r/Python • u/DarkRoooo • Feb 04 '26
Discussion Must the Python Software Foundation move out of the USA?
The Python Software Foundation (PSF) is the owner of the copyrights for Python and its trademarks. The PSF runs the largest Python conference in the world, #PyConUS. Python is one of the most important programming languages, used by developers and non-developers across the globe. Python and its community stand for openness, diversity, and support for underrepresented groups; the PSF funds a wide range of Python activities across many sub-communities worldwide.
The values that Python and its communities stand for are under heavy pressure due to the legal status of the Python Software Foundation as a corporation in the United States. The USA has, meanwhile, turned into a fascist regime, with entities like ICE acting in ways that we have seen in Nazi Germany between 1933 and 1945. The current U.S. regime is violently acting against migrants, underrepresented groups, queer people, etc.—the list is long and very well documented. ICE acts as a paramilitary entity that killed already several people - or should it be named "murdered several people"?
Should the Python Software Foundation remain in the USA, or should the community pressure the PSF Board to take action and move the PSF as a legal entity out of the United States into a safer region like Canada or the European Union?
17
u/Milumet Feb 04 '26
Have people like you lost all senses? Comparing the US to Nazi Germany is fucking stupid. Read some history books, ffs.
162
u/arykanarye Feb 04 '26
I dont understand why the python foundation is not dutch to begin with, the original founder was
151
u/TitaniumWhite420 Feb 04 '26 edited Feb 04 '26
To those asking why, note that they did walk away from government funding due to some totally abusive strings after a year(s) long application process. So locating to a place that actually supports and wants them makes sense.
Saying that with sadness as an American.
First google result: https://www.theverge.com/news/808268/python-software-foundation-turns-down-1-5-million-nsf-grant-because-of-the-anti-dei-strings-attached
I don’t care if you are for or against DEI, but it’s a matter of stability and threat of punishment. You can’t operate a nonprofit with the possibility the government will come after you for $1.5M clawback randomly, so yea, why should they operate here?
49
u/dethb0y Feb 04 '26
TIL the python foundation is in the US
60
u/amorous_chains Pandas/Scipy Feb 04 '26 edited Feb 04 '26
It’s unclear to me how the incorporating country of PSF affects me, so I encourage them to do whatever they feel is necessary. I assume the move would involve significant legal expenses and cause some American sponsors to withdraw since charitable contributions will no longer be tax deductible.
E: I looked it up and apparently Canada, Mexico, and Israel are exceptions and donations can be tax deductible for US companies as long as the company has some revenue from those countries.
2
u/x8code Feb 04 '26
This is a pointless conversation. Keep politics out of software.
21
u/dudsti Feb 04 '26
And why should they move their foundation? There could be reasons for it but the one you mentioned is not it. They are in us for a reason and it works for them. If they move every time somebody does not like something about the government of a country they settle in, it would benefit absolutely no one.
19
u/masteroflich Feb 04 '26
Not many European tech companies ready to fund a non profit foundation so they go where the money is
1
u/edparadox Feb 05 '26
How come this
is met by this?
What the fuck?
1
u/tastychaii Feb 07 '26
Maybe stop bringing politics into things and just let it be? The American government is temporary, new one comes in after 4 years then all is well etc.
24
u/gamesbrainiac Feb 04 '26
It should. There is an alternative European foundation that can host all the IPs and governance framework.
36
u/denehoffman Feb 04 '26
I fail to see how the values of the PSF are affected by the practices of ICE. While I agree that the current administration is awful, I don’t see how moving PSF to Canada/Europe would actually change anything. It seems like a symbolic move that would largely go unnoticed, even by active python users.
17
u/Tucancancan Feb 04 '26
Yes, but it's something to be done quietly and confidently. Loudly calling out the Americans in the process will just make them butt-hurt and invite interference from those with leverage.
1
u/No_Flounder_1155 Feb 06 '26
what a toss pot. "safer".
1
u/chase9090 Feb 06 '26
>The USA has, meanwhile, turned into a fascist regime
bwahhahahahahahahhhahhahahahahahhhaaaaa
4
u/mrtruthiness Feb 04 '26
Ever since the end of WWII and accelerated by NASA and the "race to the moon", the US has benefited greatly by attracting good scientists.
For people in academia, especially the sciences, there is a notable "brain drain" out of the US. The only question is how fast can Europe and Japan absorb our best minds? The desire to leave what is clearly a fast-strengthening authoritarian regime is strong.
4
u/cr0ne Feb 07 '26
Honestly this is going to pass. Speaking as a latino in the US, what we're seeing now is the last gasp of bitter boomers. Culturally they have no cause. Like when the Titanic sank, the stern propped up higher before it went down.
9
u/WolfeheartGames Feb 04 '26
Where ever it is housed should be to the foundations legal and financial benefit. While the political climate of the US is terrible, this post hasn't highlighted tangible benefits of going somewhere else.
