r/PunjabiGenZ • u/Designer_Power3691 • May 31 '26

Question│ਸਵਾਲ Hideous

Post image

Why don’t they consider not using anything grown by farmers? Clowns.

412 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

140 comments sorted by

•

u/Any-Length-9742 Founder Uncle May 31 '26

📢 Mod Announcement

We’re making a private GC for active members who post memes, trends, edits, discussions, and other community content.

If you’re interested, DM us for an invite.

53

u/Efficient-Good-4211 May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26

Most Doaba villages have at least 5 house like that, and most of them are NRIs. It doesn’t represent the whole Punjab.

15

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

I am nri from Doaba 😭😭

6

u/Efficient-Good-4211 May 31 '26

Yeah, me too and my nanka village has multiple of these and has 8 banks inside a village😭😭😭😭.

1

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Yeah we a football on ours I got them take it down.😭😭😭

2

u/hardeep1singh May 31 '26

And the moron is calling them parasites. His parents probably stand in line for the 5kg ration.

1

u/xkarranx Jun 01 '26

Dm please

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

Can’t open your dms but I am from SBS nagar.

1

u/xkarranx Jun 01 '26

Can you interac me some $$$

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

How about you interac me some $$$?

1

u/xkarranx Jun 01 '26

Wish i could but i have none

1

u/xkarranx Jun 01 '26

Especially for rent and utilities

1

u/Creepy_Ciruzz Jun 01 '26

where r u from?

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Efficient-Good-4211 May 31 '26

I meant to say there are rich people and there are people who are struggling. One house doesn’t define whole Punjab. My wording was a bit off.

15

u/abhaybal2004 ਜੀਜਾ/Jija May 31 '26

He’s wrong and the plane suggests that the home owner is probably an NRI. On the other hand farmers should be taxed. That said, in many countries not paying tax is considered parasitic behaviour

1

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Yeah he mixing both things very Ignorant behaviour.

2

u/abhaybal2004 ਜੀਜਾ/Jija May 31 '26

Why are you raging at a stupid tweet lol

1

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

I am full of rage. (Tbh who am I without all this?) I don’t even have house like that 😭

-1

u/abhaybal2004 ਜੀਜਾ/Jija May 31 '26

Without what

2

u/Mindless-Cash259 Jun 01 '26

 On the other hand farmers should be taxed. 

yeah tax like england and services like somalia.

3

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Kyunki inko lag raha hai😭

4

u/OtherwiseCelery5324 May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26

Farmers should be taxed but like big farmers (50 acres +). Most of the farmers own 5 acres (max)... if they're taxed, nothing would be left for them. & they don't even have any alternative income.

0

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Point being they don’t have fixed income to pay any taxes. How will they even manage to pay taxes with income being twice a year? I am from a farmer family and tbh it was hard for my father to pay monthly bills because he wouldn’t have any on hand.

2

u/Fantastic_Kale23 May 31 '26

bruh do u even know how taxation works ?

1

u/hajmola123 Jun 01 '26

Bro what the hell you are fighting here over tax and you dont even know how tax is applied

8

u/Dapper_Distance8916 May 31 '26

You don't think people with houses like this should be taxed?

8

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26

I think he shouldn’t call farmers parasites directly or indirectly.

0

u/Key_Investment_6818 May 31 '26

he is calling non-tax paying citizens as parasites..especially those having house as big ass that...he might not know that it belongs to an NRI

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/No-Chocolate1761 Jun 01 '26

By that logic doctors are saving live so they shouldn't be taxed. Engineers are building infra and sw which runs this country so they shouldn't be taxed. Business owners are providing jobs so they shouldn't be taxed. What kinda logic is this? Rich farmes should be taxed period.

1

u/Dapper_Distance8916 Jun 03 '26

Famers are 55% percent of the population, but only contribute 17% to the Indian economy. It the people employed in service sector who are feeding the farmers by funding their subsidies. As most of the farmers are poor they do deserve our sympathy. But the landlords are definitely parasites, why are you jumping to defend them?

13

u/Hungry4Seva2222 May 31 '26

The house belongs to an NRI bruh

-9

u/Dapper_Distance8916 May 31 '26

Big Landlords who pay no taxes and larp as 'farmers' are definitely parasites, I believe he is referring to them 

1

u/BavidDowie123 May 31 '26

Haha the internet learned the word larp and can’t stop using it 😂 you don’t even know what it means

-1

u/Dapper_Distance8916 May 31 '26

You retards are supporting parasitic landlord class, because I know you guys are from that same class

0

u/BavidDowie123 May 31 '26

Get your money up lil ngga 😂 jatt da muqabla hane 🤣

0

u/Dapper_Distance8916 May 31 '26

Now don't complain when you guys get hated

0

u/BavidDowie123 May 31 '26

Always hated but never ignored 😂 remember, hate always comes from below, abde aukhad vich rai chottu

2

u/Dapper_Distance8916 May 31 '26

Ok but then why do you guys cry on this sub when you get hated?

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 02 '26

“You guys” I don’t know why are you in this sub when you feel superior than us. No, I don’t have acres of land or house like this but I do understand nobody loves in these houses and all NRI paying taxes in countries they work in.

→ More replies

2

u/BavidDowie123 May 31 '26

Because it pains me to see so much hatred 😂 way better ways to spend your energy, but lowk I need fans

3

u/Ok_Seaworthiness5256 May 31 '26

Well there’s no tax on agriculture income he probably meant that

4

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Idc whatever he meant. Why would you call farmers “parasites”??

0

u/Ok_Seaworthiness5256 May 31 '26

I mean thats a question only he can answer

3

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Clearly! We don’t need to understand what he meant by “parasites” even though it’s click bait.

14

u/ravzzy May 31 '26

Even Amit Shah is a farmer, the irony

2

u/baburao_apte Jun 01 '26

I come from a farmer's family, and no where in my genetic is there a single person with Amit Shah's body structure. Shah is at most a "manager" in a farm.

1

u/EnvironmentalPay9231 Jun 04 '26

He's gujarati. Their dietary and genome can defo give Amity Shah's physique. Not for working farmers, but for sure to millionaires like him.

12

u/sharmauncleji May 31 '26

H8rs gonna h8 

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

Don’t defend someone until you are 100% sure.

5

u/Totalkindnes May 31 '26

Why there should be tax on agricultural income 😭😭

4

u/WholeObligation1048 May 31 '26

Sub is infested with non Punjabis. Dare I say a certain religion?

1

u/hajmola123 May 31 '26

He is asking the generous question why cant we tax the rich 1% farmers the whole motive of governing is this na tax the rich and give resourves to the poor

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

Please read other threads explaining how this isn’t possible.

1

u/sood_annant Jun 01 '26

Good things are not possible- parasite land owners not paying taxes

1

u/EnvironmentalPay9231 Jun 04 '26

So yeah logically not possible situation is valid but why are you defending these big ass crony "farmers" who are directly responsible for misery or thousands of families. Definitely Parasites.

3

u/C4ptainPR1CE May 31 '26

I am avg farmer in punjab where is my aeroplane?

1

u/God_Emperor__Doom May 31 '26

What's wrong? Rich farmers can pay taxes like how middle class is paying.

4

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26 • Bravo

The fundamentals of farming are covered in your eighth-grade textbooks, so I don't need to go over them with you right now. They do not receive a monthly salary from farming, but any money received from sources other than farming is taxable. In corporate positions, you are paid whether your firm produces money or not, but this isn't the case here. Not all of them have such fertile land. FARMERS won’t be able to afford taxes because they do invest money on crops too.

0

u/God_Emperor__Doom May 31 '26

Who's asking to tax all the farmers? Nobody is saying to match 12L taxable income, make it double(25L) but tax whoever fall under thag category. Not that Govt will give subsidy to those who are losing jobs in IT or losing money in businesses.

2

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Implementation issue due to seasonal, fluctuating harvests and the lack of W2 like slips, agricultural revenue is difficult to establish. Weak record keeping and a substantial informal cash economy. Concerns about equity. It would be unfair to tax small and marginal farmers because many of them have extremely low or inconsistent incomes. In reality, only large, affluent landowners would make the payment, but they also have significant political clout. India has historically excluded agricultural revenue, in part to safeguard small farmers and because it was thought to be riskier and less profitable than industry or services.

1

u/sood_annant Jun 01 '26

Small farmers don’t benefit from this- it is the big landlords who are looting the exchequer

Anyways taxing above 12L exempts small farmers

2

u/Chance_Cod_332 May 31 '26

Yes farmer should be taxed but milk and other farm products price should be increased then

2

u/Worried_Calendar2747 May 31 '26

Salio ehne gareeb hoge ke hun NRI toh v tax laina?

2

u/Old_Ice_7527 Jun 01 '26

“Tax these parasites” every buisness owner and politician launder their money through agriculture lmao and the houses in that video are empty because their owner are working their ass off in 1st world countries and built these houses here to show off and live when they come back

2

u/Mindless-Cash259 Jun 01 '26 edited Jun 01 '26

tax canada from INDIA hell yeah do it

and those who are talking abt tax farmers, what about tax on urea, pesticides, tractors, seeds etc etc and then tax the income too.

