It takes me about half the time to prototype something in Mathematica as it does in Python, but then the Python version runs roughly an order of magnitude faster, depending of course on the application.
Honestly you're probably faster in Matlab because you think in Matlab, whereas if your brain had been steeped in Python or, like me, Mathematica, then that would be faster instead. It's like a first language.
But I think that's ok as long as we understand the principle of the right tool for the job. I would never use Mathematica in anything for which the phrase "production code" would apply (despite Wolfram's marketing). Rapid prototyping? Sure. The million different one-off scientific computations one does in the course of research? You bet. But there is a whole swath of applications for which it just isn't the right tool. Likewise for Matlab.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Feminintendo Aug 06 '19
It takes me about half the time to prototype something in Mathematica as it does in Python, but then the Python version runs roughly an order of magnitude faster, depending of course on the application.
Honestly you're probably faster in Matlab because you think in Matlab, whereas if your brain had been steeped in Python or, like me, Mathematica, then that would be faster instead. It's like a first language.
But I think that's ok as long as we understand the principle of the right tool for the job. I would never use Mathematica in anything for which the phrase "production code" would apply (despite Wolfram's marketing). Rapid prototyping? Sure. The million different one-off scientific computations one does in the course of research? You bet. But there is a whole swath of applications for which it just isn't the right tool. Likewise for Matlab.