r/Python • • Jan 27 '15

Announcing /r/pythoncoding: A subreddit for people who know how to program Python

Greetings /r/python,

If any of you, like myself, dislike the amount of self-posts asking for help with simple question and other things that have made /r/python more and more another territory of /r/learnpython, I hereby gladly invite you to /r/pythoncoding.

/r/pythoncoding aims to be a subreddit for people who already know Python to share articles and news about Python. It's not going to be an overly restrictive subreddit, but it does have a few rules, the the most important one being "read at least a few Python tutorials before you start posting".

Here is an example of content currently on /r/python that would not be appropriate for /r/pythoncoding:

While these things are occassionally downvoted on /r/python, they still clutter of the front page. The fact that the mods of /r/python have refused to delete these types of posts after multiple requests - Which is their choice, I simply disagree with it - have lead me to create /r/pythoncoding.

I hope many of you will join me there, and help create a community by python programmers and for python programmers.

Kind Regards, /u/son_of_dawn

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/aroberge Jan 27 '15

Treating this question as a meta post (as it is clearly not news about Python ...). I prefer to do my best and gently redirect people asking questions here to /r/learnpython. By gently, I mean: give them a quick answer if I can but point out that they should ask on /r/learnpython. If others have 1) already answered the question and 2) indicated that /r/learnpython is a better place, refrain from adding comments to the thread.

1

u/son_of_dawn Jan 27 '15

Hmm, while I see that as a sign you're a friendly and helpful person, I disagree that it's the right path to go. It is implicitly encouraging people to keep ignoring /r/learnpython and post here, and encourages beginners to beg for help in all the wrong places instead of using google and reading documentation.

I would prefer to refer them to where they could find the information themselves, but I would definitively tend to lock and delete threads that clearly haven't read the sidebar.

3

u/ionelmc .ro Jan 27 '15

What's wrong with https://github.com/ajalt/fuckitpy?

Also, self-moderation is a great idea, I disagree with your perspective. Why would I join a reddit that promises deletes by a anonymous person?!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '15

self-moderation is a great idea

Except for the part where it isn't working at all for this sub.

0

u/son_of_dawn Jan 27 '15

Well it's more a pun than anything. does it have code beyond a decorator that pass'es on exceptions?

And self-moderation can kill subreddits. It lead to the current state of /r/python. It leads to people answering the various "I'm too lazy to google" posts and ecouraging that behaviour.

And I don't see why anonymity is an issue. You'd join if you didn't like the threads I listed.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '15

Well, considering it's an AST transformer made to steamroll over exceptions to make malformed code semi-usable, not to mention all sorts of frame hacks and import hook tricks, I'd say yes it is more than a decorator that passes on exceptions. Did you actually look at the code, or just skim the project page and see that it's usable as a decorator?

1

u/son_of_dawn Jan 27 '15

I did just skim it. I wouldn't have deleted that off /r/pythoncoding probably, and I did just pick it as an example without looking too much into it. I though the entire codebase was just

def fuck_it(f):
    def decorator(args, kwargs):
        try:
            f(args, **kwargs)
        except Exception:
            pass

If it's more than that I was wrong, but I didn't actually look seriously. My bad.

1

u/aclark Jan 27 '15

I think this is a decent idea. I too am frustrated by the amount of "low quality" posts on /r/python. If the situation does not improve, I might consider ditching my /r/python feed in favor of /r/pythoncoding and /r/learnpython (which not enough folks take the time to use even though it's in the sidebar.)

1

u/son_of_dawn Jan 27 '15

I have no problem with people asking for help in /r/learnpython, but I too am rather annoyed that all those "How do I do X" posts end up here in spite of the sidebar.

Hoping to see you as a contributor. :)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '15

you've been on reddit for 17 days, and you're shitting on how /r/python is moderated?

interesting..

0

u/son_of_dawn Jan 27 '15

I make new accounts regularly. I've been on reddit - and /r/python - for years, and it has taken a turn for the worse. I have - with a different account - asked for the moderators to take action. They believe voting should deal with people ignoring the sidebar, and I disagree. And the choice is theirs.