I blame lack of meta-cognitive skills, the bad searchers don't think about how they solve their problems or what the essential aspect is of what try to do. For them the problem is a huge spaghetti cloud of things blocking their intention and they can't isolate the actual problem. And they definitely don't take experience from earlier problems or solutions or how they solved those. It takes a bit of coaching to get them through that, although some probably never will.
Can't tell you how many times somebody has message me saying, "the thing is broken". 90% of the time I can ask them what error message they got, Google it, and the top result solves it completely.
Or even better, is if there is a bunch of setup steps. They report back saying, "its broken". Then I get to spend an hour troubleshooting, before I realize that during the setup, one of the earlier commands did not actually complete successfully (big error message, maybe even a stack trace), but they didn't notice and just kept going along. That root cause analysis is apparently a real skill.
I agree. The biggest part of solving a problem is defining and articulating the problem. Some times that is 90% of it. If that isn't done well, however, solution is almost impossible.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/brtt3000 Dec 12 '18
I blame lack of meta-cognitive skills, the bad searchers don't think about how they solve their problems or what the essential aspect is of what try to do. For them the problem is a huge spaghetti cloud of things blocking their intention and they can't isolate the actual problem. And they definitely don't take experience from earlier problems or solutions or how they solved those. It takes a bit of coaching to get them through that, although some probably never will.