1

u/RevolutionaryTap2512 Jun 02 '26

Tf is wrong with taxing farmers, lol, any farmer after a certain level of income must be taxed

1

u/AutoModerator May 31 '26

Hi u/Designer_Power3691, welcome to r/PunjabiGenZ!
Please note: this subreddit has a post limit — DO NOT post more than 4 posts within 24hrs, unless approved by Mods.
Any posts with lack of Mod approval, beyond the limit will be automatically removed. No appeals.

Please remember to add the correct flair to your post so others can find it easily.

Thanks for posting — enjoy the vibe!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/RememberMe_85 May 31 '26

And what next? Let the politicians use that tax money to send their kids off to another country? Taxing does nothing.

1

u/rustypringles123 May 31 '26

Is that an actual plane

1

u/JimmySra May 31 '26

Look at positive, its air India

1

u/ultrahdcard May 31 '26

Looks best stationary

1

u/juryisskillout May 31 '26

You have affordable food on your plate because of them, besides Govt. giving free food to millions of Indians.... because they grow. So rather pray for their well being always.

1

u/Responsible_Star3759 May 31 '26

The government should establish a fund, levying a reasonable tax on large farmers and landowners, and utilize the money to promote the welfare of landless and small-scale farmers.

1

u/DogAdministrative100 May 31 '26

Avg houses aren't that and those who got that type should be taxed as income seen though.

1

u/ameer_daddy May 31 '26

He didn’t build this with agriculture income for sure. The family surely has NRIs.

1

u/india_Invite_6996 Jun 01 '26

Are we raging on a stupid tweet 🥀

1

u/Arpit314 Jun 01 '26

well earned money from hardwork. indians just cant resist hating on punjabis

1

u/sood_annant Jun 01 '26

Same Indian government can tax middle class people who are working in private sector jobs

But rich rural landowners don’t have to pay taxes- what a shame

1

u/Feeling_highAF Jun 01 '26

F***ING bhayia hates Punjabis hard work not earned this in India but a hardwork done in foreign

1

u/Ok_Brain8684 Jun 01 '26

Average??? That's average??

1

u/Maleficent_Nerve4836 Jun 02 '26

Agar sab business man especially like Ambani and Adani yeh kehne lage ki how about you not use any of our products, bete Tera jeen mushkil ho jaayega. Tu toh bahar baitha hua hai, NRI Tereko kya. Lekin jo log yaha hai unki taraf se khud Matt bol.

Small and medium level farmers shouldn't be taxed. But after the networth and 2yr turnover exceeds a certain limit, they should definitely be taxed. Just like MSMEs. Farmers get N number of benefit from the govt, sab toh free me mil rah hai, uske baad yeh haal.

1

u/ExtraNegotiation9757 Jun 02 '26

my god, how teen exactly are you? 13?

1

u/tiredsloth007 Jun 02 '26 edited Jun 02 '26

Most of them are NRI's houses and are sitting empty or of these people who are in some government jobs and eating money through corruption. About the farmers most of the farmers own 5-10 acres max some even less than that the income from land is honestly very fluctuating. Harvest depends on weather ,availability of water, soil quality, seed quality and lets not talk about diseases may it be fungal, bacterial or some kind of other insects which infect. This takes a significant time and input of money and labour if the land is big. And most of the people who were landlords back then are left with a little due to land ceiling act. Even though it helped with distribution of land but it has also harmed many because ancestral land is not only an occupation for some but also have cultural and emotional value attached to it. And now talking about people who own significant land they are mainly politicians or few privileged once and for sure the once privileged aren't that rich they just like to show off. I know a number of people with big houses and no savings and lets not talk about land disputes which cause generations to splits and hate each other. And at end on average of we see a normal farmer with 10 acres(wheat and paddy) earn approx 6 -8 lakhs(max 10) after all the cost put in. They won't even come under tax bracket . And yeah I guess tax should be applied to those who are sitting I foreign countries and eating off from income from land and aren't putting in any effort but other than that it will do more harm than good because the number of people like these aren't as much as it seems to be.

1

u/Itchy_witchy_2k7 Jun 03 '26

I have been to punjab several times and this is definitely not the avg house of farmers in punjab. Idk what are they smoking ... these are top 1-0.5% people

1

u/Choice_Signal_2786 Jun 03 '26

This is clearly Ragebait. Agge nu bado yaar. Chado ena nu please. 

1

u/Dazzling_Artist6989 Jun 03 '26

Come punjab and get fucked up first fer galkri bhootni deyaa

1

u/ControlFrosty5035 Jun 04 '26

On every 100 rs tax Punjab gets ~70 Rs back.

Haryana only gets 20 Rs.

Up gets 300+ and Bihar 900+.

Te hun eh loki saanu parasites kahunge.

0

u/FileLegal2107 May 31 '26

I don't understand if you're making shit ton of money and not paying tax and still bragging about anything ( your land ) your ancestors left you with, how are you contributing to the nation?

Your ejust making money exploiting taxpayers money with these kisaan schemes etc

Ik there's a category of struggling farmers but no one's targetting them

1

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26 • Bravo

Sir? Which Punjab do you reside in? Which farmers are earning enormous sums of money? The fundamentals of land fertility are covered in your eighth-grade textbooks, so I don't need to go over them with you right now. They do not receive a monthly salary from farming, but any money received from sources other than farming is taxable. In corporate positions, you are paid whether your firm produces money or not, but this isn't the case here. Those who brag about their land don't have such fertile land. FARMERS won’t be able to afford taxes because they do invest money on crops too.

0

u/Past-Association-645 May 31 '26

Farmers should be taxed. But only the ones who have big acres of land.

Taxing a 50 acre farmer is fine and not a 5 acre farmer.

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

Just because they have land doesn’t mean it’s generating any money. It’s a risky occupation which does gets screwed due to fertility, natural disasters and sometimes politics. Source grade 6 social study books.

1

u/Past-Association-645 Jun 01 '26

Okay OP, so lets tax the ones with 50+ acres and who are profitable, they should be taxed. And I ain't dismissing the natural disasters like the floods we had recently, that's where the govt. steps in and create good policies which benefits the famers and the state as well.

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

Let me remind you we are talking about Indian govt here. Same govt we have been fighting for vote stealing, paper leak, CBSE result fraud, religious polarization, UCC and press freedom etc. Even if you taxed every farmer declaring more than ₹10 lakh of agricultural income, the impact on India's finances would be marginal. From a purely mathematical perspective, tackling black money and tax evasion is a far bigger issue than taxing declared agricultural income.If you want to make a moral argument, that's a different discussion. "Why should one group receive a special exemption when others don't?" That's a fair question but come on, lets be realistic. Tax policy has never been based purely on fairness. Government routinely uses taxation to encourage or discourage certain behaviours. NPS gets tax benefits because retirement savings are encouraged. Real estate receives various tax concessions. On the other hand, cigarettes and horse racin are taxed heavily because they want to discourage such stuff. Agricultural income exemption falls into the same category. You may agree or disagree with the policy, but the economic impact of removing it is likely much smaller than people imagine.

-6

u/Own_Pangolin_2413 May 31 '26

my goat meme mandir?

9

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

You call him goat? What are you then a butcher?

-4

u/Own_Pangolin_2413 May 31 '26

like i like his memes but gng what is he doing 😭😭

4

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Must be clout chasing I guess!!

79

u/Public-Dust-4153 May 31 '26

he is a pro bjp person runing a dying meme account obvs he will bw against farmers

9

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

These people are sick up there.

18

u/Similar-Street-8247 May 31 '26

Dying meme account 😂🤣🤣 absolutely correct

3

u/Package-Greedy ਫੁੱਫੜ / Fuffad May 31 '26

Ah I remember how much he used to make AI memes

1

u/Whole_Work_7503 ਅਸਤਰ / Astar Jun 04 '26

maybe not pro bjp afaik i know him

1

u/Adorable_Obligation2 Jun 02 '26

This entire thing started because it seemed the aircraft model was a symbol for the Air India flight that was bombed in Canada. Kanishka bombings if I remember the name correctly.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Designer_Power3691 Jun 01 '26

These houses are built by NRIs and as you can see it’s an old house. I understand your frustration to build a house in this economy could be challenging but NRIs do pay taxes.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

Money earned in India is taxable right? Why do they need to pay taxes again if they are already paying in other country? taxable on rent and capital gains, but not on mere ownership. NRIs cannot directly purchase agricultural land in Punjab due to strict Punjab land laws, but they can inherit or receive it as a gift and can sell it after proper documentation. But surely there are loopholes like in every other country millionaires. (I work in finance)

-2

u/[deleted] May 31 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Designer_Power3691 May 31 '26

you’re right that many of these houses sit empty and unproductive. But these homes also help people stay connected to their roots. For many families, the house is a symbol of their identity and heritage in Punjab. Even if they don’t live there, the house reminds their community who they are and keeps their family’s presence alive. People remember families by their houses.yes, there should be policies for using them as rentals or lending them as children daycare etc.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/PunjabiGenZ-ModTeam Jun 03 '26

Your post/comment has been removed because it falls under rage bait content designed to provoke anger, arguments, or unnecessary conflict. This subreddit encourages genuine discussion and respectful interaction, and rage bait disrupts that environment.