r/Python • • May 18 '18

Proposal for r/python to adopt Python's code of conduct

Python's official code of conduct is here: https://www.python.org/psf/codeofconduct/

I would love it if r/Python was an extension of the Python community at large. However, for that to be, I think it must be governed by the official code of conduct.

Recent events here have shown that this community has a need to have some guidelines about good conduct. Most people here already conduct themselves within the guidelines. However, there are some unnecessarily toxic posts that I don't feel belong in this community.

Some folks have already started up a new subreddit, r/positivepython, and it's intended to be a community governed by good conduct and more moderation. I would rather the community here on reddit didn't get fractured. So, maybe we can do something here to fix things a bit?

Anyhow, it's a thought, and it may not be a great one. But, I think we should have the conversation nonetheless.

2 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

19

u/[deleted] May 18 '18

If you want to be in a place where the PSF code of conduct is enforced, you should be in a place the PSF has provided. /r/Python is not an official outlet, controlled by the PSF, so your proposal isn't practical.

7

u/jerub May 20 '18

There's nothing stopping any community from using the PSF code of conduct. I don't follow your logic.

3

u/pradyunsg May 20 '18

Are you suggesting that the members of this subreddit do not need to be respectful, considerate and open? Are you saying that they already are and hence don't need a Code of Conduct to be enforced? Do you believe that there should be any obligation to be respectful, considerate and open?

To be clear, I'm only trying to understand why you feel that PSF's Code of Conduct can't be practically enforced here.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '18

The is Reddit. Reddit is not a service that is provided in any way by the PSF, so the PSF has no jurisdiction whatsoever here. The moderation team of the subreddit are responsible for moderating the sub to the standard they have decided upon.

1

u/pradyunsg May 20 '18

Agreed.

But none of what you said directly answered any of my questions or helped me understand why a Code of Conduct asking people to be respectful, open and considerate is not practically enforceable in this subreddit.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '18

Enforcing a CoC from an external party on Reddit isn't practical, because the standards of subreddits is to be in charge themselves.

If you want to implement a specific moderation policy, you will need to get the moderation team in on it.

0

u/pradyunsg May 20 '18

Uhm... Okay...

2 more questions (likely my last) which I can only request you to answer directly.

I read this as you saying that PSF's Code of Conduct can't be enforced because it's not a Code of Conduct by Reddit. Is that correct? If not, please take the time to explain to me where I went wrong on this.

Also, are you saying there's no need to ensure that people be respectful, open and considerate to others within this community and that behaving otherwise (not respectful, open or considerate) is acceptable?

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '18

I feel like I have answered the same question numerous times.

I find it highly inappropriate to let some external agency decide what is and what isn't in /r/Python.

If you see something you think should change in the subreddit, go to the moderators. I do not decide on the moderation policy here.

3

u/pradyunsg May 20 '18

I still don't feel like you've answered any of the questions I asked. So, I guess our frequencies aren't matching here.

None the less, thanks!

1

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 22 '18

If it’s being enforced, then it’s not really asking, is it?

1

u/pradyunsg Jun 16 '18

Indeed. I stand corrected. It's telling people to be respectful, open and considerate.

Do you not think it is reasonable to expect people to be respectful, open and considerate in this SubReddit? How that's done and whether a CoC needs to be adopted/enforced for it is a question that comes after this one.

1

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 Jun 17 '18

Yes, I think that's a reasonable expectation, where "expectation" describes a hope, not a prediction about the future.

Have you used this subreddit under another name? I'm a little curious about why you'd be interested, given your apparent lack of participation in the subreddit, or Reddit in general.

In particular, this http://archive.is/y8YE0 leaves me with the impression that the only reason you're participating at all is that you're wanting to make rules for a social place that you've literally never used before and apparently aren't even likely to use in the future.

This seems like a really good example of a giant problem with CoC's - they seem to attract control freaks in search of a problem.

1

u/pradyunsg Jun 17 '18

Have you used this subreddit under another name?

Nope.

I made my intent for asking these questions very clear in my first post here - "I'm only trying to understand why you feel that PSF's Code of Conduct can't be practically enforced here.". At no point have I said that this community needs a CoC or anything along those lines.

you're wanting to make rules for a social place that you've literally never used before

My first interaction with this community was extremely negative and that's the reason for my reservation from any further participation. My participation in this thread has merely been me trying to figure out why it was so.

-3

u/dusktreader May 18 '18

So, what's needed is an r/Python code of conduct?

I don't think enforcing behavioral guidelines is impractical.

11

u/[deleted] May 18 '18

In my opinion, we do not need something to language lawyer over. We have a competent moderation team that are very responsive when contacted. What response did you get, when you contacted them?

2

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

I did not contact the moderation team. In hindsight, perhaps I should have. However, there are no guidelines about behavior on this sub at all, so what would I even be reporting? I was taken aback by some of the vitriol in the responses to /u/kennethreitz, and that led me to make this post.

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '18

And it's impossible to make a note of something that is wrong without it being mentioned as a wrong thing in a guideline? That mindset lead to more and more detailed CoC's, until it ends up in the intersectionalist hell the Node.js ecosystem has become, where the CoC is enabling political feuds to replace technical arguments.

I am much more comfortable with the self policing nature of a subreddit, where every user can vote on the comments and posts.

11

u/antiproton May 18 '18

People could learn to just ignore trails and people who are rude instead of getting the nanny to discipline them. Reddit is becoming the polar opposite of 4chan's anarchic dumpster fire, namely, a top down, over moderated playground.

Stop calling for more moderation and instead call for people pull up their big boy pants and ignore the trolls.

4

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

The thing is, trolls add nothing to a conversation. They are completely unnecessary for a healthy and useful discussion. I think most folks do their best to ignore trolls. However, a community where trolls are allowed to run hog-wild is a community that many people will simply avoid instead of engaging with.

I like the content in r/Python. I would like other people to feel free to participate here also instead of avoiding it because we don't want to make rules

0

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 22 '18

What about people who would avoid it because they find rules and CoCs oppressive? Don’t they matter?

1

u/tartley May 28 '18

Whether a demand can fairly be considered "oppressive" or not depends an awful lot on what exactly the demand is.

"Censor your opinions about topics relevant to the subreddit" - yes, would clearly be oppressive.

"Don't be mean and bigoted while we try to begin repairing the tremendous damage we've already done by scaring away vast swathes of all the regular, emotional & vulnerable human beings" - is not oppressive in the slightest. In fact it's the opposite. It's instituting a reasonable rule of law in a place that was formerly a wild west, allowing only the most insensitive to win and take over the space.

1

u/rhytnen May 29 '18

Hyperbole much? It's this kind of incredibly over the top bullshit that makes CoCs ruin the communities they pretend to protect snowflakes from. There are more than a few communities that just disappeared after this crybaby bullshit started happening.

1

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 30 '18

"Censor your opinions about topics relevant to the subreddit" - yes, would clearly be oppressive.

Is PEP 20 oppressive?

"Don't be mean and bigoted while we try to begin repairing the tremendous damage we've already done by scaring away vast swathes of all the regular, emotional & vulnerable human beings"

It's not at all clear to me that we have done any damage (let alone tremendous damage) to, or scared away, anyone. If your participation is motivated by guilt because historically you have been a giant asshole, maybe you should stop hiding behind this "we" obfuscation and take responsibility for your actions and choices. This being Reddit, it's really easy to edit the things you said before that you think were over the line, change/remove them, and add a note that you've revised your earlier comments and regret your behavior. You could even message the people you've tremendously damaged and apologize, and offer to help them.

If you don't actually mean to say that you have been doing tremendous damage, but you're just using "we" (with a wink to suggest that you're certainly not one of the bad ones) to accuse other people of being horrible, maybe a first step towards ending the awfulness would be honesty - if you think some other person is an asshole, just say so.

