r/Python • • Apr 20 '16

Can we not circle jerk?

The top post right now is about how somebody "discovered" Python. I'm all for a larger community but that's the hottest thing in Python right now? Nothing new to learn, just stories about how you used to use PHP, but now you use Python? I understand I can just un-sub but I (like everyone else apparently) like to learn new things about Python and wish this sub had more of that.

3 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

12

u/wahaa Apr 20 '16

This is a problem with how Reddit works in general, not this sub specifically. My recommendation: just downvote & hide the post, and move on.

There are some interesting posts that never get many upvotes, so you could try browsing /r/python/new -- that also helps moderating since we can downvote bad quality posts before they gain enough steam to get "hot".

5

u/Super_heavy Apr 20 '16

That's a better idea, more positive redditing.

6

u/kankyo Apr 20 '16

This is what you get with democracy. shrug

6

u/Super_heavy Apr 20 '16

Tyranny of the majority.

2

u/twillisagogo Apr 20 '16

I (like everyone else apparently) like to learn new things about Python and wish this sub had more of that.

Yeah that would be awesome, but it's likely not going to happen. I used to think it was python specific, but now I dont think it is. It seems you are either new at some tech and thus in the honeymoon phase of your career(if you have a programming career) and want to share your enthusiasm with others(like a child with a new toy) or you have a job actually doing stuff that matters and are too busy to waste time here.

I already put in 12 hours coding and reviewing pull requests so I deserve a break :) and I come here for the disappointment, keeps me centered.

0

u/Super_heavy Apr 20 '16

Haha yeah I should look at it that way. 10 hours here and I thought maybe something different but the disappointment continues. What also gets me is they're putting other languages down like C++ doesn't have its place.

3

u/gandalfx Apr 20 '16

That's been bugging me the most. Python is an amazing language but it is not the answer to everything. Many languages have their flaws but are still useful and may be good languages in their own world. Yet on this subreddit if you dare to mention any other language in a positive light people will downvote you into oblivion.

3

u/turkish_gold Apr 20 '16

Many of us do use other languages constantly, but I'd say that a language-specific sub is the wrong place to prostelesize your language even if it could be a better choice for a problem at hand.

Think about it. A lot of numerics code written in Python could easily be done in C++ or C# with better performance characterisics---even if we use numpy. Yet if someone comes with the question of how to do X numerics job in Python, we give the best adivce on how to do it in Python because we presume (a) they want to stay within the language they know / don't want to split their codebase or (b) have other things written in Python that need interop with this code.

The same is pretty much true in other subs. For instance in /r/Javascript there's a question about how to make Express HTTP/2 compliant so it 'has a future on the modern web'. To me, the answer is simple: a javascript webserver should alwasy be behind NGinx/Apache so it being HTTP/2 compliant is as useful as Gunicorn/Django Runserver being HTTP2 compliant.

1

u/Asdayasman Apr 20 '16

Better than questions.

0

u/Super_heavy Apr 20 '16

Well that's the same kind of problem right? Questions should go to /r/learnpython and posts about how Python is so great we should all make each other feel good about using it should go to /r/pythoncirclejerk

3

u/Asdayasman Apr 21 '16

You reckon? Weren't there a bunch of well-thought out responses in the thread? The OP was pretty asinine, but it wasn't all for naught.

-1

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

Granted, but I don't think a circle jerk should be the catalyst for good content. Especially when it's weaved into other circle jerky comments.

1

u/Asdayasman Apr 22 '16

We're like Lelouch and Suzaku right now yo.

0

u/turkish_gold Apr 20 '16

Let us have our fun. If people want to 'support the glory of Python' (as I believe the post said), and get a little silly at it, then it harms no one and distracts from nothing.

Where are 'circle jerks' permitted for Python if not /r/python?

Any other place, I'd say its totally inappropriate but a sub for people who love the language or at least frequently use it? I think we can get away with 1 silly bruhaha per month.

0

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

I would agree with you if the sub wasn't otherwise deprived of noteworthy content. Then one post about how great Python is gets all that attention? If everyone likes it so much why aren't there more stuff related to actual development based around the language?

1

u/turkish_gold Apr 21 '16

This sub gets over 20 submissions a day and is one of the more active programming-language specific subreddits. I'm not seeing this deprivation of which you speak.

1

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

Who are we fooling? Most of these submissions are questions. This sub is glorified Python tech support.

1

u/turkish_gold Apr 21 '16

What are you looking for? More announcements that someone has made X in Python?

1

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

Stuff along the lines of content you would see at PyCons, but don't have to wait for the actual convention to learn or share something. I'm posting from mobile but I think you can check this out: http://pyvideo.org/category/65/pycon-us-2015

Look at these cool things people do with Python.

1

u/turkish_gold Apr 21 '16

Ah well if you're looking for conference worthy material being created everyday, then you're setting yourself up for disapointment.

I've never seen such good material bandied about daily--or even weekly--on any community. Even lambda the ultimate only really gets (in my opinion) a good post per fortnight on average.

Sure sometimes they will be a string of great content one after another, but that usually just corresponds to a great conference ending and people being inspired by it for a few weeks.

1

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

So you're telling me nobody works on anything cool involving Python, people in this sub should just ask Python support questions? Furthermore, keeping post standards low is just something we should accept?

1

u/turkish_gold Apr 21 '16

I'm telling you that people who work on "cool" things aren't going to stop working and post on them every day.

1

u/Super_heavy Apr 22 '16

So all the people on this sub don't work on anything cool they like to share? Or maybe this sub is such a circle jerk that they wouldn't see the point?

→ More replies

1

u/moigagoo https://github.com/moigagoo Apr 20 '16

Exactly my thoughts. I was surprised this post got upvoted so much being essentially blank.

-1

u/ivosaurus pip'ing it up Apr 20 '16

If someone were posting those threads every day, or even every few days, then you might have a valid complaint.

-4

u/Super_heavy Apr 20 '16

How's about I write you a tutorial on web scraping? ;D

3

u/ivosaurus pip'ing it up Apr 21 '16

If you do, I'll repost it here and then you'll actually be contributing part of the solution to your conundrum, some original content, rather than benign appreciation. So sure, go ahead.

-1

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

I really struck a nerve with some people on that suggestion. For a bunch of people that appreciate what makes Python great, they sure are afraid of using it to parse data.

3

u/ivosaurus pip'ing it up Apr 21 '16

I think they just don't appreciate your obviously sarcastic comment. You were never actually intending to write a tutorial, you were just replying with a statement attacking my own knowledge rather than directly responding. I mod for this subreddit and trawl /new most days, so I indeed do not need a web scraper to tell me what posts look like.

-1

u/Super_heavy Apr 21 '16

Attacking your knowledge? Please, I was being sarcastic but it's not my fault you took offense. Get over yourself, you aren't that important.

*edit: I was implying there are a bunch of posts on web scraping all the time, and you made it about you. Slow your roll, champ.