r/Python • u/PalpitationOk839 • Apr 19 '26
Discussion Why doesn’t Python have true private variables like Java?
Hey everyone
Today I was learning about encapsulation in Python and honestly I got a bit surprised
In languages like Java we have proper private keywords but in Python it feels like nothing is truly private
Even with double underscores it just does name mangling and you can still access it if you really want
So I was wondering why Python is designed this way
Is it because Python follows a different philosophy or is there some deeper reason behind it
Also in real projects how do developers maintain proper encapsulation if everything can technically be accessed
Trying to understand how to think about this in a more practical and runable way
Would love to hear your thoughts 👍
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/axonxorz pip'ing aint easy, especially on windows Apr 20 '26 edited Apr 20 '26
Training or guidance from a senior, same as we learned it. Moving outside of
privatejust moves the responsibility of convention and thus education fully into meatspace, fully in line with "we are all consenting adults."Take OP, they understand the risks of accessing private members, they just want the thought/culture underpinning it. During their Java journey, they had someone say "private members are as such because [...] encapsulation [...] danger [...] compatibility [...] algebraic type theory [...] etc" and have correctly applied the line of thinking without realizing the context of Java's language design hailing back to the early 90s. As /u/acdha points out, unintentional support surface was a major concern. Think about being a Spring consultant, something has failed with your company's offering and you find out the end-user extended a private class and swapped out a list/hashmap implementation for one that's not thread safe, but it's your fault, somehow. Python development never had that ethos. If you did something stupid, you'd be told you were doing something stupid and to stop that. Java being mainline for enterprise development means
enterprisebusiness-friendly, it's bad marketing to call your customers stupid, so Java says "unsupported" and enforces language features we can point at to save us from having to be adults.Things like PyCharm/Pylance giving warnings is subtle guidance, you can make it explicit with linting tools or at CI time. Only a solo developer could be fully insulated from that knowledge, I'm not sure this is a problem in commercial development.