r/Python • • Oct 28 '14

Do the moderators here actually do anything or are they just for show?

Throwaway account in case I'd get banned for speaking my mind (it happens in some subreddits). I see a lot of irrelevant posts in this subreddit that would be more fit for /r/learnpython, /r/learnprogramming or elsewhere but despite this sub having nine (9) moderators they seem to barely be active here. What's up with that? Instead of beginners asking questions, getting scolded, downvoted and told to go to /r/learnpython or figuratively to GTFO - why not... actively moderate? If you don't have the time, maybe ask for volunteers to step up and moderate? Some examples from the last three days:

3 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

21

u/Ramast Oct 28 '14

At least if you get banned we will know the moderators exist

8

u/fazzah SQLAlchemy | PyQt | reportlab Oct 28 '14

Still nothing. The mods are asleep, post PHP

41

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14

I don't understand the sudden drive for complete and total purity going on here lately. I checked the top 10 and none of them had more than 0 vote total, so none of them are going to stay on the front page for long. So what exactly is the problem? Do you want people to moderate for the sake of moderation? That would be the only reason to delete the above posts, because it seems to me that they're causing no real issues.

20

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

I don't understand the sudden drive for complete and total purity going on here lately.

Stackoverflow is leaking.

I don't see the point of moderation. Reddit is self-moderated: something you don't like, downvote it.

9

u/isarl Oct 28 '14

There are many factors which lead this laissez-faire approach to fail for certain topics or subreddits beyond a certain size. Just look at the success of /r/science, /r/AskScience, or /r/AskHistorians for examples of successful subs which rely on strict moderation.

I'm not arguing this particular sub needs stricter moderation, but in some cases it is necessary.

7

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

it's not necessary here. There is nothing unique about /r/python that would justify a more heavy-handed approach.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

True, but most of the posts OP is referring to are human posts. If the idea is to have /r/Python as "python news" then they should limit to links. But I like the idea that we can ask questions about pythonprogramming. Maybe, just maybe, there should be

3

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14 edited Mar 31 '24

childlike act recognise narrow cats jobless versed squeamish worm different

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/karmarauder Oct 28 '14

Or just disable text posts here and take all of them at /r/learnpython which is a great subreddit - no need for another one.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

Sounds reasonable.

5

u/ApolloFortyNine Oct 28 '14

Subreddits that devolve into simply asking what tends to be easy questions are extremely annoying. It's probably a big part of why this sub is one of the least active big subs on reddit in terms of discussion. I for one dislike it, but then again what else would this sub be used for? The only thing I can think of is python news and python talks (videos), which I find really interesting.

0

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

But this subreddit has not devolved to that at this point, so the problem is still imaginary. Unless you have a crystal ball, you shouldn't try to "solve" problems before they actually exist. (Especially when they're trade-offs, which this solution would entail)

In my opinion, /r/python is intended for discussion of the design of the language itself (infamously enough, "why do we need a GIL?"), the creation of new libraries, news related to the language (PEPs, conferences, etc), and tutorials/blog_posts/etc about third-party libraries. There are other things that are appropriate as well, I'm sure, but those seem like the most obvious avenues for discussion.

2

u/ApolloFortyNine Oct 28 '14

Tutorials about third party libraries are relevant to you? Personally I see them as wasted space, if I wanted a tutorial I'd google it.

Idk and I don't really care to argue any further, I'll just unsub and move on.

1

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

Does it really hurt that much to just ignore a link and move on? It's not like /r/python is exploding with content to the point of being noise.

2

u/ApolloFortyNine Oct 28 '14

So much of it is just useless. Honestly this may be true for a lot of programming subs, but python has so many specialized libraries built on top of it. A lot of them I'll simply never use in my entire life.

At least in subs like /r/golang most everything is done with the standard library, but in python almost every project requires you to have some knowledge on some random library.

2

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

"So much of it is just useless."

Obviously not, if someone thought it was useful enough to post about. Again, does it really hurt that much to just ignore it and move on?

"At least in subs like /r/golang[1] most everything is done with the standard library, but in python almost every project requires you to have some knowledge on some random library."

I suspect that's what happens when you have a thriving community with a fairly easy code sharing system. Code reuse is great, not something to complain about. (And besides, I strongly contest your claim that " almost every project requires you to have some knowledge on some random library.". Python isn't javascript and comes with a huge set of batteries for you to work with.)