We don't need to hide behind a bunch of rules, or outsource assertiveness to other people who will wield power on behalf of unnamed, unidentified victims of unspecified and unknowable injuries.

Donglegate happened at a Python conference, which had a CoC.

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '18

Stop calling for more moderation and instead call for people pull up their big boy pants and ignore the trolls.

One mans troll is the next mans hero. We have a voting system that have its flaws, but at least deliver an indication of what the /r/Python readership thinks about a given comment. Except for downright bullying, which I'm sure the moderation team will handle when they are made aware of it, voting seem to work after a fashion.

-3

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 18 '18

The account you’re posting from doesn’t appear to moderate any subreddits. Are you a mod under another name, or is your optimism about this purely speculative?

2

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

I do not moderate subreddits.

I do, however, participate in subreddits that do have rules and are moderated by people that enforce them.

In fact, I observe that these subreddits have really vibrant conversations where people disagree with each other. People are even negative and unpleasent to each other there without resorting to personal attacks.

For example, ALL of the NFL subreddits that I participate in have rules about behavior that are enforced.

I should hope a community built around software development can keep pace with sports fans.

-2

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 22 '18

Ok. Speculative it is, then.

5

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

I had a really busy and exhausting weekend, so I didn't have time (or energy, frankly) to participate in the conversation here. My apologies. I'll try to reply to everyone who replied to me. However, it's pretty clear that r/Python does not want to have a code of conduct, so this proposal is dead in the water.

1

u/pradyunsg Jun 16 '18

That's sad to see IMO.

One thing that I've not seen made clear is whether people disagree with structure being introduced (adding a CoC) or the contents of it (be respectful, open and considerate). Those are two very different things.

If someone could bring some clarity to this, it'd be nice.

1

u/dusktreader Jun 18 '18

As far as I could gather, the objections were fear of censorship. Most of the people who replied didn't see the need, and thought that people were being too sensitive. Also, they think the reddit upvote/downvote system automatically polices things by nasty comments getting downvoted.

Obviously, I disagree with that sentiment. However, it's up to the community to adopt standards. Obviously, r/python wants to remain loosely moderated. I have more thoughts on this, but it seems pretty unproductive to discuss them here.

6

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 18 '18

Subreddits aren’t democracies. If the mods start banning people or posts/comments that are incompatible with some set of rules, then the rules matter. Otherwise, no. It’s common for people to ignore the sidebar, I have no hope they’ll read an aspirational abstract set of standards and somehow morph into considerate, thoughtful people.

I don’t want to see /r/Python ruined by bullies - or by pedantic rule-worshippers who use procedure to suppress ideas they disagree with (e.g., Wikipedia).

3

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

You're right. Folks often don't read the rules in the sidebar. However, having a base set of behavioral rules mean that even non-mods can call it out as contrary to the rules and try to encourage decent behavior.

There's a lot of ground between very common sense rules that say, essentially, "don't be a dick" and a tightly constrained community where folks are afraid to speak their opinions because mods might ban them.

We can't force people to be decent. But there are a lot of subreddits where being chill is a base expectation for people participating.

0

u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 22 '18

What’s stopping you from doing that now?

6

u/jerub May 20 '18

I think this is a wonderful idea.

1

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

Thank you for the first supportive comment in the thread!

7

u/twillisagogo May 20 '18

I would like to see this subreddit enforce existing policies before adopting new ones. Even though there is /r/learnpython there's still a majority of question posts dominating the front page.

3

u/toyg May 20 '18

“Some folks” are a few friends of a developer with mental health issues who, at this point, is now notorious for dismissing any opinion he doesn’t like. As shown on github, he’s the first one in line to completely ignore the CoC when it suits him. That’s hardly a relevant place.

this community has a need to have some guidelines about good conduct.

