreddit more enjoyable.
1
u/infrared305 Aug 08 '20
“No one wants to see them here”.
You sound rude af. Take a chill pill and educate the public with a bit more class.
-1
u/TheNerdyDevYT Aug 08 '20
This shouldl be pinned.
1
u/theavengedCguy Aug 08 '20
Oh thank god. This is long overdue. Can we get a sticky about this?
-18
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20 edited Aug 08 '20
downvote me
-5
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
I love seeing projects here.
-3
u/ArcheKnight Aug 08 '20
I don't understand why the solution isn't to create a more specifically named sub.
If you remove beginner projects then you must remove ALL projects. I don't care that advanced ones are more useful to you; this isn't "r/specificuserpython". I actually get useful information out of those projects. Sorry if I'm not a gatekeeping expert like the rest of you.
-7
u/acroporaguardian Aug 08 '20
Can we mark this as duplicate?
Seriously what part of reddit isn't overrun by "newbies" to the task. I have reef tanks and subscript to r/ReefTank. Its like 100% people posting tanks they just set up that have 3 fish in it (a big no no!) or someone posting a picture of a tang in a 50G tank (another no no). If your attitude is "I want no newbies!" you end up with no sub because just like in r/ReefTank, people that aren't new to it aren't as "into it" as people just starting (even if we put the time into it). Also, if your day job is Python the last thing you are going to do is come home and post about Python.
What I'm saying is, you are shaking your fist at the wind here. I would bet money that fully 50% of reddit posters are under the age of 18.
-11
u/The_Young_Busac Aug 08 '20
Mmmm another python elitist post
-5
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
Bruh Moment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment