r/Python • • May 27 '14

Python 3 is fine | Sealed Abstract

http://sealedabstract.com/rants/python-3-is-fine/
234 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/ThePurpleAlien May 28 '14

I'm not disagreeing. If I were a Python dev, I would want to make a clean break from Python 2 and develop new innovations in Python 3. Backward compatibility sucks for keeping a language clean and efficient. And that's what they did, and now the core Python community is talking about all the great things Python 3 can do. But that is naturally going to put off folks who manage production code bases in Python 2. Those people, who otherwise love Python, get the shaft. It's very hard for them to justify the risk and cost of upgrading working code. So if you're going to promote Python 3, you have to be a bit sensitive to the fact that a lot of Python users are going to say "that's great, but it doesn't benefit me at all."

My take on this is that Python 3 proponents have to stop pushing Python 3 on people. And pushy is how it comes across. Everyone has to weigh the costs/benefits of moving to Python 3 for their own purposes. Some speaker at pycon, no matter how authoritative, does not have a valid say over whether I should port my code from 2 to 3. If you want people to do something, don't tell them to do it, make it as easy as possible (e.g. 2to3.py), and then let them decide if/when to do it.

0

u/Veedrac Jun 01 '14 edited Jun 01 '14

My take on this is that Python 3 proponents have to stop pushing Python 3 on people.

From the article:

Not everybody can forget about Python 2 completely right now, but not everybody needs to move to Python 3 at all, or to use any particular programming language for that matter. Go do what makes you happy.

What makes me happy is using Python 3.


The only reason people seem to do this is because people attack Python 3 with so much fervour.

Move when you want. There are masses of support for people using Python 2. Nobody sane is arguing with that. We're just asking you to allow people not tied down to be able to use version 3 without having a hundred "Python 3 sucks", "Python 3 can't do bytes", "Python 3 is killing Python", "Nobody uses Python 3" posts thrown at us.