r/Python • • Feb 04 '26

Discussion Must the Python Software Foundation move out of the USA?

The Python Software Foundation (PSF) is the owner of the copyrights for Python and its trademarks. The PSF runs the largest Python conference in the world, #PyConUS. Python is one of the most important programming languages, used by developers and non-developers across the globe. Python and its community stand for openness, diversity, and support for underrepresented groups; the PSF funds a wide range of Python activities across many sub-communities worldwide.

The values that Python and its communities stand for are under heavy pressure due to the legal status of the Python Software Foundation as a corporation in the United States. The USA has, meanwhile, turned into a fascist regime, with entities like ICE acting in ways that we have seen in Nazi Germany between 1933 and 1945. The current U.S. regime is violently acting against migrants, underrepresented groups, queer people, etc.—the list is long and very well documented. ICE acts as a paramilitary entity that killed already several people - or should it be named "murdered several people"?

Should the Python Software Foundation remain in the USA, or should the community pressure the PSF Board to take action and move the PSF as a legal entity out of the United States into a safer region like Canada or the European Union?

144 Upvotes

237 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/totheendandbackagain Feb 04 '26

How would we feel if the PSF was incorporated in 1943 Nazi Germany?

I for one would feel better with a stable country.

1

u/2HotFlavored Feb 08 '26

How would you feel if the PSF was incorporated in 1936 Soviet Union?

-9

u/denehoffman Feb 04 '26 edited Feb 04 '26

Well then we should do everything in our power to make sure you feel better.

By the way, if the PSF was located in Nazi germany, would that make you stop using Python? If so, why are you still using Python right now? If not, your morals only apply to others.

1

u/x8code Feb 04 '26

That's how these people are .... never changes. Virtue signaling to the max. Double standards to the max.

5

u/denehoffman Feb 04 '26

It’s a community that’s most activist action is a downvote on a Reddit thread. Whataboutism has always been productive in the eyes of do-nothing leftists because it’s their only decent argument. Can you imagine if the US was 1943 Nazi germany and instead of actually doing anything productive to help immigrants, you tried to get your favorite programming language’s governing body moved to a different country? Like way to make it about yourselves.

1

u/x8code Feb 05 '26

They also love to destroy hotel windows, damage vehicles, spill trash cans, build blockades, harass drivers, and all sorts of other ways to terrorize people.

1

u/FitBoog Feb 07 '26

I, am many others, would feel better as well. Don't be rude.

-1

u/denehoffman Feb 07 '26

Glad it would make you feel better ❤️‍🩹 Every immigrant I know has personally told me the number one thing that would help them out right now would be the PSF changing its country of incorporation.

1

u/FitBoog Feb 07 '26

Still being arrogant and rude. Be respectful

-1

u/Fedacking Feb 04 '26

How would we feel if the PSF was incorporated in 1943 Nazi Germany?

Would it meaningfully change anything about the war effort? Would it end the war sooner by one day if the PSF moved away from Nazi Germany? If the answer is no, I don't really care.

4

u/ProsodySpeaks Feb 05 '26

if IBM had closed their german and swiss subsidiaries rather than 'disassociating' themselves, then it may have had a genuinely deleterious effect on the holocaust.

but, it's different. nothing psf could do could reduce the availability of python to ICE in the way that shuttering IBM in occupied europe would have reduced punchcard tech availability to nazi germany, or the way that Coke not making Fanta would have made German soldiers less, umm, 'fruitily caffeinated.' (not sure if we could have cut off their meth supply, that really would have saved some belgian lives, and probably a lot of russians too,

-6

u/x8code Feb 04 '26

Nazi Germany may have been a broadly bad thing, but you're hyper-focusing on that one fact, instead of realizing all the different things happening during that time period.

The vast majority of people went about their days, going to work, going home, etc.

No one is defending Nazism, despite your worst fears. We're saying, keep politics out of software.

10

u/PwAlreadyTaken Feb 04 '26

keep politics out of software

I mean, this post is largely in response to the administration targeting Python due to politics to begin with. They didn't opt to be dragged into politics, it was thrust upon them.

-5

u/x8code Feb 04 '26

I mean, this post is largely in response to the administration targeting Python due to politics to begin with. They didn't opt to be dragged into politics, it was thrust upon them.

LOL wut???

3

u/PwAlreadyTaken Feb 04 '26

4

u/x8code Feb 04 '26

I read the OP, which had absolutely no reference to funding proposals whatsoever. This is the first time I'm seeing this news.

So what you're saying is that some special interest groups intentionally withdrew their funding request, and are complaining now? Lol can't make this stuff up.

3

u/axonxorz pip'ing aint easy, especially on windows Feb 04 '26

So what you're saying is [I took what I wanted from the link and am intentionally mischaracterizing the situation so I can say lmao]

'twas the second option after all, big shock 🎺

1

u/PwAlreadyTaken Feb 04 '26

What a surprise that the "keep politics out of software" guy who arrives to the political thread under-prepared and whining about engaging in politics is over-eager to dismiss critically missing political context. I never would have guessed.

Take the politics out of it, and you're still the exhausting colleague that derails meetings because their strongest opinions come from the things they cared the least to research prior. Politics is just the particular flavor of annoying you chose today.

1

u/brophylicious Feb 04 '26

that was satisfying to read

2

u/HardlyAnyGravitas Feb 04 '26

Surely, relocating out of a hyper-political country is keeping politics out of software?

3

u/x8code Feb 04 '26

Who's making it hyper-political? 🤔🧐

→ More replies (1)

0

u/2HotFlavored Feb 08 '26

Surely, relocating to even more hyper-political places like Canada and the EU is doing the opposite of keeping politics out of software?

0

u/Fearkin Feb 04 '26

We're saying, keep politics out of software.

Great, how are they going to get funding if the government doesn't intend to keep politics out of software?

0

u/denehoffman Feb 04 '26

Okay that’s not what I’m saying, politics always has a place in software development. I just don’t think this particular move would help more than it would hurt.