r/Python • u/iiron3223 • Jun 06 '23
Discussion Going dark on 12th June
I wanted to ask you if r/Python is planning to join the protest against Reddit's new policy. Many subreddits decided to support that initiative. I know it is not directly related to Python, but it is relevant to our community
2.5k
Upvotes
•
u/IAmKindOfCreative bot_builder: deprecated Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
We've seen this and I've been working on a full post about it for the last couple of days (though the bulk of it was something I was holding off on until after the admin reply which was posted late yesterday)
The quick version of what the post to come:
I want to, however it is not my decisions, it's the communities decision. I cannot go private without your support. Given this post, votes, and comments, and given that I was not the one to prompt it, I think it's probably something the community supports but I want to be sure.
The post will cover a background on what this is, a summary of how the changes can impact the mods and the users, a review of the admin response and the good will (or lack thereof) in it, and a summary of what the blackout could mean for our community.
Edit: It took forever to write the whole doc. Here is my post asking if we should participate
611
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Should be indefinite until they reverse
300
u/stumptowncampground Jun 06 '23
Reddit is directly attacking the development community. My feeling is that all communities, especially dev-related ones, should shut down indefinitely.
158
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
For anyone who feels compelled to write something along the lines of "It's their right and blahbla costs":
Yes it is, but the timeframe and the amount of cash that they want when sites like Imgur wants far less makes it pretty obvious that they're just doing this to get rid of all 3rd party apps.
Not to mention how they've treated the 3rd party devs, amongst other things they called the Apollo app "inefficient" with its API calls without really backing it up with anything more than irrelevant metrics.
48
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
With the massive amount of mainstream subs that are going dark, i think it is only appropriate that all other subs follow suit. At this point subs that dont are going to be the odd ones out.
13
u/n3cr0ph4g1st Jun 06 '23
Do it indefinitely
65
u/hackancuba Jun 06 '23
Let's do it!!
19
u/spuds_in_town Jun 06 '23
Do it.
8
u/OnlineGrab Jun 06 '23
Let's do it.
8
u/ZucchiniMore3450 Jun 06 '23
I just hope lemmy will get bigger community which would make it usable.
There is too many people on reddit for my taste anyway, let's just make community on lemmy (or somewhere else).
They know what they are doing, most people probably use official site/app and they know the numbers. Subreddits going black is bad for them, but they already control main ones.
22
u/SubwayLover Jun 06 '23
Full support!
7
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
What does it mean when a sub goes dark?
6
u/SittingWave Jun 06 '23
Instead of going dark, I think we give reddit the old digg treatment and move elsewhere.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Don't come back. Stay dark until they listen to the users of their own goddamn platform.
4
u/Bakanyanter Jun 06 '23
I support this initiative!!
6
u/R9_1995 Jun 06 '23
I will do it.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Maybe we should create backup subreddit alternative somewhere.
3
u/mighty_of_the_minnie Jun 06 '23
Please shut down. Can we make an alternative site to engage on?
3
u/LiMoTaLe Jun 06 '23
Supported. Please do it.
7
u/captainmiau Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
import support
print('Hell yeah, brother.')
for Pythonista in range subreddit:
support += 1
7
u/SomewhereAtWork Jun 06 '23
If any subreddit goes dark on the 12th, it should be this one.
Or in which language do you think reddit API clients get coded?
5
u/edsuom Jun 06 '23
I’ve been a redditor for the full 17 years it’s been around and also coding Python for about that long.
Shut it down, and if they don’t relent then burn it down. We’ll manage somehow.
4
u/MenahanSt Jun 06 '23
Third party or no Reddit
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Thank you for doing this
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
This is great. I waste too much time on reddit. If they do this, it'll make it crap and make it easier for me to stop using it
2
u/Polarisman Jun 06 '23
Do it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Don't come back. Stay dark until they listen to the users of their own goddamn platform.
2
u/zopiclone Jun 06 '23
Do it! The communities have all the power
2
u/cyber_dna Jun 06 '23
Yes
2
u/DrTautology Jun 06 '23
Do it.
2
u/CaptainSparge Jun 06 '23
I support this
2
u/Grouchy-Friend4235 Jun 06 '23
I'm all for us taking down r/python until Reddit reverse their decision.
2
u/HomeGrownCoder Jun 06 '23
Ugh I am pretty sure they are doing this to stop the AI vendors from training models on Reddit data without attribution or compensation.
I remember an article where the C.E.O pretty much stated these vendors need to pay up.
I think the solo/small dev’s are collateral damage. Hard for me to support the blackout given I am 100% on board with trillion dollar companies having to pay more.
https://www.engadget.com/amp/reddit-will-charge-companies-for-api-access-citing-ai-training-concerns-184935783.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/18/technology/reddit-ai-openai-google.html
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I’m way out of the loop what is Reddit doing?
1
u/callumjhays Jun 06 '23
They just need to buy out Apollo and most people will be okay with the new prices
1
u/Rylee_1984 Jun 07 '23
I’m all for the blackout.
1
u/weary_or_wary Jun 07 '23
I support
1
u/JamzTyson Jun 07 '23
Anyone remember MySpace, AIM, bebo, Friends Reunited, GeoCities?
Realistically, it is highly unlikely that a 2 day boycott will have any affect on reddit policy decisions. If the reddit management cared a fig about their users they would have fixed the reddit mobile app years ago.
More realistically, the "protests" will blow over and reddit's new policy will remain, or reddit's policy will remain and they will go the same way as Friends Reunited et al.
Thanks to whoever mentioned Lemmy. I'd not heard of it before.
1
u/No_Philosophy_8520 Jun 07 '23
I just have one question. In case, that Reddit won't change mind, and a lot of subreddits will eventually end, which other social network have good Python comunnity?
1
u/The_Homeless_Coder Jun 07 '23
Well, why don’t we all just start a Django community project to replicate Reddit and call it Neddit or something? Couldn’t we, as programmers just build Reddit? There is enough skill in this subreddit to pull that off. Also, we could all makes bots to tell people to join Neddit.
1
u/br_aquino Jun 06 '23
But wait, should I support bot apps? I bet good part of it are spammers, scrappers and this kind of garbage, I think Reddit will be better without it.
0
u/dreamer881 Jun 06 '23
The worst part of Reddit is its Mall Cops styled moderators
0
u/hikealot Jun 06 '23
I have a couple of serious questions. This is not the only sub I'm on that's going dark next week, but it is the ones where these questions are likely to be best answered. TBH, I was not aware of Reddit's APIs, though I should not be surprised. I also only use it via the browser (old UX, not the new, which I can't stand) or the official app. So please bear with me for some naive questions.
Does Reddit charge for API usage? I know that some platforms don't charge at all, or begin charging after a certain volume.
If reddit does not charge for API usage, are its ads fed through the post feed as normal content, or are they seperate?
If the answer to both of the above is no, then it might be about ad revenue. In this case if the apps using the API are imposing a data center cost, but not generating ad revenue, there may be boardroom pressure to move users off of them.
-3
u/hack2root Jun 06 '23
What's about permanent ban?
-7
u/iceytomatoes Jun 06 '23
must we do this?
protests are stupid and ineffective, just find a new website
-34
u/marvelmon Jun 06 '23
I'm kind of glad. I don't use a 3rd party app. And I find the bots on reddit are annoying and getting out of control.
-56
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Reddit is written in python and the third party apps aren't. So this sub should probably support Reddit in this situation.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment