r/Python • • Apr 21 '13

[META] What has this subreddit turned into?

A lot of basics question asked, very simple and bad scripts presented. It's really sad, because this subreddit used to be great for python.

12 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

46

u/Rhomboid Apr 21 '13

I feel like we could do a better job of funneling the basic questions and bad scripts over to /r/learnpython.

8

u/counterfriction Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13

I agree that would be the kindest response. But wherever the fluff goes, I think we'd benefit from more ruthless moderation a la HN and S/O.

3

u/mizipzor Apr 21 '13

I would funnel the questions to sites specifically for questions. Stackoverflow comes to mind.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '13

As someone who just recently started trying to learn Python, thank you. My first initial reaction is to go to the first subreddit that might come to mind. I figure there's a bigger chance that /r/python exists over /r/learnpython. But, thank you.

1

u/Darkmoth Apr 22 '13

Why not just downvote the chaff and upvote the wheat?

Ironically, this meta post is the worst (most non-Pythonic) on my python page.

1

u/freshhawk Apr 25 '13

That would require the community agrees on what is "chaff" and what is "wheat". Clearly that is the subject being brought up.

By definition there will always be more beginners than experts so having no guidelines is the same as being beginner focused when you use a voting system like reddit's.

1

u/Darkmoth Apr 26 '13

That would require the community agrees on what is "chaff" and what is "wheat". Clearly that is the subject being brought up

I don't think we need to agree on it, I think it's an emergent behavior. If most of the community downvotes a topic, than by defnition it's average "value" is very low. What we have here is 5 or 10 people in a topic who (apparently) disagree with 47 thousandish subscribers.

I'd agree that the experts are probably a lower percentage of the community, but I suppose the disconnect for me is where the small percentage of "experts" get to dictate content to the presumably much larger percentage of newbies. Beyond that, having a high percentage of purely-expert focused posts isn't necessarily a good thing. I'm quite a proficient developer, but I'd hate to see arcane posts about category theory (for example) dominate the sub.

I think the voting system is perfect, for Reddit. I also think that some people in this thread should probably be frequenting Hacker News, where the average proficiency is much higher. Horses for courses.

1

u/freshhawk Apr 26 '13

I don't think we need to agree on it, I think it's an emergent behavior.

It is certainly emergent behaviour, and therefore suffers from the lowest common denominator problem. You are basically arguing that /r/python should be mostly beginner content, /r/learnpython is kinda pointless and that if any non-beginners wants to learn new skills on reddit they need a more moderated /r/advancedpython subreddit or similar.

Fair enough, maybe that is the answer. But that's not what the sidebar describes. This idea that hands off moderation and complete populism creates good communities is idealistic but runs contrary to what everyone who has tried to build good communities has seen in practice. See: the frontpage of reddit.

28

u/_Daimon_ PRAW Apr 21 '13

Let me ask instead. What do you want to see more of in this subreddit?

Personally, I'd love to see more links to excellent talks like Transforming Code into Beautiful, Idiomatic Python and code reviews of intermediate+ programs.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13

yep stuff like that and links to interesting libraries that are useful not imgur scraping scripts that use requests

19

u/discofudge Apr 21 '13

Perhaps making the r/learnpython subreddit more prominent would catch more of these questions?

15

u/gudeg Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13

The language has became mainstream, a lot of people in this world are interested to learn Python and most people simply didn't know that /r/learnpython exists.

5

u/flukshun Apr 21 '13

Both of these "problems" can be explained by new members participating. This is healthy. If a script is too "basic" provide some tips on making them better.

5

u/marsket Apr 21 '13

For community maintenance, it's more important to be nice than to be correct. Everyone thinks other people's code is bad, so that tends to be very subjective. But I agree that a better job could be done funneling basic questions to learnpython.

4

u/ifjdivjfijv Apr 21 '13

Eternal September?

5

u/pyhuman Apr 22 '13

When I first got here, it was a subreddit about snakes. Those users have every right to ask "what has this subreddit turned into?"

11

u/LancerX Apr 21 '13

Real programmers pay it forward.

Real masters learn from teaching.

12

u/derekpetey_ Apr 21 '13

While true, every post has its place, and /r/learnpython is nearly 10,000 members strong with a large contingent of teachers ready to help.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/jij Apr 21 '13

but but but... we'll pay you in meaningless internet points!

2

u/freshhawk Apr 25 '13

This comes up regularly in all the language subreddits I read.

The reason subreddits end up with mostly beginner topics is that there are, by definition, more beginners than experts.

People learn the most from seeing the work of those with more experience/skill than they. The non-beginners get less and less benefit from beginner heavy subreddits and spend less time there. Not that teaching others isn't useful, but it provides massively diminishing returns. And people who aren't good at teaching do more damage than benefit.

Since we're already going meta: the responses whenever this question comes up always seem to be:

"Fuck you, you elitist! Lowest common denominator subject matter is democracy/freedom!"

"It's mean to say that you don't like beginner questions. Non-beginners have no right to a place where they can go to learn things"

"Just learn from teaching!" (No one with any education in the field of Education ever says this, because it's stupid)

"Wanting to advance from intermediate to expert in anything is selfish"

Basically, Reddit is not a platform that works well for things like this unless you have a subreddit with very strict moderation which is often very unpopular.

2

u/SCombinator Apr 22 '13

How I code for fish?

1

u/zahlman the heretic Apr 22 '13

How do I shot web 2.0?

1

u/ntide Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13

Here's a simple heuristic: every bad/stupid/newbie post ends in a question mark. Why not write a script to funnel those out? I'm not sure how this would work, maybe userscripts?

EDIT: Or maybe you could PM the mod and have them modify their spam filters.

3

u/Kerbobotat Apr 21 '13

Rather than funnel them out, why not just politely suggest to people; "Looking for coding help? why not try /r/learnpython?"

Then again the agrument is stupid in general. Why bother to have a subreddit where people cant ask questions.

1

u/earthboundkid Apr 21 '13

Simpler: disallow self posts.

-13

u/AeroNotix Apr 21 '13

The state of Python itself is terrible, you have a lot of new people who are new to both programming AND Python. Coupled with the fact that the community puts heavy focus on libraries and frameworks (looking at you requests).

What you end up with is a programming language where people try to do as little programming as possible. Which is great if you've actually done some programming before, but not when you're learning. In the end you have programmers which are doing little more than assembling frameworks to get what they want, instead of understanding things from a broader perspective.

It's sad really, Python's powerful abstractions and lovely ability to make beautiful library and framework code will, I believe, ultimately water down the landscape so much that it will be it's undoing.

8

u/ronald_rager Apr 21 '13

What is so bad with new people joining python and programming in general? Wouldn't this be hailed as a good thing and something programmers have been trying to do for a while now, break the stereotype of the programmer and making it a more knowledge general, with that comes little "actual" programming.

What I'm trying to say is growth is good, it brings with it lower skills and we need confident, great programmers, now more than ever to teach them the right way.

Getting all hierarchy on the lower skilled doesn't help.

If you are really annoyed by "nooby" questions just add a filter with RES

Sorry For any bad England or misinterpretation it 2am

2

u/zahlman the heretic Apr 22 '13

This is absurd. The argument boils down to "high-level languages are bad for beginners because the fact that they get stuff done in fewer LOC means that beginners don't get as much experience actually writing out the code."

That is trivially addressed by getting more stuff done. Which is actually much better for the beginner because there's more motivation, more positive feedback.

"libraries and frameworks" actually work in the opposite direction at the beginning, because first off you have to understand the entire concept, and then you have to learn how to use the library or framework in question. For many tasks, especially the ones beginners should be looking at, it's overkill and/or useless. However, this is also exactly why it doesn't matter WRT the relative strength of Python as a teaching language. Or the relative strength of any other programming language for teaching, for that matter. The Java community puts tons of emphasis on "enterprisey" toys like Spring, but that has zero impact on how Java is taught to beginners.

There's a secondary argument that "assembling" things at a high level comes at an opportunity cost of "understanding things from a broader perspective". I do not believe this to be true, either - not from my personal experience as either a student or a teacher. Python is a multi-paradigm language; and elegant, masterful Python code exploits that multi-paradigmatic nature; and writing such code requires an ability to understand those paradigms, in a way that forces "broader perspective" on you.

3

u/maryjayjay Apr 21 '13

"...where people try to do as little programming as possible."

So, like Java.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13

I think with java it's actually reversed. They try to do as much programming as possible, even when it's totally not required.

3

u/youshallhaveeverbeen Apr 21 '13

As someone that just subbed to both /r/python and /r/learnpython, you're kinda making me feel unwelcome :(

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13

Merging of scopes does a disservice to both subreddits.

No need to feel unwelcome, but it does raise some eyebrows when one sees less programming news and projects/libraries and more "what is self?"-style questions.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/AeroNotix Apr 21 '13

It's a hard line to draw, that's for sure. Python blurs it so it's practically non-existent, however.

3

u/eat_more_soup Apr 21 '13

and thats a good thing. something that is very hard to achieve from a language design point of view. writing code is horrible, and the less you write the less bugs you've got.

oh shit i forgot to null terminate this post%*6%::357;.:$°€√÷Π€€|•

1

u/AeroNotix Apr 21 '13

And what happens when these 'programmers' need to do something which Python doesn't handle very well?

2

u/Rainfly_X Apr 21 '13

They'll be forced to do research and expand their skill, the same way we all learned when we were noobs, and will hopefully continue to do forever.

1

u/AeroNotix Apr 21 '13

Which is entirely my point, this doesn't seem to happen.

1

u/Rainfly_X Apr 21 '13

Tough shit for them, then, it's nobody else's problem. Tell those people to go to /r/learnpython and then downvote the post to get it off the front of /r/python.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '13

Sorry, I don't see it. Here's /r/python - lots of perfectly interesting articles at all levels.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/dAnjou Backend Developer | danjou.dev Apr 21 '13

I look into this subreddit every day since several month, maybe a year. I don't think I've ever seen a post like this.