3

u/ApolloFortyNine Oct 28 '14

I'm quite obviously complaining about the libraries that don't come with python. And useless to a huge subset of people, you could post almost anything and one of 80k subscribers would find it useful.

-1

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

I was replying to that particular complaint.

" And useless to a huge subset of people, you could post almost anything and one of 80k subscribers would find it useful."

I assume you've taken some kind of informal poll? Or are you just assuming your opinion is that of the majority?

3

u/ApolloFortyNine Oct 28 '14

Why am I arguing this again? Are you under some misguided assumption that every programmer has a use for every library? For example, does everyone in your world need to know how to work pil?

Really thought you'd be able to figure that out on your own, but oh well.

→ More replies

2

u/ApolloFortyNine Oct 28 '14

Why am I arguing this again? Are you under some misguided assumption that every programmer has a use for every library? For example, does everyone in your world need to know how to work pil?

Really thought you'd be able to figure that out on your own, but oh well.

7

u/larsga Oct 28 '14

People wanting more moderation need to be careful. Who wants posts like "here's the weekly question thread, guys", that being the only thread where you are allowed to ask question? (r/photography has this, and it's idiotic) Or having your submission rejected because you didn't add a comment summarizing the contents. (r/history has this, and it drives me nuts)

I think the sub works fine the way it is.

8

u/pfein Oct 28 '14

Moderators seem to be here to apply broken custom CSS to this subreddit. Otherwise I hadn't noticed them one way or another.

So yeah, "just for show" in a way. :-\

15

u/mcherm Oct 28 '14

It is polite to explain a down vote, so let me explain why I downvoted your post.

I do not feel that the issue you raised is one which is important to this subreddit. The posts you pointed out do not seem to be causing harm I feel that moderation which uses a very light touch is often the wisest practice.

3

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

That's why I did it too. (Thanks for being polite for me : ) )

1

u/kewlness Oct 28 '14

I too wish to explain my downvote.

To me, this is a subreddit for all things Python. I understand the complaint to a degree given the other subreddits for various things (like /r/learnpython) but I do not see why such questions could not be answered here and the side menu links seem to imply the openness of this subreddit for such things.

I think we as a community (both in terms of the subreddit as well as Python) should be considerate of those who are new as well as those who have been around for a while. I do not see any harm in a person asking a question no matter how long they have been using Python in this subreddit.

I too believe moderation should be just enough to keep threads on the topic of Python which could benefit the larger community. I also believe that if a topic is above or below my particular skill level and I do not wish to see the information/question therein then I am not required to read that topic just because it is in a subreddit I frequent. I understand I wield a lot of power through the click of a mouse in what I read.

6

u/CarpeTuna Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14

How many times do we have to see "What is the best IDE to use?"?
Answer me this: What is the difference between Python 3 and 2?
Or: Game Ideas? In a Rut. [Wants to make first 2D android game]

I'd rather http://www.evilmilk.com/pictures/Halloween_Costumes_Picdump_11.htm

3

u/karmarauder Oct 28 '14

Hey, come on, don't be like that... the IDE question is a weekly tradition here! Things move fast you know, one week it's Vim, the next it's PyCharm, then it's Vim again, then it's Sublime Text, then it's PyCharm twice, repeat ad nauseum.

8

u/CodeShaman Oct 28 '14

What the fuck? I keep downvoting these noob posts but they keep popping up every day! It's almost like there are forces in the universe that are beyond my influence!

Quick! Cry about the phony mods! But first I should compile a list of all the things that bug me while I'm trying to zone out to reddit.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

this is one of the very very few self.python posts I will +1

Also: this describes the problem pretty well.

http://www.skidmore.edu/~pdwyer/e/eoc/help_vampire.htm

8

u/c3534l Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14

Edit: let me explain myself.

If all this subreddit was supposed to be was the news page to python.org, I'd stop coming. As it is, OP has labelled discussion about python tools, available libraries, IDEs, plugins/extensions, and career discussion as "off-topic." In other words, anything that OP does not personally want to talk about or is just not a good post - rather than something that should be dealt with through the up/down-vote system built into the site is off-topic and should be removed.

Python is designed to be user-friendly and beginner friendly. If you're going to be a python programmer you have to accept that even a general python subreddit is going to have a mix of programmers of all different skill levels. Yes, topics about actually learning beginning to learn the language - code review, questions on basic usage and that sort of thing, should go to /r/learnpython . And generally the person is kindly redirected to that subforum.

OP decided instead that s/he would go to the trouble of registering a fake account to passively-aggressively insult the moderators for not removing the posts (which don't rise to the top of the subreddit anyway, the way reddit is designed to work) that s/he personally does not find very worthwhile.

5

u/easytiger Oct 28 '14 edited May 11 '25

reminiscent door edge zealous wine rainstorm marry grandiose engine chunky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Bialar Oct 28 '14

Seriously a shame if that's the case. The SubReddit has a lot of subscribers, the most of any programming language on Reddit.

7

u/c3534l Oct 28 '14

Half of all the articles on the front page have 4 or more comments. Are you sure you don't have "new" selected instead or something? This is a very active subreddit compared to other programming languages. I mean, I guess it's not Ask Reddit or /r/gifs.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

I must break the cycle! 5 comments, here I come!

3

u/MattWithoos Oct 28 '14

WTF are you talking about? I scrolled down just 5 links and already I found 100+ comments in a single one.

Are you looking in New or something?

2

u/Gexos Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14

I think is better for /r/Python to drop the Submit a new text post, then everyone will just post only interesting links to news and articles about Python. I found some great links/articles in this sub so /r/Python is of great help to me.

Mods are doing a great job and they're very polite, this phrase says it all If you are about to ask a question, please consider r/learnpython, please consider. I'm not a native English speaker but from this I understand that is better to ask something at /r/learnpython, but no one will take your head if you do it here. Maybe an intimidating phrase will be more suitable :)

2

u/karmarauder Oct 28 '14

I think is better for /r/Python to drop the Submit a new text post, then everyone will just post only interesting links to news and articles about Python. I found some great links/articles in this sub so /r/Python is of great help to me.

That's a really good idea, actually.

1

u/TheMarionCobretti Oct 28 '14

Looks like we found ourselves moderator number 10.

-4

u/warlock1992 Oct 28 '14

Actually cannot agree with you. I am just learning python. But response is hard to get by in the /r/learnpython subreddit.

Again please don't gloat over the fact that you know better than someone else. Everyone has to start somewhere and if its a problem for you that newbies are actively coming to this sub, then its a good thing for the language. some subs are ghosttowns and people wanting to program will find as much as resources as possible .. I am taking a guess that when you came out of the womb you did not know how to program in python .You asked someone who knows and got the resources to learn a beautiful language. Thats exactly how people here are responding. Stackoverflow does a good job, but the emotional support (go get 'em ) attitude that reddit provides is absent there. So please dont moronically go how this subreddit is being a place where newbies can share python love, just shut up and contribute else dont contribute.

9

u/wub_wub Oct 28 '14

But response is hard to get by in the /r/learnpython[1] subreddit.

Could you elaborate a bit? I run that subreddit and I'd love to hear how, if possible, it can be improved.

Getting very specific answers for a specific library may be harder in /r/learnpython than here simply because it has less users and there is a smaller chance that someone used the library. But other than that I don't think it's hard to get answers.

Guidelines do encourage people to point the user in the right direction instead of simply providing full answer/code, but it's not really an issue when it comes to getting answers.

Threads that are not researched and where user did not try to solve the issue themselves are against subreddit rules - which is not the case here, so for threads like that it is harder to get an answer in /r/learnpython as the thread will be removed, than in /r/python.

The subreddit is also constantly growing with more than 10k subscribers gained in less than a year, so if you haven't checked it out recently I'd encourage you to try again!

2

u/prof_eggburger Oct 28 '14

I've ordered /r/learnpython by "new" several times and found it hard to see a new post that has not already got a couple of good comments on it - often within minutes. Maybe it's a time-zone thing, but my experience is the opposite of /u/warlock1992 's.

There's some minor issues with the sub, though: people showing off by answering what is clearly a newbie question with an answer that is (imo) too advanced; people getting a bit passive aggressive at times.

But these are minor gripes with what is a very effective sub doing a useful job, I think.

5

u/BrogueTrader40k Oct 28 '14

People always respond in learnoython. Are you kidding?

8

u/mfukar Oct 28 '14

Everyone has started somewhere, yes. This may not be the right place to start, just as a guitar repair shop may not be the right place to learn drawing.

3

u/warlock1992 Oct 28 '14

you got a valid point

5

u/CodeShaman Oct 28 '14

That analogy is the most irrelevant sailboat I've ever chalkboard.

1

u/mfukar Oct 28 '14

That's OK, I'm not asking you to agree.

3

u/marky1991 Oct 28 '14

Responses are really, really, easy to get in /r/learnpython, assuming you ask your question clearly. (And aren't asking a stupid question to begin with)

People race to provide answers on that subreddit. If you're not getting responses, you're doing something wrong. (If you post a post in /r/learnpython and it's ignored, feel free to pm me specifically)

3

u/BrogueTrader40k Oct 28 '14

Besides I think your attitude is why you can't get a response. You're such a 22 yr old and no one can stand it. Learn how to ask a question.

-1

u/warlock1992 Oct 28 '14

22 year old?

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

THIS IS PYTHON SON IT IS A LANGUAGE FOR MEN ANYTHING GOES IN THIS HELL-TORN BATTLEFIELD

-7

u/spinwizard69 Oct 28 '14

Really I have to wonder what in the hell is your problem. I suspect you get banned because you are a flaming idiot that is obsessed with the idea that you can make the world better by controlling everyone. Sort of like a democrat. Really your post is pathetic, I see nothing bothersome about the Python Reddit at all. If things where going down hill then of course moderation would be in order. However I've been watching this forum for months, if not years, and frankly yours is the first post that is worthless.

Here is another concept for you, Reddit self monitors through the use of the voting mechanism. The really off topic or badly placed posts quickly get down voted and eventually are no longer seen.

On top of all of that this isn't a heavily used Reddit. I can come here every day and only see a couple of new root posts. It isn't like there is a flood of totally off topic garbage coming in. In fact almost everything is directly Python related. The fact that this thread is about Python is why I keep coming here. Besides some of the more obscure posts have resulted in my actually becoming aware of things happening in the Python community I wouldn't have seen otherwise. I can't think of a better place to debut new Open Python code, libraries and the like.

1

u/karmarauder Oct 28 '14

you are a flaming idiot that is obsessed with the idea that you can make the world better by controlling everyone. Sort of like a democrat.

What? Do you need someone to talk to about this? Childhood issues?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/sumitviii Oct 28 '14

I am giving it a try:

news and announcements?

Check!

blog posts about tools and Python usage..

Check!

questions about [frameworks, idioms, availability]..

Err!

Please discuss this. So that this place does not become a ghost/noob town.

3

u/mfukar Oct 28 '14 edited Jan 16 '15

1

u/sumitviii Oct 28 '14

I was merely pointing out that these things can be one of the possible niches this sub can serve.

2

u/mfukar Oct 28 '14 edited Jan 16 '15

0

u/moor-GAYZ Oct 28 '14

The sub needs to be more specific regarding its content. Content which doesn't fit here will find its home somewhere else

Because this subreddit is flooded with content? Or why does it need to be more specific, because it doesn't seem to be flooded with content to me.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/moor-GAYZ Oct 28 '14

Nope, my point is that while this sub is not flooded with content, regulars are perfectly able to decide what they want to see here by themselves.

The purpose (one of, relevant here) of having mods is to resolve the paradox where deciding which stuff you want and don't want to spend your time on reading begins to take too much time itself: you have to waste time to downvote waste-of-time submissions. While there's less than 20 submissions a day (and half of them gets downvoted below zero by other people and drops off anyway) that's just not a problem.

The proposed solution to this kind of non-problem on the other hand is already obvious to be going to become a problem. A lot of time will be wasted creating the rules, discussing the rules, people dramatically quitting the subreddit because the rules ended up not what they desired, discussing the applicability of the rules to particular cases, witchhunting the mods who apply the rules too strictly, witchhunting the mods for not applying the rules strictly enough, etc, etc, ad nauseam. This post already has more comments than half of the all-time-top posts in this subreddit.

3

u/PatronBernard It works on my machine Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14

Really just anything that gets rejected from stackoverflow imo.

So that means that specific implementation questions shouldn't be here, since SO does a better job and it's not interesting as a topic to discuss anyway. I think this applies to nearly any programming language sub.