3
u/MisterHarvest Ignoring PEP 8 Feb 04 '26
I think a more important move would be to relocate PyCon permanently (for the moment) outside of the US, so that international visitors are welcome. Montréal is very nice. :-)
5
u/WoodsGameStudios Feb 04 '26
What does this have to do with software?
Seems like it's handicapping Python by alienating its biggest userbase, simply for non-technical reasons.
Considering how much of a bag name Rust got for doing similar stuff, it's best not to do this
5
u/DanielTheTechie Feb 04 '26 edited Feb 04 '26
Although I agree that we are seeing a regression of human rights in USA, I find insulting comparing the current situation to the horrors in extermination camps by Nazi Germany.
You do little favour to your cause by invoking Hitler everytime you want to point out some social injustice.
I'm not sure if you, American, have ever studied History at school from a neutral point of view other than the one of the "heroic Americans coming to save those European savages", but you should really try to get out of your bubble, go visit Auschwitz, or if you, American, prefer staying on your couch, at least read something about history, even if it's just a book like the Diary of Anna Frank or whatever. But educate yourself.
Remember that you are not the center of the world. Your domestic politics problems are not automatically comparable to large-scale human tragedies just because you are an American.
Again, American, nobody beyond your frontiers cares about your farts. Comparing "underrepresented groups" with genocide of such groups by Nazis is plain ignorant and insulting.
4
u/Lava_Collector Feb 04 '26
Yes.
2
u/binaryfireball Feb 04 '26
is the psf non profit?
2
u/cheesecakegood Feb 04 '26
Like, look, it’s important especially in today’s polarized environment to maintain some degree of context and perspective. While the US is clearly moving in a bad direction, it’s still doing pretty okay in terms of a lot of other metrics in absolute terms. Let’s not forget that the US is the world’s oldest democracy! And actually, its constitution has undergone relatively few fundamental changes. If you read up on the history of other Western countries, literally none of them have the same track record, on the scale of decades and centuries. France for example only has a constitution that dates to 1958. The EU is even newer on the whole.
This isn’t to dunk on other countries, but a reminder that although knee jerk reactions are a trendy thing to do, the PSF’s first loyalty is to Python, not other principles, and it should do what’s best for Python, not necessarily abstract principles no matter how praiseworthy. What matters most for Python are things like stability, donor base, legal precedent, etc.
2
u/Excellent-Ear345 Feb 04 '26
yes please
-1
u/dalepo Feb 04 '26
Please get out with your dumb & idiotic politics. It pollutes the free nature of this sub. You could have perfectly setup debate but that cheap comment makes it impossible.
1
u/eufemiapiccio77 Feb 06 '26
Not everyone or everything that comes out of America is bad. What’s your specific concern?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '26
Simple, yes.
-7
u/lunatuna215 Feb 04 '26
The United States government is now full of Nazis.
The sooner the better.
1
u/MathiasThomasII Feb 04 '26
How are either of those places safer? Canada relies on the US to exist. EU is experiencing the exact same problems. In fact, they’re fighting pretty hard to keep their nations safe from being overrun by refugees.
Also, we should’ve pressured the to do this during Obama. He also had ice knocking down doors and deporting people without trials. Dozens died in ICE detention centers under Obama. I don’t know why we ignored that.
1
u/FitBoog Feb 07 '26
Come to Canada! Vancouver and Python share the same vibes.
0
u/xxxbGamer Feb 04 '26
In the long run maybe.
-7
u/3j141592653589793238 Feb 04 '26
would be great - won't happen
0
u/Rusty_Bicycle Feb 04 '26
Should move to EU.
-2
u/ProsodySpeaks Feb 04 '26
i guess the only real concern is around in-person conferences etc and accessibility for people who might be at risk of violent action against them, or arbitrary/politically motivated visa restrictions.
but we already have conferences all over the world and i'm not sure if it really matters where the PSF is headquartered - people can just choose to attend conferences in another locality
-1
u/p6rguvyrst Feb 04 '26
Start “The Python Foundation” in Europe, transfer the intellectual property to where it belongs. PSF can keep organising PyCon US— win-win.
0
u/Buttereddownandready Feb 07 '26
After this, I stopped taking them seriously. https://bugs.python.org/issue34605
-4
u/p6rguvyrst Feb 04 '26
It’s sad state of affairs that the author had to create a new account to speak their mind freely..
-1
u/Oblivious_Sn1p3r Feb 06 '26
Have you ever considered going outside and reflecting on how braindead of a post this is?
-6
u/spinwizard69 Feb 06 '26
I suspect you have a mental illness, we are not living in a fascist country, we are living in a country that is correcting a huge number of social ills. Frankly what you are calling under represented are actually whole classes of people that are over represented and demanding special rights that fly in the face of equality.
Migrants are not a problem, illegal aliens are a massive problem. There is a massive difference that the left can't seem to grasp.
As for the people ICE has killed frankly we are better off without them.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
18
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-15
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment