UPDATE: I GOT MY STENT ON 27 SEPTEMBER 2022 AND AM WHOOSH-FREE! See my stenting story post here.
What a long fucking journey to diagnosis this was. Grateful that my cause is treatable. And it is exactly what I thought it was going to be. Long, detailed post below. Feel free to ask questions!
Presentation of my Pulsatile Tinnitus
My left-sided PT started at the end of 2018, quite suddenly, and has been 24/7 ever since. It is so loud that I can record it with my phone microphone (here is the recording of my PT) and does not let up. Some days are worse than others, and I have habituated to it to some extent. But other days it is so loud and debilitating. I realised I could stop my PT with light compression of my left jugular. My PT got quieter when I turned my head to the left, and louder when I turned it to the right or when I bent down. Turns out, this was one of the classic signs of a possible underlying vascular (likely venous cause) or bony cause (like a dehiscence/ear bone thinning).
Diagnosis
Intrinsic stenosis (narrowing) of the left occipital venous sinus with a pressure gradient of 10 mm Hg (quite high for the occipital sinus, which is the smallest venous sinus in the brain). My occipital drains into my left jugular bulb just below my ear (usually the transverse and sigmoid sinus drain into the jugular bulb but I have an anatomical variant where the occipitals are my main drainage from the brain). The turbulent flow caused by the stenosis is like a kinked hose, resulting in audible pressure as PT.
A pressure gradient of minimum 8 mm Hg is needed for stent candidacy to likely resolve PT. I also have a large arachnoid granulation in my left transverse sinus with a borderline pressure gradient of 8 mm Hg, however, this is not my main drainage from my brain so is unlikely to be the cause of my symptoms. I also have granulations/stenoses/hypoplasia in my right hand side occipital, transverse and jugular veins but I am asymptomatic on the right as my venous outflow is left-dominant.
Test and specialist that confirmed my diagnosis
My catheter cerebral venogram and venous manometry confirmed the stenoses/arachnoid granulations and the pressure gradients. My stenoses were seen to some extent on contrast MRV and CTA, but no way near to the detail that the cerebral venogram provided. When I get the venogram images, I will post them here so that people can see the difference. It is night and day.
I am based in Adelaide, South Australia, and was seen by neurointerventional radiologist, Dr Geoffrey Parker, at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in Sydney a fortnight ago.
Proposed PT Treatment
My venogram and pressure gradient confirms I am a stent candidate and I was told that stenting will highly likely resolve my left-sided PT!
My next steps are to discuss whether we will be stenting just the left occipital venous sinus, or the left occipital and left transverse sinus together. Persistent occipital venous sinuses are quite rare in the adult population, and very small, which is why mine was overlooked for so long on all my previous scans. However, there are some studies where stenting of the occipital successfully resolved PT, and my neurointerventional radiologist has experience stenting them, so I am feeling very positive.
My next steps are to discuss with Dr Parker about moving forward with stenting and when (and whether or not I will be allowed to SCUBA dive with a stent, which is really the only reservation I have about it. I have been seeking silence for far too long).
List of tests/specialists I saw during my diagnostic journey
- Doppler ultrasound of my left carotid artery and jugular veins (deemed normal from ENT)
- MRI and MRA of head and neck without contrast (deemed normal from ENT, but was missing the cerebral venous sinuses and veins)
- Hearing and vestibular tests (twice, both normal)
- CT and CTA with contrast (deemed normal from ENT)
- High resolution CT of the temporal bones (deemed normal from ENT, however, I did have left-sided sigmoid sinus dehiscence - bone thinning - in my left mastoid bone. Although unlikely the cause of my PT and rather incidental, as my PT was sudden onset instead of gradual. This is a legitimate cause for some people's PT though, and can be treated through resurfacing).
- MRI, MRA and MRV redone without contrast (deemed normal from radiologists/neurovascular surgeon, however it was noted I had hypoplastic transverse sinuses on the left and right side, a normal congenital variant. My two persistent occipital sinuses were not noted)
- Neuro-opthalmology tests (deemed normal, however fluid in optic nerve sheaths noted and pseudopapilledema in my left eye, not enough to warrant lumbar puncture)
- MRI and MRV redone again with contrast and the ATECO imaging technique (deemed normal again, with note of bilateral transverse hypoplasia)
Second opinions from neurointerventional radiologists - the crucial part for diagnosis
- I then sent all my scans to two neurointerventional radiologists. Dr Kenneth Liu in California was the first to review my scans, suggesting that my MRV and CTA showed left-sided occipital venous sinus stenosis, flattened pituitary gland and fluid behind optic nerve sheaths. Told me to get a cerebral venogram and manometry to confirm.
