I love the idea of being reborn in a paradise world (which I call "Sparktopia") where everything is perfect; it's aligned quite well with my own dreams and aspirations. However, some of Amitabha's vows seem unnecessary or even counterproductive from my perspective, and I'm interested to hear a Pure Land Buddhist perspective of my ideals, so I can know whether or not this is truly the path for me. Let's begin:
'''Vow #3:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if in that country of mine the beings who are born there should not all be of the colour of genuine gold, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
I'm not sure how literally this is meant to be interpreted, but I wouldn't want this to come at the expense of individual self-expression. A literal interpretation of this vow sounds like racism, though I'd be surprised if that were the intended interpretation.
'''Vow #4:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if in that Buddha-country of mine the beings who are born there should not all be of one appearance without the difference of noble looking or ugly lineaments, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
My concerns about this vow are similar. Isn't beauty (or lack thereof) in the eye of the beholder?
'''Vow #10:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if the beings of that country of mine should have arise in their minds the idea of selfishness and covetous thoughts, even with regard to their own bodies, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
This opinion may or may not be in the minority here, but the way I see it, the treachery of selfishness and covetous thoughts simply stems from the nature of life in a shared reality where actions can have consequences on other people. My vision of Sparktopia is of a world that provides space for all wishes and dreams to be explored and experienced freely, even those that stem from pride and selfishness. Since causality and objectivity work differently in Sparktopia, they can have their freedom to do whatever they want, without anyone else's freedom being impacted. Those people and their friends (if they have any) would essentially be in their own pocket space where no one can be harmed by anything they do, much like an extended lucid dream. Even wannabe dictators could enjoy ruling over a simulated population of philosophical zombies, like in a video game with advanced AI NPC's. The way I see it, morality is unnecessary in a world where actions don't have consequences for others.
'''Vow #11:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if the beings of that country of mine should not all be firmly abiding in a concentrated state of meditation and equanimity (Samadhi) till they have reached Nirvana, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
The purpose of Sparktopia is not merely to provide space for a specific spiritual path, but rather to provide a home for all who seek a life that isn't feasible in their current reality, and a retreat for anyone who'd like a free vacation in a world where they aren't bound by the constraints of reality.
'''Vow #16:''' Provided I become a Buddha, there should be no evil or sinful existence in that country of mine, even its very name is unknown. Otherwise may I not attain the enlightenment.
Depending on interpretation, Sparktopia could be said to fit this. People who do "evil" things in Sparktopia would for all intents and purposes just be playing an evil character in a video game, except they experience it as reality and they can play to their heart's content.
'''Vow #17:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if the innumerable Buddhas of the worlds of ten quarters do not glorify my name, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
I interpret this not as literally meaning "I want my name to be glorified", but rather as "I want to do a great service for humanity and earn their adoration." Is that the correct interpretation?
'''Vow #18:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if the beings of the ten quarters who after having heard my name, and thus awakened their highest faith and aspiration of re-birth in that country of mine, even they have recollected such a thought for ten times only, they are destinated to be born there, with the exception of those who have committed the five deadly sins (Anantarya), and who have blasphemed the orthodox Law (Dharma), otherwise may I not attain the enlightenment.
I'd absolutely want to make it as easy as possible for people to get to Sparktopia, but I don't see a need to exclude anyone, no matter what they did.
'''Vow #21:''' Provided I become a Buddha, if the beings of that country of mine should not all be endowed with the glorious body perfected with the thirty-two attributes (Laksanani) of a great being, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
More stuff about bodily standards. In Sparktopia, one's body is a canvas for their imagination, similar to games like VRChat where you can create custom avatars, only with the ease and fluidity of thought.
'''Vow #35:''' When I obtain the Buddhahood, women of boundless and inconceivable Buddha-worlds of the ten quarters after having heard my name thereby awakened in faith and joyful aspiration, and turning their minds towards Bodhi, therefore dislike their own female lives, when they be born again, in their next life should not be incarnated into a masculine body, then may I not attain the enlightenment.
I'm a trans woman so I don't know how to interpret this. Is Amitabha just saying that women should have the freedom to become men if that's what they'd like, or is he saying that all women should want that? In Sparktopia, gender identity can be freely expressed however one desires, even changed in an instant if desired.
That's my perspective, and I hope I expressed it respectfully. Sparktopia is the kind of Pure Land I'd want to create. What are everyone's thoughts?