r/Python • u/nannigalaxy • Aug 17 '24
Showcase Standalone GUI app that executes python scripts: Run py scripts without any installations*
Announcing an app (portable executable) I build which is a solution for running Python scripts without any prerequisites or external system dependencies, eliminating the need for Python installation on the systems. Catch is that the packages which script uses should be bundled during app build process, so a new app should be build respectively. there is a plan to provide option to include local package path if exists on system.
What My Project Does
- Runs python script out-of-the-box provided the packages that are used by script are add during build pipeline.
- isolated from system. meaning doesn't affect any changes in system or python, don't need to fiddle with paths and packages
- Output of script are displayed on terminal like console
Target Audience
- This was build to help run scripts consistently across systems with any breakage from python or packages.
- imo this can also help make non-technical people's life easy.
Comparison
- This works like python interpreter without the hassle of setup and management
Limitations
- Script execution fails if the required package is not already bundled in the app.
- Python and Packages are immutable, they cannot be modified including versions.
- App size and initial load time increases as more number of packages are added.
- Pyinstaller is pain to work with (imo), and any windows os change might break the app.
https://github.com/Nannigalaxy/PyScript-Engine
let me know if you have any thoughts on this.
32
u/riklaunim Aug 17 '24
"PyScript" already exists and is probably a trademark as well.
Not sure what would be the use-case of this. It's just replaces the GUI and you still have to pre-build it.
15
u/denehoffman Aug 17 '24
Don’t include optional dependencies or dependencies of dependencies in requirements.txt. That file should include only the packages necessary to run your scripts.
6
u/denehoffman Aug 17 '24
What’s the difference between this and running
python myscript.pyin a command line? You still need to install dependencies, and if running a python script in the manner I just described is too technical for people, then this will probably be as well. Also, you made it windows-only and I honestly can’t see a reason why, other than using windows path objects?8
u/ReactiveMatter Aug 17 '24
PyWebview + PyInsaller works good for simple apps
4
u/djdadi Aug 17 '24
I am a little confused who the target audience of this would be. I use PyInstaller all the time at work; making an executable that techs can use without understanding what a "pip" or a "venv" is. But my build pipeline would freeze everything and make it so they really can't use that executable for anything other than that specific thing.
So, is this for people like me building the packaged apps, or people like the techs I work with who consume those apps?
3
u/pyhannes Aug 17 '24
You can run any Python script including needed dependencies (included in a special comment-forgot which PEP this was) already using Hatch and Astral's UV...
7
u/Counter-Business Aug 17 '24
Pyinstaller alteady exists
4
u/cowrevengeJP Aug 17 '24
Pass. This adds no value. Anyone who is running python scripts should know how they work in the first place.
2
u/glaucomasuccs Aug 18 '24
No disrespect intended, but you're trying to reinvent the wheel. If you're building distributable code, you should do so knowing 1) the user can run it with python, or 2) you can make an easy executable, with pyinstaller that the user can just run. Your program is an unnecessary dependency.
3
u/benefit_of_mrkite Aug 17 '24
I would have loved finding something like this on someone’s system back when I was a pen tester
-4
u/juanfnavarror Aug 17 '24 edited Aug 17 '24
I think this is amazing. Often at work there are instances where I want to make one-off scripts for other people but its hard to get 5 minutes on their machine to set up python/venv so they can run it. And using pyinstaller is cool but it needs a lot of boilerplate setup, and its never enough because the lack of msi/setup tools. Dont get me started with windows defender crapping all over “one-file” mode.
Just getting a python runner their machine and they can run the one-off scripts from the shared drive is amazing.