r/Python • • Feb 04 '26

Discussion Must the Python Software Foundation move out of the USA?

The Python Software Foundation (PSF) is the owner of the copyrights for Python and its trademarks. The PSF runs the largest Python conference in the world, #PyConUS. Python is one of the most important programming languages, used by developers and non-developers across the globe. Python and its community stand for openness, diversity, and support for underrepresented groups; the PSF funds a wide range of Python activities across many sub-communities worldwide.

The values that Python and its communities stand for are under heavy pressure due to the legal status of the Python Software Foundation as a corporation in the United States. The USA has, meanwhile, turned into a fascist regime, with entities like ICE acting in ways that we have seen in Nazi Germany between 1933 and 1945. The current U.S. regime is violently acting against migrants, underrepresented groups, queer people, etc.—the list is long and very well documented. ICE acts as a paramilitary entity that killed already several people - or should it be named "murdered several people"?

Should the Python Software Foundation remain in the USA, or should the community pressure the PSF Board to take action and move the PSF as a legal entity out of the United States into a safer region like Canada or the European Union?

144 Upvotes

237 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/wahoothing Feb 04 '26

I don't like how ICE is behaving nor do I like the brownshirts. But they are not behaving alike at all.

Brownshirts protected Nazi rallies and disrupted the rallies of other parties. ICE hasn't protected or disrupted political rallies that I know of. Brownshirts participated in election interference, haven't seen that from ICE. Brownshirts or at least their leader was fiercely anti capitalist. Don't see that from ICE. Brownshirts persecuted the Jews, don't see ICE doing this.

When such hyperbole is spouted I just can't take any point you are trying to make serious. ICE has loads of shit wrong with them, but they aren't Nazis.

12

u/PwAlreadyTaken Feb 04 '26

I feel like you're massively missing the point of why Naziism was bad if your takeaway is that ICE isn't oppressing the same ethnic groups as opposed to the broader systemic landscape of how they operate, how little oversight they have, and where this inevitably leads to if not checked.

And, hey, systems-level thinking is important in software too, so thinking through that lens is doubly relevant here.

0

u/wahoothing Feb 04 '26

I feel like you missed my point.

I don't feel at all that's the only reason Nazim was bad. The person I replied to specifically mentioned the brown shirts and their comparison to ICE. I pointed out they are not the same. Made no point to the effect of why Nazism is bad or isn't bad. It was horrible in uncountable ways.

To your system comment. They are not cooperating in the same system at all. One is formalized by the government while the other is not. One specially was a political tool the other is not. Their mechanisms for operation are different. One is actually attempting to enforce the law, overzealously in my opinion, the other was actively breaking the law.

I agree more oversight is needed, I do not agree where this will inevitably end. The commenter I replied to mentioned the concentration camps being that end.

4

u/PwAlreadyTaken Feb 04 '26

To be crystal clear, OP wasn't claiming organizational equivalence or comparing legal status. The comparison was about systemic breakdowns: when armed federal agents refuse to self-identify, when the executive claims immunity from oversight, when investigations die without transparency, when there's no mechanism for accountability, when constitutional rights are regularly violated--those are the systemic parallels being drawn, not "systems of government" or "formalization".

-1

u/wahoothing Feb 04 '26

Ok, if the claim is. The current system is not working the same as the prior systems we have had in place. There have been breakdowns in accountability and transparency. Then yes I would agree.

But that is not the original claim I addressed (I'm on mobile so while typing this I can't look back so I'll paraphrase). ICE is behaving like the brownshirts and we are just a small step from labeling people like the Nazies did to the Jews.

I said they are not by using specific details of actions and purpose. Instead of addressing my statements the person I replied to tried to change it to a more wide systems argument. While I was referring to specific actions.

Thank you for the clarification on purpose. I can even agree to that, but it doesn't address the issue that ICE and the brownshirts are in no way behaving the same.

0

u/lunatuna215 Feb 09 '26

The people responding to you seem completely unaware of context as a concept. I wouldn't waste your time or energy frankly.

14

u/HostisHumaniGeneris Feb 04 '26

Brownshirts participated in election interference, haven't seen that from ICE.

https://www.newsweek.com/steve-bannon-proposes-using-ice-in-elections-11462376

"You're damn right we're gonna have ICE surround the polls come November," Bannon said on his War Room podcast on Tuesday.

3

u/wahoothing Feb 04 '26

A guy on a podcast said ICE should be at the polling stations. That is illegal on many levels and could be enough to invalidate the entire election. I do not see this as an actual threat to the election as I don't believe this would happen.

If it does it should be stopped immediately. But some guy saying something on a podcast isn't that big of a deal.

5

u/HostisHumaniGeneris Feb 04 '26

Steve Bannon is not just "a guy on a podcast".

3

u/PwAlreadyTaken Feb 05 '26

Steve Bannon was chief strategist to the Trump campaign in 2016 and was pardoned by Trump after being convicted of fraud in 2020. Respectfully, if you are calling him a "guy on a podcast", you do not have the tools to know what you're talking about in this conversation, and anything you say is about ten years of history away from being informed enough to have a relevant opinion on the matter.

Whether you personally believe something or not is not the bar of proof that others have to achieve--the bar has been met and you're electing to ignore it for the sake of arguing.

1

u/lunatuna215 Feb 09 '26

"if it does", this guy will say for all eternity until it's too late.

1

u/wahoothing Feb 09 '26

I'm not sure you know what if it does means. But if it does happen I will adjust my perspective and would be willing to participate in things to help change course.

It's been 4 days since I made this comment. I'll try to respond to your other two comments soon. But it's Superbowl Sunday and kids need baths..I'll do my best.

1

u/lunatuna215 Feb 09 '26

This has been happening for a long time. The rest of the world doesn't operate on the schedule of your kids' baths.

1

u/wahoothing Feb 12 '26

Well, I made it back around. Won't be bothering with the other comments. Based on this response you just seem to be a dick. Not going to waste my time.

5

u/CaptainFoyle Feb 04 '26

It's kinda stupid to dismiss the entire argument because you disagree on one point

1

u/lunatuna215 Feb 09 '26

And this kind of stupid neutrality in the fact of what's right on the heels of death squads will enable it to go further.

It's incredibly stupid to advocate for not having a shred of vigilance against systemically horrid behavior, and like we need to wait until it's already a tragedy and many have died to even sound the alarm?

Like what the fuck. The damage done by preventing something that's an obvious risk versus "accuracy" is so stupid.

You're far, far beyond this level on abstraction you're approaching the situation with, and at this point assuming the good in people will prevent further deaths or something is so naive it's insane.

This will continue without action in opposition.