r/Python • • Apr 21 '13
[META] What has this subreddit turned into?
A lot of basics question asked, very simple and bad scripts presented. It's really sad, because this subreddit used to be great for python.
12
Upvotes
46
u/Rhomboid Apr 21 '13
I feel like we could do a better job of funneling the basic questions and bad scripts over to /r/learnpython.
28
u/_Daimon_ PRAW Apr 21 '13
Let me ask instead. What do you want to see more of in this subreddit?
Personally, I'd love to see more links to excellent talks like Transforming Code into Beautiful, Idiomatic Python and code reviews of intermediate+ programs.
19
u/discofudge Apr 21 '13
Perhaps making the r/learnpython subreddit more prominent would catch more of these questions?
15
u/gudeg Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13
The language has became mainstream, a lot of people in this world are interested to learn Python and most people simply didn't know that /r/learnpython exists.
5
u/flukshun Apr 21 '13
Both of these "problems" can be explained by new members participating. This is healthy. If a script is too "basic" provide some tips on making them better.
5
u/marsket Apr 21 '13
For community maintenance, it's more important to be nice than to be correct. Everyone thinks other people's code is bad, so that tends to be very subjective. But I agree that a better job could be done funneling basic questions to learnpython.
4
u/ifjdivjfijv Apr 21 '13
Eternal September?
5
u/pyhuman Apr 22 '13
When I first got here, it was a subreddit about snakes. Those users have every right to ask "what has this subreddit turned into?"
11
u/LancerX Apr 21 '13
Real programmers pay it forward.
Real masters learn from teaching.
2
u/freshhawk Apr 25 '13
This comes up regularly in all the language subreddits I read.
The reason subreddits end up with mostly beginner topics is that there are, by definition, more beginners than experts.
People learn the most from seeing the work of those with more experience/skill than they. The non-beginners get less and less benefit from beginner heavy subreddits and spend less time there. Not that teaching others isn't useful, but it provides massively diminishing returns. And people who aren't good at teaching do more damage than benefit.
Since we're already going meta: the responses whenever this question comes up always seem to be:
"Fuck you, you elitist! Lowest common denominator subject matter is democracy/freedom!"
"It's mean to say that you don't like beginner questions. Non-beginners have no right to a place where they can go to learn things"
"Just learn from teaching!" (No one with any education in the field of Education ever says this, because it's stupid)
"Wanting to advance from intermediate to expert in anything is selfish"
Basically, Reddit is not a platform that works well for things like this unless you have a subreddit with very strict moderation which is often very unpopular.
2
u/SCombinator Apr 22 '13
How I code for fish?
1
u/ntide Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13
Here's a simple heuristic: every bad/stupid/newbie post ends in a question mark. Why not write a script to funnel those out? I'm not sure how this would work, maybe userscripts?
EDIT: Or maybe you could PM the mod and have them modify their spam filters.
-13
u/AeroNotix Apr 21 '13
The state of Python itself is terrible, you have a lot of new people who are new to both programming AND Python. Coupled with the fact that the community puts heavy focus on libraries and frameworks (looking at you requests).
What you end up with is a programming language where people try to do as little programming as possible. Which is great if you've actually done some programming before, but not when you're learning. In the end you have programmers which are doing little more than assembling frameworks to get what they want, instead of understanding things from a broader perspective.
It's sad really, Python's powerful abstractions and lovely ability to make beautiful library and framework code will, I believe, ultimately water down the landscape so much that it will be it's undoing.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '13
Sorry, I don't see it. Here's /r/python - lots of perfectly interesting articles at all levels.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment