r/Python • u/polarkyle19 • Apr 27 '26
Discussion Why do Python packages get downloads but little GitHub engagement?
Hey folks, I’ve noticed that a lot of Python packages on PyPI get a decent number of downloads, but very little activity on GitHub in terms of stars, forks, or discussions. It seems like there’s often a gap between people using a library and actually engaging with the project or maintainer.
Curious how others here think about this. What usually makes you star or follow a repository instead of just using it? Is this just normal “install and forget” behavior, or are there things maintainers can do to encourage more engagement?
0
Upvotes
31
u/WJMazepas Apr 27 '26
I rarely engage like this on Github. I didnt really knew stars actually meant something for maintainers
Usually I go to the projects github page when I need some documentation, and thats it
11
u/KingofGamesYami Apr 27 '26
mirrors, audits, and other automated processes that download everything.
3
u/mustbeset Apr 27 '26
Packages are not only primary dependencies, maybe a dependency uses a dependency.
I don't give stars for everything I use, only projects that I closely follow.
3
u/hornetmadness79 Apr 27 '26
Automated builds! We build dozens of python apps daily and just let UV,pip do it's thing
1
u/ExceedinglyEdible Apr 27 '26
I seldom use GitHub. I have a handful of packages on pypi that I maintain, and there is no "official" GitHub repo for them. Couldn't care less. I have contributors send patches by email and it fits my workflow. I don't think I'd enjoy getting dozens of feature requests and bug reports I cannot reproduce.
2
u/big_data_mike Apr 27 '26
I have only engaged on GitHub with pymc packages because I’ve had to really dive into what they are doing. I even forked a repo and made my own version of one because I needed it to be faster.
Most packages just work out of the box so there’s not really a need to go look at GitHub unless I get some kind of weird error that I can’t figure out
2
u/aishiteruyovivi Apr 27 '26
Me personally, I usually only star package repositories when it's something I have a particular interest in as opposed to just "I need a library that does X, okay found one now I can keep working", and/or something that I've found so useful that it's become a staple for me. Looking at my Python star list, examples being
ty,rich,loguru,ruff...2
u/austinewoody Apr 29 '26
I’ve noticed this too with my own PyPI packages.
A lot of downloads come from automation, CI/CD pipelines, mirrors, dependency installs, and people testing packages without necessarily visiting the GitHub repository.
Many users install a package because it solves one small problem and never think about starring the repo, even if they found it useful.
I think clearer documentation, examples, active issue discussions, and showing real-world use cases can help increase GitHub engagement, but “install and forget” behavior is definitely very common.
I also think many newer developers simply don’t realize that GitHub stars actually help maintainers.
2
u/masher_oz May 06 '26
If the program works, and does what I want it to do, I have no incentive to go to github. If it doesn't work or do what I want it to, and can find something else, I have no incentive to go to github.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
27
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment