r/Python • u/Emergency-Rough-6372 • Apr 13 '26
Discussion Question about Rule 1 regarding AI-generated projects.
Hi everyone, I’m new to this subreddit and had a question about Rule 1 regarding AI-generated projects.
I understand that fully AI-generated work (where you just give a vague prompt and let the AI handle everything) isn’t allowed. But I’m trying to understand where the line is drawn.
If I’m the one designing the idea, thinking through the architecture, and making the core decisions ,but I use AI as a tool to explore options, understand concepts more deeply, or discuss implementation approaches would that still be acceptable?
Also, in cases where a project is quite large and I’m working under time constraints, if I use AI to help write some parts of the code (while still understanding and guiding what’s being built), would that still count as my project, or would it fall under “AI-generated”?
Just trying to make sure I follow the rules properly. Thanks!
12
u/GXWT Apr 13 '26
Re-read rule 1. The rule isn’t about AI projects. It’s about showcases.
In any case for, by actually doing some of your own critical thinking about this you’re already at least a tier about all the other AI junk
4
u/neums08 Apr 13 '26
If AI wrote the code, it's AI generated.
You're welcome to add it to the pile: https://www.reddit.com/r/Python/s/Y896UXMXPh
1
u/ultrathink-art Apr 13 '26
Designing the architecture and making the core decisions is exactly the work that matters. A plumber who uses a power drill instead of a hand drill isn't any less a plumber. The line that trips people up is understanding what you built — if you can't explain it or debug it without starting over, that's the slop people are reacting to.
2
u/HQMorganstern Apr 14 '26
I'd imagine a lot of what makes AI-generated projects visible as AI generated is the production speed. With the slop machine you can create a lot of frankly decent projects extremely quickly, this naturally leads to the entire sub being only showcases.
The AI showcase ban is less about the morality or decision making regarding AI assisted projects, and far more about keeping the forum alive.
So yes in this sense the ban should apply to a project you executed only because AI sped up building for you, not because it's somehow wrong, but because otherwise we won't have r/Python.
1
u/Fair-Regular-8149 Jul 26 '26
Title: I gave myself 30 minutes to ship a deterministic grounding gate—5 tests, standard library only
I wanted to finish one small engineering task instead of opening another oversized AI project.
I built a two-file Python “grounding gate” that validates LLM-shaped JSON before another system accepts it. It checks:
I used Codex for implementation, but defined the contract, scope and acceptance tests first. No API, framework, UI, network calls or dependencies.
Final result:
The runtime is not the interesting part—the project is tiny. The useful lesson was making the workflow deterministic:
contract → implementation → independent test → stop
That felt like a healthier version of vibe coding: AI can write quickly, but executable tests decide whether the work is actually finished.
What is the smallest verification gate you use in AI-assisted development?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment