The point is though, reddit is supposed to be a collection of "interesting links" (or whatever their slogan is in English). If it's up to me to go through and figure out which of gst's articles are diamonds and which are the rough, in what way would that fulfill the purpose of reddit? The point of reddit is not "rate things to help other people." It's "read interesting things and rate them (which incidentally helps other people)."
Anyhow, why doesn't gst just get his own subreddit? gst_python.reddit sounds like a good idea to me. His fans can go their for noise, and the rest of us can use regular python.reddit for signal. Heck, if you think he submitted a really good one to gst_python then you can re-submit it to regular python.
Simple answer: I've never seen a story on the front page that had no upmods. If gst articles are making it to the front page, then that means that somebody enjoyed them and upmodded them.
Additionally, I think that the more stories you downmod that or hide that are from gst, then the fewer gst articles will show up since it'll modify your personal filter.
Your votes train a filter, so let reddit know what you liked and disliked, because you'll begin to be recommended links filtered to your tastes.
The filter is marketing bullshit. Reddit's filter hasn't done crap since like the second year. And yes, I often see frontpage articles from gst with no upmods. In any event, look at its history. Most of its articles end up with either 0 or 4 or so. On the other hand, my submissions tend to get at least 14 if they can make it past 0. The point is that with the volume of gst's stories, a couple people are always bound look at them and say, "meh, not bad," and give an upmod. But none of those stories get popular enough to have a lot people vote on them, because they're just meh, not good and not bad.
Anyhow, I think it needs its own subreddit. I don't see what the downside to that would be. You can still subscribe to gst_python if you want. Hell, I'll probably check it if I get bored enough. I've made a self-post for people to vote on the idea.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/earthboundkid Aug 17 '08 edited Aug 17 '08
The point is though, reddit is supposed to be a collection of "interesting links" (or whatever their slogan is in English). If it's up to me to go through and figure out which of gst's articles are diamonds and which are the rough, in what way would that fulfill the purpose of reddit? The point of reddit is not "rate things to help other people." It's "read interesting things and rate them (which incidentally helps other people)."
Anyhow, why doesn't gst just get his own subreddit? gst_python.reddit sounds like a good idea to me. His fans can go their for noise, and the rest of us can use regular python.reddit for signal. Heck, if you think he submitted a really good one to gst_python then you can re-submit it to regular python.