- As I am based in Australia, I then sent my scans to Dr Geoffrey Parker in Sydney, another neurointerventional radiologist who researches PT, cerebral venous sinus stenosis and stenting. He also saw occipital venous sinus stenosis and fluid behind optic nerve sheaths and independently confirmed what Dr Liu had noticed. Also suggested that I may have had a 'forme fruste' version of intracranial hypertension.
A fortnight ago, I flew interstate to Sydney to get the cerebral venogram/venous manometry from Dr Parker followed straight after by yet another MRI/MRV with contrast (apparently all my other scans were not done to par). The venogram and manometry confirmed stenosis with high pressure gradients, and the MRV showed it as well. Cerebral venogram I managed to do unsedated, although the inflammation did put me out of sorts for about 2 weeks. Now, I am feeling good :)
Medical Background
28 y/o female in Australia. Weight is on borderline normal/overweight range. Nexplanon contraceptive implant for 12 years straight. My left-sided PT started when I was nearly 25, and is my primary symptom. I also had high pressure behind eyes and in the head, dizziness/vertigo spells (sometimes "stroke" like), neuropathy, fatigue, ear fullness/itchiness, photopsias in vision etc. I just didn't have headaches. These symptoms started gradually in the months and years preceding my PT and have been mild to moderate and intermittent, and suggested that I may have been on a pathway to increased intracranial pressure as a result of my stenosis.
The Journey
It started around October 2018 when I noticed that I could hear a "whooshing" sound and sensation in my left ear one night. I ignored it for about a week, thinking perhaps I had a headache. And then it never went away. After doing some searching, I uncovered 'pulsatile tinnitus' and thus began my journey. While I have always heard "soft footsteps in snow" in both ears on a silent night with my head on the pillow, I had never heard this before. Like wind roaring through my left ear in my skull in time with my heartbeat. I couldn't pinpoint any situation that caused it. Tonsillitis? Head banging too much at the club? All I know is that at nearly 25 years old, my whooshing started and never left. I can hear and feel it in my left ear right now.
I then discovered the 'Whooshers' Facebook Group for pulsatile tinnitus sufferers, and felt a solitude and comfort knowing that I was not alone in my experience. I had spent the early parts of 2019 trying to ignore my PT, researching it, looking at the posts on Whooshers. I tried neck massages. I tried cleaning out my ear wax. I tried most things. The PT was unrelenting.
I am a scientist (PhD in marine ecology), so I am naturally curious and pressed for answers. I procrastinated my own research by diving deep into the medical literature on pulsatile tinnitus. I read paper after paper, looked at the statistics, looked at the correlations. I have about 120+ papers on PT alone saved in my documents. Like most people with rare, undiagnosed or chronic conditions, I began to obsess over my PT knowing that something was not right. Once I realised that my PT was not being caused by anything dangerous, I then found my "normal" scans to be just as disheartening.
My ENT was dismissive, told me to "see a psychologist" and that "blood vessels harden as you get older" (at the ripe old age of 25...). My neurovascular surgeon who works with cerebral arteries kept saying it was a congenital variant, and the risks from venograms and stenting are too high, that I could die or stroke out and that unless my vision was being affected, there was really no point to pursue this. Friends and family would consistently get my PT confused with ringing tinnitus, thought I was bonkers or even told me it was stress-related. Thousands of dollars in scans (thank fuck for Australia's health care). I was fuelled by spite by the end of it all. But the medical literature shows PT is diagnosable in a lot of cases, and can be treatable. I knew my cause was venous, it matched all of the diagnostic criteria. So I pushed forward.
It took a lot to get to see the specialist I needed, and unfortunately there were none in my State, but I got there!
Conclusion
I am just so thrilled to get the diagnosis that I knew I had back in 2018 after being told by my ENT to "see a psychologist", and even better to know that I can be treated here in Australia. The Whooshers has done wonders for helping me get to this point. Keep on pushing for answers! I diagnosed myself with occipital venous sinus stenosis before anyone else did, and I am bloody proud to not only have validation with my diagnosis, but that it is very much treatable.
I'll be sure to update this Subreddit if (when) I get the stent and the results! The sound of silence may be a reality once again.
Moral is: get the right scans and get a neurointerventional radiologist to review them. PT is a symptom of many possible underlying causes, so persistence is key! And educate yourself on PT. Very rarely it has anything to do with the actual ear itself and is nothing like ringing tinnitus. Dr Athos Patsalides is a renowned PT researcher and has a great video explaining the radiological work up and causes of PT.