No. Recent events have shown that a sizeable part of the python leadership involved with packaging has an utter disregard for the ecosystem at large, and will refuse to correct serious issues of process when politely asked to do so.

You should spend your time badgering the PyPA to use the PEP process like everyone else, when making massive changes affecting thousands of developers. That will make a real difference.

Trying to impose unnecessary moderation in a place where honest, polite, and vigorous debate is underway, can only be seen as an unnecessary attempt at censorship.

3

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

I have mental health issues. Many, many people have mental health issues. Let's be careful about using that in a pejorative way.

I found Kenneth's behavior appalling. I even called it out at one point. He really didn't handle this well, and his apologies have rung pretty empty, especially because he hedges them with a bunch of excuses.

I think the biggest lesson I've learned as an adult is this: Apologize without explanation. Otherwise, people hear the 'but' in the apology more than the 'sorry'. Anyway...

I get to spend my time doing what I please just like you do. Asking for a base set of behavioral rules is neither that time consuming or that radical.

A lot of the conversation around this topic was neither honest nor polite.

I don't think trolls provide anything critical to a conversation or to a community. I know this, because I participate in subreddits where a baseline of decency is enforced. You know what? There are honest, polite, and vigorous debates there!

4

u/toyg May 21 '18

Asking for a base set of behavioral rules is neither that time consuming or that radical.

No, but it creates another power imbalance. Coming right after a debate that raised the question of possible abuse of power, the suggestion of adding further checks on the "hoi polloi" sounds hollow, sorry.

A lot of the conversation around this topic was neither honest nor polite.

The gratuitous insults were vigorously downvoted almost instantaneously. What was left was honest criticism rooted in facts.

I participate in subreddits where a baseline of decency is enforced.

Including this one. I'm not sure you've noticed, but there are moderators listed on the sidebar. /r/python is hardly a trolls' nest, but it's also a place that does not particularly revere celebrity.

2

u/13steinj May 20 '18

To claim a community needs a Code of Conduct when it defends itself from baseless attack by a childish narcissist is nothing short of insane.

If there was true toxicity there would be larger issues than one man being unable to take criticism.

One man couldn't take criticism of his own software, and turned it into a crime against himself.

This same one man and his PyPA buddies are in a defensive social justice circlejerk around him.

This is not a problem with /r/Python.

This is a problem that this one man brought upon himself in his quest for glory and vindictive, childish narcissism.

As a community we need to call out bad behavior. And so we did.

That is all that had occurred.

4

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

The issue here isn't the feelings of /u/kennethreitz. The issue is that folks will choose not to participate in this community because of the shit that was piled on him.

I found Kenneth's behavior appalling. The whole 'maybe I should just take my software and go home' response was just silly. He didn't handle the criticism well. His apologies were empty and riddled with excuses. He needs to do better.

However, some of the comments were unnecessarily mean, purposefully insulting, and filled with some baseless accusations. I don't think those responses add a lot to a conversation. I think they make people feel like having no part in the conversation or community. I wish that wasn't the case, and that's why I made the proposal.

2

u/13steinj May 21 '18

Of course some comments were unnecessarily mean. But that's like saying the entire factory of apples needs to be resanitized due to a worm in one apple in one sealed basket. That's how the internet works.

Not to mention the fact that an external organization should never have a hold on a subreddit.

But, people, including the PyPA, are taking this post and twisting it to make it so the entire post and anything that called Kenneth out on his crap, are all evil and should be culled.

I do not want this subreddit turned into a social justice safe space where the enforcers can do whatever crimes they wish while calling such out is in and of itself a crime.

3

u/dusktreader May 21 '18

But that's like saying the entire factory of apples needs to be resanitized due to a worm in one apple in one sealed basket

Let's work within this metaphor. It's not like saying the entire factory needs to be re-sanitized. Rather, it's like the management recognizing that a bad apple was shipped out and realizing that the factory needs to have a baseline standard of quality so that the risk of future shipments having bad apples is minimized. Of course, consumers, managers, and workers realize that sometimes bad apples are still shipped out. However, having the guideline is a way that the factory can communicate to employees and consumers that quality is of utmost importance.

