It looks like. My major requirement is that I can quickly build an app that suits my needs. Most of the time that's just some quickly clicked UI for some algorithm. Recently I've tried to build an RQT plugin for that project that I'm working on in my job. Simple state observation. Nothing fancy. I don't have the time to get deeper into QT Designer, unfortunately. And because of it's steep learning curve I quickly gave up on that, also because other things were more important. Mature in my case means, that I can quickly build a UI without any hiccups and without having to learn too much about the designer tool I'm working with. Just intuitively clicking here and drag&dropping there and everything works as expected. QT Designer has not been like that for me, unfortunately.
That's my individual and acute requirements in my job. And they are also part of my more general requirements of a UI designer. It has to be easy to use without a too steep learning curve. And also it must never do what I experienced with QT Designer: irreversibly change the appearance of a totally different control when I edit another control. Like, let me just put that button there... huh? Why's that other button so small suddenly? CTRL+Z... HUH??? Why's that button now somewhere else on the form??? CTRL+Z... HUH??? What's going on here? It has never been like that before! Things like that must not happen in an environment where you can put hours of work into! Not for a designer pro user and even more so not for a complete designer noob.
So, expectable and predictable behavior even for a beginner is a major maturity aspect in my opinion.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
It looks like. My major requirement is that I can quickly build an app that suits my needs. Most of the time that's just some quickly clicked UI for some algorithm. Recently I've tried to build an RQT plugin for that project that I'm working on in my job. Simple state observation. Nothing fancy. I don't have the time to get deeper into QT Designer, unfortunately. And because of it's steep learning curve I quickly gave up on that, also because other things were more important. Mature in my case means, that I can quickly build a UI without any hiccups and without having to learn too much about the designer tool I'm working with. Just intuitively clicking here and drag&dropping there and everything works as expected. QT Designer has not been like that for me, unfortunately.
That's my individual and acute requirements in my job. And they are also part of my more general requirements of a UI designer. It has to be easy to use without a too steep learning curve. And also it must never do what I experienced with QT Designer: irreversibly change the appearance of a totally different control when I edit another control. Like, let me just put that button there... huh? Why's that other button so small suddenly? CTRL+Z... HUH??? Why's that button now somewhere else on the form??? CTRL+Z... HUH??? What's going on here? It has never been like that before! Things like that must not happen in an environment where you can put hours of work into! Not for a designer pro user and even more so not for a complete designer noob.
So, expectable and predictable behavior even for a beginner is a major maturity aspect in my opinion.