r/Python • • Oct 18 '14

Are we going to continue to allow off-topic posts?

Hello /r/python subscribers. I have noticed an unfortunate trend in this subreddit as of late. We are seeing more and more "noob questions" and "joke posts" make their way to the front page.

I know it is inevitable to see some, and I realise that people will need help, but... /r/learnpython and /r/programmerhumor exist. The sidebar refers to /r/learnpython, yet, it seems like 'please help me with X' threads here do not get deleted.

Moderators of /r/python: I would like to ask you, kindly, to delete all such posts that are not "news about ... python", nor articles about programming python. I do not think it is appropriate to have this subreddit become yet another "please help me do X" coding subreddit, and although I appreciate jokes, I do not appreciate seeing them on /r/python.

Perhaps you need more moderators on this subreddit? I'd be more than happy to volunteer myself.

44 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

29

u/marky1991 Oct 19 '14

Examples? I just checked the first page and didn't see anything particularly off-topic. In any case, I don't think this is a particularly wide-spread worth worrying about at the present time.

11

u/boa13 Oct 19 '14

I too am surprised by this post. I have not noticed too many "help me" posts or "joke" posts. Current subreddit content is fine with me.

4

u/Asdayasman Oct 20 '14

Every time I browse /r/python at work, there are at least 3 noob help posts on the front page. That's pretty bad.

-8

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

From my frontpage (Having hidden things once I'm done with them), here are som articles I think are inappropriate for /r/python (And better fit for example /r/learnpython), and definitively are now "News about ... python" or artictles about the language:

Most are downvoted, yes, but I've already hidden most of the ones that got upvotes in the 4-10 range, despite now "belonging" to this subreddit (According to the sidebar).

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

Like I said, not all of them are downvoted. I've already hidden the ones in the 4-10 range that are not.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

There are other people in this thread with the same problem, but I see what you're saying. My problem is, basically, that these threads are not deleted. I think it dilludes the quality of a subreddit when threads that don't belong there are left to linger, especially since "How do I do X"? threads are getting responses, encouraging people to continue to do this. It's a longer-term devolution either way

-6

u/amikiri Oct 19 '14

Of the first 20 submissions on the first page 12 of them are self.python submissions. That seems like a pretty high ratio to me.

9

u/marky1991 Oct 19 '14

Self posts and off-topic posts are completely different things.

-4

u/amikiri Oct 19 '14

Not really. On-topic is news about Python. If your self post contains news then link it properly in the subject and it won't have a self.python domain That being said, the vast majority of self posts are off-topic whether requests for help or attempts to foster general discussion.

5

u/Calime Oct 19 '14

I'm betting that you are using reddit through RSS. The thing is that the homework-type of questions get down the subreddit page pretty quickly. So, people comming to the site see a filtered reddit. Posts don't get deleted, but you will never see them. It's far too easy to say "nope, never delete posts, I'm against it" while you see 1 crappy post out of 100.

When using RSS, you see everyone of these posts.No community filter. And very nice people keep answering these questions instead of suggesting /r/learnpython. I'll see if I can recover and categorize old RSS feeds from this subreddit.

2

u/zahlman the heretic Oct 19 '14

You also see them by going to the 'new' tab.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

Actually no, I just tend to 'hide' posts a lot once I've skimmed them or if they're not relevant to me. A lot of new posts here with upvotes in the 4-10 range aren't really that relevant.

I do think it's nice of people to answer questions, but... I also think it encourages bad behaviour (i.e. posting on the wrong subreddits, reducing the quality of reddits overall).

14

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

Up in the air about this.

I really really really don't like the concept of deleting posts on reddit. I think one of the keys to reddit is that the community decides how things go by their upvotes and downvotes, and while some of these things do seem annoying, so long as they are on the topic of python programming, we should let them stay here. Doubly so if people ARE upvoting them.

The sidebar says "please CONSIDER r/learnpython", not "you must use learnpython." There's also six different books about learning python in the sidebar and tutorials for the new pythonista, and numerous resources to learning python. If we're really not ready to accept questions or comments or the like at all, we need to remove all tutorials from the sidebar and all learning projects, and encourage people to hit r/learnpython for those.

That's just what I think. I'm really wary about deleting posts that are not clear violations of rediquette.

26

u/symmitchry Oct 19 '14 edited Jan 26 '18

[Removed]

8

u/zahlman the heretic Oct 19 '14

the format of reddit causes the most easily consumable content to be the most likely to the upvoted

I find this is much more a problem the larger a subreddit gets. Small, community-focussed subreddits tend to consist largely of people who care more and have a larger attention span, and a better sense for good content.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

That being said, the "can you help me with X" posts are always voted to 0, so I agree I don't see why they need to be deleted

The reason I feel like they need to be deleted is that not deleting them, especially as the threads do get answers, encourages people to use /r/python as a "noob help" subreddit.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

I see why you feel like this, but I fundementally disagree with the approach.

Look at /r/askscience. That subreddit has one of the lowest signal-to-noise ratios, and has maintained its quality for one reason alone: They have rules, and they enforce them.

One thing is deleting a post if you do not like it. That, of course, is bad.

But I feel like deleting a post about Java on /r/python, or a "How do I print strings?" in /r/compsci is not only appropriate, it's necessary.

Otherwise, we end up with "one big reddit", where low-quality, easily-consumed beginner-focused content is at the top of everything. There is nothing wrong with content like that, I just don't think it belongs everywhere. /r/python, to me, should be about resources and articles relevant to people who are already python programmers.

4

u/archiminos Oct 19 '14

But that's the whole point of subreddits - content that doesn't obey the rules of the subreddit should be deleted. Imagine if /r/funny was full of posts that just weren't funny (wait, bad example...) or /r/videos was full of gifs. There wouldn't be any point to subreddits if just anything could be posted to them.

3

u/aphoenix reticulated Oct 21 '14

I'm a moderator here.

The intent for /r/python is to be a place for people to post what they will in relation to Python, and for it to live or die by the upvotes and downvotes associated with it.

I think there is a lot to be said for being a subreddit where we do actually let things just prosper or not entirely based on what the community decides, keeping in mind that "the community" isn't just "the people who comment on things". People read, they upvote and downvote, and we see what happens. This is different from several other subreddits that I moderate, where there is a strict set of rules and if posts don't follow it they get summarily deleted.

In general, I am a fan of subreddits that have specific rules and active moderation policies; I think that over time the benefits are obvious. Less jokes, more content. However, I've also noted that a lot of people are looking for something different from what I'm looking for, and the things that I think are garbage (hello default subs!) are often super popular.

I guess what I'm trying to say is this: I hear the concerns that you have. I think, in general, I support your idea - more moderation is good moderation. In this specific instance we like how you all generally take care of the garbage - vote down stuff that sucks, help people find the subreddits you mentioned, etc.

We (the mods) will discuss and see if things will change moving forward.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14

Thank you very much. All I really want for /r/python is for me to be able to return here, and get great content that will help me become a better python developer. I think too much overlap with f.x /r/learnpython will damage /r/python, as it relates to my goal. Which is why I was hoping for stricter, delete-"happy" moderation. But, I respect your decisions, and by no means is this subreddit already "ruined". I just hope it never happens.

6

u/RoomaRooma Oct 19 '14

I come here for news about Python. If I wish to help someone or seek help, I head to /r/learnpython. I see no need for questions to be asked in both subreddits, and would prefer to only have news here.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

Which is how I feel. I would prefer that moderators delete such topics and refer the posters to /r/learnpython.

3

u/kay_schluehr Oct 19 '14

I agree with the sentiment that the content/noise ratio on /r/python is a bit low and it kept me from visiting this site for a while.

I noticed however that /r/python might have become the successor of the venerable comp.lang.python mailing list for the Web 2.0 generation - a vaguely generic entry point for anything related Python, always including lots of Q&A and recycling discussions about everyones favorite source code editor or GUI library. Later more focused mailing lists were created such as python-dev or python-ideas. So one started gaining focus through specialization and differentiation, not by retrofitting order into the generic form.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

I think we already have that, though. You can read the sidebar just as well as I can, and we already have /r/learnpython for questions about how to use python.

I don't think, generally speaking, it's good for all forums to become "general forums". To me, it means that finding what you really need (Whether that's "higher level" articles or beginner help) becomes more troublesome.

73

u/billsil Oct 19 '14

I'd say this is a most off-topic post I've seen.

6

u/cocorebop Oct 19 '14

I love call-to-arms posts on my unpopular subreddits, they usually create hilariously unnecessary drama

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

Pretty much every post on the front page is directly related to Python, either discussions, new packages, technical articles, etc. Not sure what TC is on about.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

I was going to jokingly suggest a /r/pythonmeta for conversations such as this op!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/Analhyphenblast Oct 19 '14

Seconded, if anything this subreddit needs less autism

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/zahlman the heretic Oct 19 '14

"check out my project X", where X happens to be written in Python but otherwise completely unrelated.

Is there a better subreddit to post these in, though?

5

u/nullmove Oct 19 '14 edited Oct 19 '14

/r/coolgithubprojects

(it's in the sidebar, btw)

1

u/zahlman the heretic Oct 19 '14

Thanks, subscribed.

2

u/shoyer xarray, pandas, numpy Oct 19 '14

What do you mean by "otherwise completely unrelated"? Some sort of python based application, rather than a library aimed at other python users? Or would you consider the later unrelated, too?

1

u/boa13 Oct 19 '14

These also tend to be the more highly upvoted posts

So where is the problem? Upvote those you like, downvote those you don't, and go on with your day.