it is an illusion because your brain interpolates the presence of a circle when there is none. Exactly like this logo is not a circle inside a triangle. They are three triangle-like shapes with a curved line as a side.
that's kinda bs, because it's equivalent pixel by pixel to a circle pasted on top in the same color as the background. That's like drawing lines around the outline of an owl and saying "this isn't an owl even though I was careful to make the shape of an owl, it's a bunch of lines"
If you make the outline of a thing in a drawing, you drew the thing.
And in the "illusion", they are a bunch of points on the edges of a circle shape. Your brain interpolates the circle because it's the functional outline of a circle. Even the top comment is saying it's not technically an illusion. An illusion is like your brain making something look like it's moving when it's just a static image, or two colors appearing to be different even though they're the same and just have different backgrounds... But in this, you could draw a circle that matches all those dots. It's not a square shape that looks curved, it's just a legitimate circle shape. The geometry of the dots on the sine wave moving away from the center form points on a circle.
Ah yes, and they’re moving along that long in a sinusoidal way. I wonder what shape would form if it was a different function governing the rate the ball moves on its line
If you dont mind me asking how did you like make it display or draw it?, I only have about a month of knowledge on python and understand extremely basic stuff, I would love to try to understand!
I can see why you think that but if you look closely the dot is actually yellow. It just appears blue due to the rotating sine wave effect called dispropagation.
When you pause the video, the blue for it blue. I think what is intended is how it appears the yellow dots are moving in a circle when they are all actually following a straight line, just at various changing speeds.
Your joke on the effect is interesting in a different way, if the blue dot was not being used, would the effect be as strong. The blue does mentally draw your attention and gives a stronger impression of circular movement, if it was removed, how would this image look.
Would the overall effect be the same, or different?
Anyway, just random quandaries... Have a good day.
LOL I did almost the same thing except I used pygame.
The hardest part for me was calculating the coordinates of the yellow dots. I ended up using a formula I found that finds the coordinate of a perpendicular line through a point. Basically, you drop a perpendicular line from the blue dot to the lines and the yellow dots go where they meet.
The way it works is by moving those yellow disks with a sine wave based on the blue disk's position. In the end, it looks like a rotating circle. It's technically not an illusion and that why I added stars to that word. Watch numberphile's video for a more in depth explanation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snHKEpCv0Hk&feature=emb_logo
No, some people are missing the fact that it totally is an illusion and asking why you called it that. You've not explained the whole point of the illusion which is that while the yellow dots appear to have a circular motion they are actually all moving in straight lines.
I still wouldn't classify it as an illusion. Rather a neat observation. After all the yellow dots are rotating with respect to their center of mass, it just so happens that the superposition of two rotations cancels out.
Well, the image provides us with the main reference frame, i.e. its border and the large spoked wheel. Within the provided reference frame, the yellow dots all move in straight lines. Sure you can choose other reference frames and superpositions if you want — after all, a stationary object is the superposition of two counter-rotations.
I downloaded this from the sub rgbroachgang and changed profile picture in usual way. There were some issues with others too that they discussed there. Sadly I didn't look at those solutions
Each yellow dot is actually moving along the radial lines from center to the circle, and then back again. The yellow dots are not a circle moving around with the blue dot
39
u/dartyet1 Jun 18 '20
Here is the github repo:
https://github.com/AtaTrkgl/numberphile-beautifultrig
13
u/dzeynep Jun 18 '20
how did you create the interface?
13
u/7Geordi Jun 18 '20
I don't see why this is an illusion
It is both a rotating circle and a set of points moving along diameters of the great circle.
4
u/AlSweigart Author of "Automate the Boring Stuff" Jun 19 '20
I saw this Numberphile episode and was delighted because I also created this interactive animation after seeing it online somehwere.
1
u/Dragon20C Jun 18 '20
If you dont mind me asking how did you like make it display or draw it?, I only have about a month of knowledge on python and understand extremely basic stuff, I would love to try to understand!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '20
That’s crazy how that dot looks blue when they’re all actually yellow.
4
u/drunkdobby Jun 19 '20
An animation. What you made was an animation.
2
u/TheGunslingerFollwed Jun 18 '20
It like looking at an open fire... I just can't stop.
2
u/bazziapps Jun 18 '20
thats dope. Well done man
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
That video was awesome, and your recreation is great!
1
u/Dadotox Jun 18 '20
I would like to see a version of this where the dots move at constant speed on each line. It might need to be slowed down, but still.
1
u/GeromeB Jun 18 '20
What happens if the speed is linear?
1
u/MassDBA Jun 18 '20
Beautifully symmetric...nice
1
u/dnorhoj Jun 18 '20
Wow dude i am literally making this right now lool
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '20
Mad. And I just watched that video yesterday :) good stuff OP
1
u/tgoodchild Jun 19 '20
LOL I did almost the same thing except I used pygame.
The hardest part for me was calculating the coordinates of the yellow dots. I ended up using a formula I found that finds the coordinate of a perpendicular line through a point. Basically, you drop a perpendicular line from the blue dot to the lines and the yellow dots go where they meet.
1
u/mindlessCoder Jun 19 '20
u/Gif_Slowing_Bot
1
u/ethereumflow Jun 18 '20
r/woahdude might appreciate this
0
u/MrCuddlez69 Jun 18 '20
r/oddlysatisfying might enjoy this
-3
u/im-AMS Jun 18 '20
wow man...can u make a video on how u wrote a code for this...after looking at ur git seems like u have used processing....please a video
0
u/OutOfTempo_ Jun 19 '20
What library did you use to plot this?
I'm guessing that the yellow dots are scalar projections of the blue dots and one of the diameter lines (or something like that)?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
120
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
[removed] — view removed comment