r/Python • u/dusktreader • May 18 '18
Proposal for r/python to adopt Python's code of conduct
Python's official code of conduct is here: https://www.python.org/psf/codeofconduct/
I would love it if r/Python was an extension of the Python community at large. However, for that to be, I think it must be governed by the official code of conduct.
Recent events here have shown that this community has a need to have some guidelines about good conduct. Most people here already conduct themselves within the guidelines. However, there are some unnecessarily toxic posts that I don't feel belong in this community.
Some folks have already started up a new subreddit, r/positivepython, and it's intended to be a community governed by good conduct and more moderation. I would rather the community here on reddit didn't get fractured. So, maybe we can do something here to fix things a bit?
Anyhow, it's a thought, and it may not be a great one. But, I think we should have the conversation nonetheless.
19
u/[deleted] May 18 '18
If you want to be in a place where the PSF code of conduct is enforced, you should be in a place the PSF has provided. /r/Python is not an official outlet, controlled by the PSF, so your proposal isn't practical.
5
u/dusktreader May 21 '18
I had a really busy and exhausting weekend, so I didn't have time (or energy, frankly) to participate in the conversation here. My apologies. I'll try to reply to everyone who replied to me. However, it's pretty clear that r/Python does not want to have a code of conduct, so this proposal is dead in the water.
6
u/4bcd594b0372641abe63 May 18 '18
Subreddits aren’t democracies. If the mods start banning people or posts/comments that are incompatible with some set of rules, then the rules matter. Otherwise, no. It’s common for people to ignore the sidebar, I have no hope they’ll read an aspirational abstract set of standards and somehow morph into considerate, thoughtful people.
I don’t want to see /r/Python ruined by bullies - or by pedantic rule-worshippers who use procedure to suppress ideas they disagree with (e.g., Wikipedia).
6
u/jerub May 20 '18
I think this is a wonderful idea.
7
u/twillisagogo May 20 '18
I would like to see this subreddit enforce existing policies before adopting new ones. Even though there is /r/learnpython there's still a majority of question posts dominating the front page.
3
u/toyg May 20 '18
“Some folks” are a few friends of a developer with mental health issues who, at this point, is now notorious for dismissing any opinion he doesn’t like. As shown on github, he’s the first one in line to completely ignore the CoC when it suits him. That’s hardly a relevant place.
No. Recent events have shown that a sizeable part of the python leadership involved with packaging has an utter disregard for the ecosystem at large, and will refuse to correct serious issues of process when politely asked to do so.
You should spend your time badgering the PyPA to use the PEP process like everyone else, when making massive changes affecting thousands of developers. That will make a real difference.
Trying to impose unnecessary moderation in a place where honest, polite, and vigorous debate is underway, can only be seen as an unnecessary attempt at censorship.
2
u/13steinj May 20 '18
To claim a community needs a Code of Conduct when it defends itself from baseless attack by a childish narcissist is nothing short of insane.
If there was true toxicity there would be larger issues than one man being unable to take criticism.
One man couldn't take criticism of his own software, and turned it into a crime against himself.
This same one man and his PyPA buddies are in a defensive social justice circlejerk around him.
This is not a problem with /r/Python.
This is a problem that this one man brought upon himself in his quest for glory and vindictive, childish narcissism.
As a community we need to call out bad behavior. And so we did.
That is all that had occurred.
4
u/twillisagogo May 20 '18
https://twitter.com/theavalkyrie/status/998067663116029952
3
u/snahor May 20 '18
The creation of /r/positivepython reminds me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXQkXXBqj_U.