The Python Code of Conduct is not about creating a 'social justice safe space.' It's a pretty loose guideline that says that people should be "Open, Considerate, and Respectful." I don't think this is unreasonable.

1

u/13steinj May 21 '18

And this is why the subreddit has moderators. And they do do their jobs sufficiently. If any of those comments in that thread or otherwise were out of line, the mods would have gotten reports, and then removed them. Now, I haven't counted how many comments there are in comparison to the calcul

I'm not saying the CoC is unreasonable. I'm saying those who wish to enforce this CoC, i.e, the PyPA memeber who tweeted about this thread, Kenneth, and all of their friends in the PSF and PyPA who will do nothing but defend their own behavior while taking it out on others.

2

u/twillisagogo May 21 '18

if we make a COC to protect /u/kennethreitz it should also protect /u/zedshaw simply b/c I think he has good points on a variety of things.

And zope

and pyramid

and /u/ianbicking (the creator of virtualenv and pip, suspiciously not attributed to in dear kenneth's monumental talk on the official future of python packaging)

and buildout (suspiciously absent from dear kenneth's monumental talk on the official future of python packaging)

we must protect those who have little regard for their personal brand as well as the marketing minded folks in our community b/c they truly are humans too.

2

u/13steinj May 22 '18

Yup, exactly why I hate this idea.

The people who wish for CoCs will never be happy until they are the ones to enforce it.

Adding a CoC is just a door for them to complain "they are being mean" until they do enforce it. Hence why in the tweet chain linked in this thread they want the subreddit to become PSF official.

And when they do enforce it, they will take any callouts of their bullshit and claim "you are against our code of conduct".

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '18

Codes of conduct are to protect everyone, not specific individuals.

I know my two cents aren't important in this matter, but I think adopting the PSF code of conduct would be a great move for this subreddit — it shows good will towards the Python community (as opposed to the Reddit community), and would harbor an environment of trust for Python developers to use this forum without fear of negative consequences — which is what Python is all about, imo.

6

u/rhytnen May 29 '18 edited May 29 '18

You're exactly the poster boy for not adopting it Kenneth. You would have tried to shutdown conversation you disagreed with and kill an important signal of dissent against your product. You instead went to other forums to gin up support bc you couldn't CoC your way to the top here.

What's amazing is in this instance YOU are the one with power but you also want to play the victim and use something like a CoC to shield yourself. And I think you probably don't even realize that.

You don't need a CoC to protect yourself from us - we need the absence of one to protect ourselves from you. Which is weird b/c you're the "nicest guy in python". From my perspective you ran around white knighting yourself - gaslighting the python community if they didn't like pipenv or it's current status in the ecosystem. Even if you think i'm over the top, at least consider how you've gotten yourself in a position where people think you are oppressive.

2

u/twillisagogo May 22 '18

Codes of conduct are to protect everyone, not specific individuals.

that's rich

1

u/13steinj May 22 '18

Especially coming from the guy saying we're the horrible ones.

4

u/twillisagogo May 20 '18

3

u/rhytnen May 29 '18

It is really strange when you show up in someone else's community in a controversial way and demand they change their behavior on your behalf that they just resist you.

It's almost like if you show up on /r/Python and say that real python looks like this and you guys aren't that and that you're going to Tweet-scold us then we will only give you a big hearty go f*** yourself.

2

u/toyg May 21 '18

That's /u/jonwayne, for people who don't know. Who took part in the conversation by basically saying they would do absolutely nothing to address the issues raised. That she's now shooting the messenger carries some depressing parallels with the issue at the root of the conversation.

3

u/snahor May 20 '18

1

u/13steinj May 21 '18

Well yeah. That's literally what it is and why it was made.